Convenient location, but overpriced in relation to quality (a medium shake costs as much as a whole pint of Häagen Dazs). Though Fudgy’s is surrounded by local creameries, the ice cream is Perry’s, sourced from Pennsylvania. Around twenty different flavors, served hard, soft and milk-shaked. Napkins issued only upon request. Staff all young trainees. One saving grace is that Fudgy’s contributed to events at the local school, so that civic engagement is appreciated. Gravelled parking lot deeply pitted, so be careful when entering and exiting. There are two picnic tables for those who prefer not to drip melting ice cream into their laps in the car.

Ice cream is delicious. I had two scoops of Peanut S’mores and my friend had one scoop Peanut s’mores and one scoop pistachio. Staff was friendly.

I can describe this place in 2 words: extremely pleasing. The staff were super friendly and the ice cream was filled to the top! They were not stingy with their sizes and made sure we got our money worth! I had a Small Lemon Sorbet. Highly recommend.

The ice cream (especially the soft serve) is amazing! But depending on the hour you arrive, be prepared to wait a bit, and also know that there is limited parking available. But the lines do move very quickly so I encourage you to try some of the best soft serve in the area!

An institution in Eastern Dutchess County. Between the hard, soft and gluten free selections, there's something for every ice cream lover. Friendly servers and amazing value make thus spot a go to! You won't be disappointed!

Best ice cream spot! I always come here prior to going back to the city and it never disappoints.

Nice place. Cash only. A little overpriced but still nice. There are lot of flavors to choose from, even more than in the picture. I got Perry' Ice Cream banana cream pie in a waffle cone. If you want to sit, there are tables to the right of the building. Lots of parking in the front. Not to far from the Harlem Valley Rail Trail.

Great unique ice cream selection. It was so good! Banananna split recommended!