I was searching all over for the Mischevious Kittens ornament and finally found it at Tuttle's. The clerk was busy at the time with a customer but called me back within less than 10 minutes, took my information and went to the post office and sent it out to me. I was so surprised to see it in my mailbox the very next day!!! Anne Wesner was the person who helped me and deserves a huge round of applause. Lisa, the store's owner must be very proud to have an awesome employee in Anne. I thank them from the bottom of my heart. Their customer service is A+.

I love this store. You can spend hours just looking at the stuff.

Great Hallmark store! A smaller store right on main street but filled with Hallmark classic items that are hard to find otherwise. They have an ample selection of greeting cards to choose from with specialty cards available as well. I always find cards for my special occasions at Tuttles! You will find yourself immersed within their vast array of other quality gifts and trinkets. There's also the usual card store items of wrapping paper, ribbons & bows, albums, etc. Although the store itself is in an older building, it is always nice looking & clean on the inside and is adjacent to a pharmacy. I have never met nicer sales staff. Love this store!

I am so thankful to have a nice gift shop in Fort Atkinson. The staff are always friendly when I go in, and I usually find something special while I'm there. (And, they have homemade masks right now!) A great shop to support.

I was looking for a gift of sympathy for a family friend who recently lost her husband. The shopkeeper was a wonderful lady who helped me with the gift I found and was even wonderful enough to wrap it for me. The shop is filled with many unique items and the perfect small town business atmosphere.

Huge selection of gifts, decor, and cards to choose from. Proprietor was friendly and helpful. Nice to have a Hallmark store within 20 miles since they are closing/closed all over the Madison area.

Friendly and helpful staff. Great choice in greeting cards. Displays are always well organized.

Always have found a gift for everyone