I went in with high hopes ...but when I received my mushroom pizza I was hella disappointed 😔. Looks like they went out back and picked 🍄, threw it on the pizza and called it good. Not sure how the person who pulled it out the oven even thought that was okay to serve. Had the nerve to half melt some cheese to keep those dry a$$ uncooked mushrooms in place 😂.

I got a Calzone with Ham and GF got a Pasta Dinner. The food was hot, fresh and delicious. The staff were extremely pleasant and very friendly.

We devoured a pizza and garlic knots. Our only complaint is that we didn't order more knots! This pizza was great.

Cooperstown-Being local, we often order a couple large pizza’s to go. Always ready on time, delicious, and everyone likes them. Service is also always good. Consistently a great place for pizza, and probably other foods as well

We ordered from NY Pizzeria as we had previously gotten take out from them when passing through Cooperstown. The pizza is always quality, the wings were top notch: large, meaty, well cooked. The antipasto was smaller than I expected as the description for the family special just said antipasto ans I expected it to be a large one for a family. The only issue I had was with the service. I placed my order online for 6:20. I arrived, based on reviews, later at 6:31. I was told it was "almost ready." We waited in the dining area. At 6:51 I returned to the counter to inquire about my order. The cashier was cutting a pizza that was at the bottom of the stack when I walked up. The other cashier retrieved my salad and wings and it was brought to the counter. Clearly it was done earlier and no one let is know. There was also supposed to be forks, plates and napkins included but there were not.

Clearly a busy day! They are quick at taking the orders! Affordable pricing! Fast service!! I ordered a Small Buffalo Wing Pizza !! Most importantly it was delicious 😋!!🍕

Last year we discovered this place and we made sure to stop again this year. During our visit to Cooperstown, we must have eaten here 3 times!! The pizza and wings are soo good! A must stop! We dined inside, outside (weather was perfect) and we did take out.

This place hit the spot after a long morning on the baseball field. I would highly recommend it! The food was excellent.

My son loves the pizza! The wings, although too big for my liking, were cooked perfectly! I highly recommend the garlic parmesean! Outstanding!!!

Diligent and friendly staff with fantastic pizza. I grabbed a couple of slices for lunch. They had my favorite crust; a nice crunch into a warm, soft center. Also, they didn't skimp on the cheese or toppings. Great pizza, you won't be disappointed.

Food was good. Pizza was a little greasy but not bad. Dough and sauce were good. Garlic knots were also good

Been going here since a kid. Pizza and wings are so good. They are very consistent and fair pricing. I have eaten many things they offer and everything seems to be good. Plenty of room for dinning in. Would recommend to anyone.

We’re in town, visiting. Fridays are pizza days. We decided on New York Pizzeria. It was AMAZING! My son is picky about his pizza and he LOVED this! The pizza was some of the best I’ve ever had. The staff was super friendly and so helpful. If we ever come back, we’ll definitely eat here again!!