2023: Got the Hellfire Pizza 🍕 with a recommended beer. My girl got the pasta. I gotta say the Hellfire was 🔥, but at least for me The Good Spice. The movie they had on was also great. Shout out to the art gallery in the back!! I want that fox 🦊. Jan 2024 Edit: Went back for round 2. Hellfire pizza is still the goat. Pun indented. I found out they had draft beer. Last time I went it was dimly or it was extra sunny outside or maybe I have bad vision. Food and beer are great as always. Staff was great. They were playing Freddy vs Jason this time. Also my beloved fox has not been sold. Soon my creature.

The most unique pizza place I’ve ever been to for sure. Pizza was awesome, good beer selection. Would return and recommend!

Crust was burnt, I asked if it was up to their standards, bartender looked and said it was fine. The middle 2/3 of the pizza was mostly edible, the rest just shattered to the touch. I was charged a "covid gratuity" of 10% for a *pickup* order that was placed online and took 50+ minutes. Why would you add an automatic, unannounced surcharge when you know you're already giving *worse* service because you don't have enough employees? Either take responsibility or stop screwing me on the bill.

I wish we had a place like this here in the midwest similar to Kumas corner in Chicago. Most people eating here are dressed all in black and many people might turn around as they enter because it's a metal pizza joint. Really great feeling inside though and I felt welcomed. Selection if beer is awesome and food was pretty incredible. Seemed like coal fired pizza and had delicious toppings.

Love the brutal death metal playlists they have and all the fun decorations throughout the place. Ordered the belly of the beast pizza. Tasted amazing! Lots of unique drinks and beers tap. Wish the place was bigger! Hopefully this place can expand to a bigger venue!

Being up for pizza, I decide on eating at an eatery with Vegan pizza I remember checking a time ago on my way to eat elsewhere. The 4th Horseman is like a theme restaurant for Death (the fourth Horseman, Revelations 6:7–8). In the eatery, there is a table in front of a television that, during my visit, is playing a movie, Serial Mom (1994). I sit at the table to watch the movie with another patron while awaiting my order. I order a Vegan pizza, Frailty. If there are a lot of pizza orders, be ready to wait for about twenty minutes minimum. The Frailty Pizza (😅) has ingredients with distinct flavors of which the most distinct and noticeable are the Kalamata Olives (the ingredient with the most potent flavor), the Vegan Italian Sausage Crumbles (the ingredient with the second most potent flavor which I think tastes better colder than hot, Vegan meat can taste very different by brand, I wonder how meat of a different brand might taste on the Frailty pizza), and the Cherry Tomatoes (the third ingredient with the most potent flavor like thin warm pulpless V8, in a good way). I like the crust and dough: the crisp is the way I like with this kind of crustful thin pizza (though not with a kind of Sicilian pizza, for example); not too hard, not too soft, with a bit of crunch. Even so, if an offering for a dipping sauce is available, I think it may be a good addition because the crust is good though dries my mouth, and the crust is a sizable portion of the overall pizza. Now, the pizza tastes quite different cold— personally, I think better; the flavors of all ingredients seem more present in my mouth altogether when the pizza is colder than warm. In my experience, customer service is good: employees communicate/are open to communicate throughout the ordering process i.e. by telling if a plate or so is on its way, answering a question about pizza preparation—along those lines.

What the duck!? If you’re a spooky lover and horror enthusiast that loves a good slice and beer this is the spot for you. The (thin) slices are piping hot, huge and cheesy. The drinks are beer, not a full bar but helps get the food and drinks out faster. The space is fairly big and has seat in/dine in options but you do order through your phone so make sure to bring it with you. The coolest part was the dark art studio in the back.

Really great, unique takes on specialty pizza, with something for everyone from vegans to the bloodthirsty. They even offer a (shudder) vegan gluten free crust if that's your thing. Excellent drink selection and an atmosphere I dig- although be forewarned, they only play metal and they play it pretty loud. If you don't like that, feel free to sit outside. Always eat too fast for pictures, so here's one from the bathroom.

I've been a coming to The 4th Horseman since they first opened their doors. I have always been a fan of their amazing pizza, and wide selection of craft beers. I've seen them grow, adding the DAE and becoming a staple of Pine Avenue. I have yet to find a pizzeria that tops the atmosphere, fun, creativity, and deliciousness of The 4th Horseman and I get excited each time I go in. From the cheesy horror films, to the amazing, attentive staff. I have never had a bad experience here and will always recommend it to friends who want a good slice of pie.

Very cool spot. Not your typical restaurant. Not your typical customers. Go here for: Good pizza including lots of vegan options Beer Typically loud metal music or the loud volume of a Sci fi movie Multiple Sci-fi movies playing within the place Interesting and dark art all over the walls Supportive of the LGBTQ+ community All-in-all, one of my favorite spots in Long Beach. You definitely need to check it out.

Great pizza, one of the best in Long Beach. Options for basics, meat eaters and vegans. Good beer selection too. Amazing atmosphere. Fans of horror and metal/hard-core music will enjoy. New hours suck! No more lunchtime pizza. Bummed.

This place is SO great! The pizza is delicious and they always have a fun variety of items on their menu. Good beer and wine, I love the blackberry lemon sangria. Horror movies on the TVs and great variety of music dealing a little heavier on the Metal side, of course. Indoor and outdoor seating, 21 and up. The vibe is not for the faint of heart. 💀🖤☻️

I picked up a pizza. It was pretty good I would order pizza here again. They have a lot of variety. I didn’t realize it was also a whole bar until I picked up my pizza and went inside. It’s dark inside kinda like a small dive bar feel. Overall OK experience. I’ll have to come back and eat there and have a drink next time.

Huge DANK pizza. Unique DARK ambiance. Hardcore ROCK music playing in the background. They also had black metal Santa Claus you can take a pic with as he’s sitting on his throne. They had the scary movie Chucky playing on the big screen lol. 5/5 stars ⭐️

This place closes at 10pm I have been calling and trying to place an order since 7:30pm-8:30pm no answer(I was working but still trying to place an order). I even went online and it said they are not taking online orders. So I drive down leaving at 8:45, getting there at 9:10, and am told that they are no longer making whole pizzas. The cashier was very sweet and tried to explain that they were short staffed, but their policy to not answer the phone or online orders when they are busy is unprofessional. They should treat all customers, regardless if they are in store or online, with respect. Having to drive down there wasted my time and gas. In response to your unprofessional comment, I didn’t say she disrespected me if you could read or comprehend anything that’s not your own ego you would understand that the policy disrespects its online and over the phone customers by deliberately ignoring them. And No, I don’t need a horrible manager like you or your pizza to keep my hands too sticky to write this honest review. You’re telling me what to order as if a slice isn’t completely different than a whole pizza. I wanted a whole pizza that was vegan, smh. You had an opportunity to step up and speak to me but you didn’t another example of disrespectful customer service, and you telling me I’m the one who never worked in customer service. I need to ask you that same question.

Loved the place. I got the really spicy pizza and I loved it. My friends were punks and they couldnt handle the spicyness so I had to finish the pie on my own. The drinks were strong. Would go again.

Pizza was delicious 🤤 I’m from Buffalo NY and I think their pizza is quite good. I really liked the vibe. Definitely great to take your fellow rollers.

Great pizza, beer selection, and atmosphere. What more do you need to know? Well, I guess if you aren't a fan of horror movies and/or metal, then you might want to make it a togo. Otherwise, just sit back enjoy the music while you dine on some delicious over the top pizzas while throwing down a craft beer of your choice. Definitely will be in again when I'm in Long Beach.

Interesting Pizza bar with an atmosphere that fancy the macabre. The pizza was alright as it was heavily sauced and cheesed (which is fine) as well as there was a good variety of pizza topping choices to choose from. Be aware, the pizza is top heavy so your cheese can easily slide off as you pick it up. There is also an art store towards the restroom if you're into taxidermy and other macabre pieces.

Small place yet big, if that makes sense. It was a busy night so it was hard to find seating and when there was one available it was left dirty but not the staffs fault. We eventually got a table. Pizza was delicious we got the jalapeño popper one, only thing is I would have liked it to have more white sauce but that's ok I'll ask for extra next time. Overall a cool place with good food and good beer selection. I went with a dead guy beer and definitely always a good choice

Incredible vibes/atmosphere, staff is polite and service was quick. I had the Death to Piggy pizza and it's some of the best pizza I've ever had. It's a must try restaurant.

Grungy vibes but clean. Pizza was delicious and service was excellent. Decent selection of draft beers and a huge variety of cans to choose from. Will definitely come again.

I was anxious to try this pizza, because of all the recommendations on Facebook. The ingredients were good but did not seem to blend well. My wife thought it was over spiced, too much red pepper, not enough the other spices.

Awesome bar, enjoyable art on walls and rocker/metal music. Havnt tried the pizza but im coming for it next time!

The pizza here is amazing the dough is always on point and the ingredients always taste fresh I've never bought pizza here that didn't taste fresh. It's also a cool spot if you want to eat there and grab a drink they have really good beers and the overall decor is something different.