I have been here 2 times, when I’ve been in the area. I’m gluten and dairy free, so wasn’t sure what I would find that I could eat, but they have gluten-free pizza crust. Today I did a make-your-own pizza without the cheese and added old world sausage, black olives, and spinach. It was amazing! Everything I got last visit was delicious as well. I would definitely come back again. Highly recommend.

I visited Sandusky for work and when I’m out of town I love to try a local pizza place. I scoured Google for food near me and came across this place and the reviews were good so I tried them. All I had was a pepperoni deep dish pizza and it was not good. No flavor whatsoever; it just tasted like cheese on thick bread. Sauce was nonexistent and bland. I ended up going to McDonald’s. But the girl on the phone and my delivery driver was great! I’m glad I can expense this meal through work and get my money back!

Newly remodeled. We got here right after the nightly rush, so it was quiet. We ordered salad pizza, a calzone, and spaghetti. They didn't get the salad out before the pizza which a little upsetting, but the salad was tasty. My daughter got a gluten-free pizza, which she enjoyed. My other daughter did loke the meatball but was not thrilled with the spaghetti. The sauce didn't have much flavor. We got a large pizza with some meat and mild peppers. I love how the pizza is cut in little pieces and not slices. The pizza was delicious My wife loved her Calzone. She added green peppers and onions to hers. The crust was just the right amount of crispy and soft. Draft beer selection was okay. Our waitress was great.

5 out of 10 of My chicken wings had broken bones. Had to pick out the bone shards to even try to eat. The sauce was great. Got the cheeseburger pizza and it was nasty. So much ketchup mayo and mustard I couldn't even eat it all. Way to much lettuce also. My co worker got chicken parm and he said it was pretty good.

Wow! Great food! Generous helping!! Our waitress Sam was exceptionally attentive! Definitely going back !! Thanks Jim's Pizza Box!!

Awesome little pizza place in a small town. Great service and a beautiful dining area made for a wonderful experience. Their pizza is a little but thicker than I prefer but it was delicious nonetheless. Will be back when visiting CP!

We were in town for a softball tournament at the beginning of August & had Jim's delivered to the hotel. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, boneless wings, and the homemade sauerkraut balls. Everything was incredibly awesome! The lady on the phone was polite & the delivery driver brought the food right to the pool. Hope to have this again in the future. Kudos to Jim's!

We ate this nice restaurant one evening and enjoyed it. Great service and really good drinks. Beat Manhattan’s ever. Had great anti-pasta salad and meatball sub. Excellent. Nice dining area outside.

Half and half Hawaiian & BBQ chicken. Garlic butter for service!! It was very good.

You would think growing up with Chicago style pizza that we would know what good pizza tastes like. Boy oh boy, this is hands down the best pizza we have ever tasted in our lives. So incredibly fresh. The crust is the best we have ever ! Kudos to you all!

We ordered a deep dish pizza and it was absolutely amazing!!! Best pizza I've had in a long time!! The delivery driver was super friendly and courteous!!!!

Driving from Chicago to Pennsylvania and this place is so close to the service stop that only has fast food trash. It was so worth going to. The server was extremely nice. The buffalo wings were really good, sometimes places overcook them and they are dry and chewy. These were moist and crispy and not too hot. The pizza was good not too greasy. My daughter was so thankful that we didn't eat at the rest stop. Not expensive at all either.

Jim's Pizza Box is a staple in this area. Jim's homemade sauce and various Italian and American food items are of top quality. I have NEVER had a bad meal. The service that you receive is way above average. With the installation of the bar and now pasta every day has made Jim's Pizza Box a restaurant for all ages and those that want more than just Pizza. I cannot say enough great comments about this treasure of a place.🥰❤️

We took our kids, grandchildren, my sister and her family, and some friends to Jim's last night for dinner after our mom's memorial. I had called ahead to make sure that they could seat 15-20 and when we got there, the table was set up with reserved signs all ready for us but our group had grown to 23. That was no problem at all for the great people at Jim's and they pulled more tables and chairs over and happily accommodated the larger group. Everyone there was fantastic and the food came out quickly and was awesome just like it has been since I started eating there over 40 years ago. I want to say a big Thank You to Jim and all the great people that work there! Keep up the great food, service, and atmosphere!

Best food I ever ate and Abby was a great waitress that gave great customer service. 10 stars definitely from me and I will be going back for sure this weekend and every weekend up until end of October!! Very tasty food and great atmosphere and customer service!!

After years of not eating here, I decided to give the restaurant another chance! I spent $7 on a salad that had ONE slice of cucumber and ONE slice of tomato. Portion sizes on everything was very tiny. And my husbands stomach hurt for hours after eating the pork and beef fries. He did say the calzone crust was really good, this is why I'm giving 2 stars. All in all, over priced for greedy portions.

Really hit the spot. Stopped in off the highway and needed a pit stop. Pizza was amazing. Great crust, good cheese, and not too much sauce. I had the sausage and red pepper. Amazing. The reviews were right, highly recommended. Really friendly staff, too.

Love this place. We live 3 hours away and will generally go out of our way to eat here when traveling. Great food, staff, atmosphere and prices.

Atmosphere unknown, as we had our food delivered.We are passing through the state on our way home to Wisconsin. We found this locally owned spot and decided to order. We were NOT disappointed!! Delivery was super fast and everything was hot and delicious!! 10 out of 10 for us. Highly recommend! We will be back next time we come through! Thank you Jim's pizza box!! Wasn't an option below, baked spaghetti is amazing. R.M.

Wow big surprise! It was great, I took my servers suggestion and did a buffalo wing calzone and it was awesome. I'll be going out of my way to go back for a more traditional pizza but I was impressed the entire time.