Pizza crust was very overcooked. Second time trying them . Will be the last. I’m sure Millville has a better pizza place.

They completely are disgusting in their the guy makes the pizzas wipes his sweaty face an then proceeds to play in the cheese an then sitting next to it is a 5 gallon bucket sauce sitting next to it covered in flies I also couldn't help but notice a heavy set an a older gentleman stuffing their faces as they prepared food I didn't eat the food I ordered an I would never eat thier

The Only Pizza That Is Good In The Entire Vineland . Is “Lucas Pizza Located Inside Cumberland Mall” they are from brooklyn . S&J pizza uses the most cheapest Cheese and lets not go with the sauce .. super sweet . Almost ketchup . This is not pizza !!!! Undercooked cheese . Just plain disgusting 🤮

First time ordering from here got 25 piece wings and extra large pizza..it was all amazing,pizza was good and flavorful..wings banging..Garlic parm..

Located right in the middle of the hood. Pizza not too bad. If you have a good life insurance policy, and don't worry about possibly getting stabbed or shot then try it out. If you are a thrill seeker and or like to try something dangerous and later brag about it, then go on over there and try the pizza. Just watch your back when you exit the store, you never know if you'll be propositioned or asked if you want to buy a dime bag or other style drugs.

🔥 🔥 🔥 this pizza is amaaaaaaaazing and so are their cheese fries I have nothing but good things to say about them.

Bad customer service! I walked in on a recent weeknight around 5pm. I was greeted by a woman who came from the back. I told them i needed a large pie with pepperoni and extra cheese. She warned me that it will be at least an hour. That was ridiculous, i told her i would pass, she seemed like she could care less. i left and will never return.

BEST PIZZA IN MILLVILLE. Ordering process was smooth. Pizza was ready when restaurant stated. Staff was friendly. Pizza quality was excellent. Having had a few other pizza options in Millville, this is hands down the best place.

We love S & J! We have been getting pizza here for 25 years! They have best tasting pizza in our area!

Cheese was very clumpy , unevenly distributed. Almost too cheesy, I could not stay out the bathroom the next day. I would not recommend them as your go to spot if your looking for actual good pizza

Best pizza I have had since I moved to New Jersey 😊

I just ordered a cheese steak platter came to $12.60 over the phone,.. so I decided to order a soda. Not only didn't I get my soda but the $12.60 some how turned to $20.60! Oooh not to mention my order was in deed not correct! I said salt n pepper not salt n peppers!! 🤬🤬🤬🤬🤬

Great pizza with a unique recipe and tangy and sweet sauce. You have to eat it while it’s hot to really enjoy it at its best.

The pizza is fantastic! It always has been. Their unique ways and flavors are famous. It's a real deal pizzaria so not much to say about the atmosphere. You can eat in but trust me, people don't come here the "ambiance" they come here for the delicious food. And they keep coming back.

Some of the best pizza I ever had. Will be back again.

I just tried to order a 12 of a party tray (listed on the menu) and was told they only have WHOLE party trays. LOL-- if you have the whole tray I'm guessing you have 2 half trays!! If you don't want to sell a half tray take it off the menu!

My first time getting 🍕 and wings form them the pizza was awesome and the wings was great I get food from them again 😋 soon .

Best party pizza around. I've driven from over 30 minutes away to pick one up.

The best pizza in town. Been eating S&J pizza for over 50 years!!!

Just had pizza here for the first time. Gotta say the pie wasn't greasy like other places. Does need a little more garlic in the sauce but thats my opinion. Other than that it was really good.

This place is my favorite place for Sicilian Pizza, or Party trays! I usually order a large Sicilian with extra cheese, Mushrooms & Onions with the occasional Sausage, Pineapples, & peppers, and sometimes Anchovies. The Party trays here are fantastic! Another fine establishment in Millville! Don't hesitate, place your order, ASAP!

You should not advertise opening at 11am if that is not the time you will be opening I called and was told I have to wait until 1230 to pick up a large cheese pizza ridiculous