Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Flinders Lane

It's 00:05 right now, with clear sky and the temperature of 10.01°C (50.018°F) in Melbourne.

Sal's Authentic New York Pizza - Flinders Lane - Restaurant in Melbourne, Australia


Open on Google Maps

🏆 Trophies

This place has not received any awards...


289 Flinders Ln, Melbourne VIC 3000, Australia


Rating on Google Maps

4.60 (346 reviews)

Working Hours

  • Tuesday: 11:30AM to 10PM
  • Wednesday: 11:30AM to 10PM
  • Thursday: 11:30AM to 10PM
  • Friday: 11:30AM to 1AM
  • Saturday: 12PM to 1AM
  • Sunday: 12 to 10PM
  • Monday: 11:30AM to 10PM


  • 5sahirchamp v. 1 year ago
    Delicious! Good SERVICE!

  • 5Alastair V. 10 months ago

  • 5Matthew W. 10 months ago
    This is as close to a true New York pizza as you will get in Melbourne the best!

  • 5Linkin L. 11 months ago
    One of the best American style pizzas in melbourne. Cheese is super stringy and their flavours taste quiet authentic. Highly recommend grabbing a slice whenever you get the chance to be in the area.

  • 5Chris W. 11 months ago
    Awesome authentic NY pizza

  • 5Imogen O. 1 year ago
    Gluten free pizza was by far the best I have ever had! And I am one picky pizza girl! Gluten free pasta was also delicious!

  • 5Eve D. 1 year ago
    I can't travel now so I love coming to Sal's to remind me of travelling in New York it's so authentic! Make sure to grab one of their lunch deals it's fantastic value

  • 5Sally C. 1 year ago
    Yum! We went for the half and half (half cheese half pepperoni) and let me tell you it was everything I wanted it to be. The pizza was soooo goooood. Each slice was huge! Thank you for the fast and efficient delivery.

  • 5Casper T. 1 year ago
    My most favourite pizza place in the CBD. The buffalo wings are insanely good. Must try!

  • 5D. 11 months ago
    Good pizza. Simple as that! Grab it by the slice or as a whole. Would go back

  • 5lee m. 1 year ago
    Probably one of the best pizzas I’ve had in a long time! Meatball half pizza, garlic knots! Friend got the buffalo chicken, he did not complain. Friendly staff, helped with recommendations.

  • 5Jesse I. 1 year ago
    Best pizza in Melbourne

  • 5Luke L. 1 year ago
    Authentic as it get and so glad it came to Melbourne ❤

  • 5Courtney R. 1 year ago
    Best pizza by the slice in Aus ?

  • 5Brian S. 1 year ago
    OMG. Real NY pizza crust in Melbourne. Reminded me of home. Thanks Sal!

  • 5Claude C. 1 year ago
    Cracking New York Slice.The Fire Island is well on point. open late, so perfect after a few beers or late meetings. Quick, Cheap and filling.

  • 5Darragh B. 1 year ago
    The pizza here is absolutely delicious!! Can't stress enough. The staff were very accommodating and helpful. Keep up the good work guys

  • 5Laura R. 1 year ago
    We got half a pizza and the pound of wings for two people, which was the right amount of food for us. The wings (we got the original sauce) were fantastic, crispy and wet from the sauce.

  • 5Kino M. 10 months ago
    Epic NYC style Pizza

  • 5Melon T. 11 months ago
    Super friendly staffs. Cheessy pizza?. My favorite one is Buffalo.

  • 5Lilly M. 9 months ago
    The pizza available at Sal's Flinders Lane brings you the same happiness as running around in a field filled with puppies. 10/10.

  • 5Sandhya T. 8 months ago
    The best pizza in Melbourne with amazing staff.

  • 5Matthew B. 1 year ago
    Delicious pizza, the pepperoni wraps were fantastic. Very close to what NY pizza is like. Buffalo chicken could have been a touch hotter but that’s just being picky ??

  • 5Natan M. 1 year ago
    Ahhh!! Finally a good old fashioned NY slice! If you ever want to have good pizza then this is the place!! Look no further.. this is the holy grail of pizza and the service is awesome! You can’t go wrong when you go to Sal’s :-)

  • 5Daniel T. 1 year ago
    Noting late night New York style pizza at Sal's. My personal favourite is the Buffalo and the Brooklyn. The Buffalo is very creamy and flavourful while the Brooklyn is very meaty and savoury.

  • 5Andrew M. 9 months ago
    Not too many NYC style slices around Melbourne, always a treat coming here.

  • 5ash h. 9 months ago
    Best pizza South of the Equator..!

  • 5Matthew M. 1 year ago
    Just got back from a day in the city and Sal's pizza was definitely the highlight. New York Pizza, which is large thin base with just the right amount of toppings and premium ingredients. I was lucky enough to have received a free pie from a promotion and we put it towards a Pepperoni full pie and half Cheese pie. You can fold the slice which is the New York way and they both tasted great. Definitely something that Melbourne was well overdue in getting.

  • 5Abhishek R. 9 months ago
    Had a great pizza at this nice little pizza joint! Got into a long conversation with the store manager (I think his name was Buck?). He was a really nice guy and helped me decide what pizza was best for me. This was before the lockdown of course but I seriously recommend this place! Terrific pizza and terrific service!

  • 5Andrea J. 10 months ago
    Yummo, Garlic is my fav..

  • 4James C. 1 year ago
    Feels like New York New York

  • 4Stephanie S. 8 months ago
    One of the best New York style pizzas I have tasted in Melbourne. Good place to stop for a quick slice in the city.

  • 3A. 1 year ago
    Pizza is nice but nothing special, good for a late night stop after a few beers.

  • 3Dallas M. 1 year ago
    Average pizzas and no restroom.

  • 3big F. 10 months ago
    Sorry guys pizza in NYC is very different to here

  • 3Devon D. 1 year ago
    Was expecting more from the reviews. I get the vibe from reading other reviews melbourne doesnt have great pizza so I think some people's views on this place are skewed a bit ...I dont know pretty standard pizza to my north american palette. Pretty expensive for amount of toppings you get too. Dont get me wrong...its pizza..its delicious just when your creeping in on 5 stars on google reviews you should be a game changer. Staff very nice tho!

  • 2Shane O. 1 year ago
    Amazing pizzas if they arrive in one piece. In my experience that's 1/3 of the time.

  • 2Ty A. 1 year ago
    Came for the good reviews but the "deep fryers are broken" so no wings, and they ran out of sausage for a full Brooklyn pizza so we had a half. This is on a wednesday afternoon before 5pm. Pizza was average, very junk foody. Staff were nice though.

  • 1Kevin C. 10 months ago
    ordered pepperoni and meatball via uber eats with a side of buffalo wings. Both pizza dough not cooked properly and i would expect just as much taste from the cardboard box. Buffalo wings the opposite and very tasty. Family felt ill/bloated after eating. Not what i expected as it was highly recommended. Disappointing given the disappointed as they expected a true new york experience.

  • 1your dear old Uncle J. 11 months ago
    I will start off by saying if there was a lower possible score I would award it to them. There pizza sauce was very bitter in flavour taste was dripping in oil the garlic knot were burnt. First and last time to try new York style pizza thanks sals

  • 1m. 9 months ago
    Ordered two Nonna pizza’s which is just cheese and sauce the entire pizza didn’t even contain enough cheese for one slice. I tried calling through to give them feedback instead of leaving a review, but the girl answering the phone was only interested in speaking over the top of me to direct me here to write a review. Good luck staying open through these times mates. You’re having a laugh. Lucky this won’t allow me to post a photo bc I’d be laughing.

  • 1Daud i. 1 year ago
    Unprofessional staff.

  • 1Daniel S. 10 months ago
    Service is appalling. Unfriendly, first of all, and apart from waiting around 40 minutes for 1 pizza to eat-in, we were left to desperately catch a table to eat on as there is barely any seating inside. While on the brink of takeaway until we got a table, we were served our pizza in a box with no offer to put it on a tray (like everyone else at their table) until we complained. I can see dogfights ensuring over a table as the staff's answer to this is simply saying seating is not their problem...because they did. Even though it's their store. I can vouch for the pizza toppings but crust is far from any flavour and texture. Just support your local pizzeria rather than this unauthentic excuse of a restaurant.

Last updated: 2020-08-25