This was my first time trying Wick's Pizza and I have to say its Absolutely Delicious!!!! I highly recommend it!

My wife and I have been eating here for years and tonight was the worst pizza I have ever had. I called in for a carryout order. When I went to pick it up I checked the order and the pizza looked overcooked. I asked the person at the counter if it looked a little toasty she just sniffed and laughed. I asked about having it remade she said sure it will be about 45 min. I asked why would they send something like that out she said that the pizza is to standard I explained that I have never had one look like that she said if I did not want it cooked that much I was supposed to tell them not to cook it all the way. I needed to eat something to take my meds and took it even though the crust was too hard to eat along with the burnt cheese. If this is there "standard" now it has greatly gone downhill. This was at the Baxter location Saturday night 8 Oct 2022 time approx 630 pm. The person that I was talking to about this was very short and condescending I asked to speak to the manger she patted her chest and said I am the manger Update someone did reach out to me about my experience however after trying to contact them back several times they were either unstable or not in

We were sat immediately and greeted by the most charismatic waitress I have ever met in my life! Found out later her name was Cara (I hope I didn’t spell that wrong) I wish everywhere we went had people like her! She literally made our night. We drove 3+ hours just to get pizza at wick’s. No lie. She was such a pleasant bonus. This place has the best pizza I have ever eaten, but Cara made it an extra awesome experience this time. Highly recommend! And if you can request a waitress look for Cara! She will make your night. 💕

Only a few good places to go in louisville for great quality pizza! Wicks never disappoints!

We came from Frankfort mostly because they offer classic steak sandwich/hoagie. Food was top quality and everything was delicious. I'm picky about pizza sauce and crust. Getting quality and quantity for our money is important. Everything about our experience was excellent. Cara took fabulous care of us we'll will be going again and hoping she'll be there.

Love this place but you pay for what you get. Thick delicious one of a kind pizza!

We ordered "The Boss Favorite", cracker thin crust, your choice of three toppings. Excellent, we will return before we leave town..We went back for 14" The Mighty Meaty Wick" added some jalapeño peppers and the rest is history. Superb pizza..

It was nice experience. I was there with friends for Pizza Week. We had the Cheeseburger pizza. It wasn't too bad. I enjoyed it. It would taste better with lettuce, tomato, and bacon to make to more delicious. BUT since it is pizza week, it is more reasonable for the price. I will like to come back and try few mores.

Had our teenage daughter's birthday party in their back room. They were extremely accommodating, so sweet. Such a cool local establishment.

Wicks is worth the trip from Frankfort when we are wanting something special. Our favorite meals are the mighty wick, the wings and the best steak sandwich( I call it a steak hoagie) around. Wicks original pizza sauce is the best. And our favorite of the two restaurants is the original. If you like more of a sports bar vibe, then the newest place is for you. And a big shout out to Cara. We only get up there about once or twice a month, but she always remembers us and takes time to actually have great conversations with us.

Overall a good experience at Wick's. Pizza itself was great, I ordered the Sicilian and was very impressed. The crust was crispy on the outside but light and chewy on the inside, cheese had a lovely char to it without tasting burnt and a very appetizing pull when cut. The pepperoni also had a delicious char flavor though it was maybe slightly overcooked. The sauce was very tasty, a rich tomato sauce with a strong yet not overbearing presence in the overall taste. Definitely a well made pie. Atmosphere was a very casual, dimly lit pizza bar. Music choices were appropriate and the smell was amazing. Service was okay, not fantastic but nothing that detracted from the experience. Would definitely recommend if you are in the area.

We walked here on a weekend night. We got pizza and some entrees. We didn't have to be seated, but it took forever for someone to take our order and serve us. The food turned out really well. This place is huge. It's a bar and pizza place. The restroom is okay in terms of cleanliness.

We had an excellent server who went above and beyond to see that we were happy. Food was amazing. Andrea Knabel is a missing person and the server took our poster of her and hung it on the door at the entrance. We are forever grateful.

Order a Fajita sandwhich. Hardly anything in the bread. Wife had a better sandwhich. But mine was so sad I had to put a review. Also, can not even get a order of fries to go with sandwhich. Instead you get tiny bag of chips.. Recommend: Get Pizza (pricey). 9 FEB -3:30PM

It's rare for me to meet a pizza I don't like but I crave wicks like an addiction. The atmosphere is like a grunge bar, a college place, somewhere to get a good drink and chill with friends. I haven't had much of their other food, just the pizza and it's never disappointed. For me I think it's the pizza dough, it's unique. I'm not a big fan of their sauce by itself but it pairs perfect once it's all together. They're selection of pizza is standard with a few flares. Totally worth the 3 hour drive, everytime and it makes good leftovers.

They catered my wedding and did an AMAZING job! Everything ran so smoothly. They setup, cleaned up, took trash out, and boxed up the food. They were so friendly and attentive, that night and throughout the entire process. I absolutely recommend this business for your event and catering needs.

Food was wonderful as always! Excellent service 1000%! As a former waitress, I know how it is to get a large group coming in at once- our server Kayla was very patient and accommodating to my group. We came in with mixed emotions from leaving a funeral service. Kayla was very friendly and made our day better on HER BIRTHDAY! Of course we celebrated her birthday and hopefully everyone left her a wonderful tip. Kayla deserves employee of the month & to be off work on her next birthday😉

I’ve been buying pizzas from Wick’s for about nine years now. The Sicilian has been by consistent favorite from their menu. Tonight for takeout I experienced friendly staff and a great pizza. And the ingredients are always super tasty, hot, and FRESH. They are generous with the toppings. Perfect comfort food. Highly recommend.

Dropped in for pizza week and was pleasantly surprised. Cheeseburger pizza was delicious and loved the pasta deal. Definitely will be returning.

I travel through Louisville fairly frequently, and I've made it a ritual to stop at Wick's. It's a little out of the way, but it's totally worth it. Pizza is my favorite food, so I eat an unhealthy amount of pizza. Wick's is some of the best I've had. I honestly think the crust is the best of any pizza place. I would also recommend the cinnamon sticks. Honestly, though, everything is good. They also have a pretty decent whiskey selection. If you're ever in the area, give this place a shot!

Wick's has, pretty consistently, always had decent pizza. The new pizza menu items are really good. I'm disappointed at their appetizers, but that isn't the reason we go there. The bartenders must have had a bad day, because they put regular coke in a Captain Morgan's and ginger ale--three times! That was really disappointing. Our server was a sweetheart and really helpful. Thankfully they weren't super busy.

The staff at this location is wonderful. I have been going to Wick's since I moved to Louisville. My go to place for Pizza. Their Spinach Alfredo, Grilled Fajita Chicken, Wick's Bacon Chicken Ranch and Mexican pizzas are amazing. The chicken on the pizzas is super well seasoned, juicy and tender. Thick, but perfectly cooked crust. Cheese bread is a great app!

Everything was wonderful. Christy was so nice. Very Knowledgeable about the products. Customer service was great.

Was my first time there and I really enjoyed the whole experience! Great food. Service and atmosphere.

Extremely delicious pizza! My Server was the best server I have had in 6years He was on point every Second! Great atmosphere! Music was great as well Look it was like this GOOD Pizza,wings,music, and amazing Server what more could one person ask for but it was 6 of us

First and foremost I have too say finding a pizza in which the cheese is melted perfectly is very hard too do especially now a days and growing up in the East hometown Newark NJ pizza is what surrounded me. I picked up a 18in pizza and wanted a nice triangle sliced traditional pizza didnt think wicks had it but they do. No disrespect to those square sliced lovers but to me a real pizza has to be in the traditional triangle shape. The cheese melted and was stringy upon moving apart this melted my heart and reminded me of the good Ole days growing up before the squares, and Trans fat nutrients changed America lol. I give it 5 stars and recommend to all and shall eat here more often with my friends and family the sauce did not give me a sudden attack of heart burn it was solely perfect with every munch tasted very very light and good. Please try it out. Ps thanks to one of wicks employees for guiding me to my new found triangle sliced pie 😌☺