Love the pizza here, it's always delicious and fills me up. This is my second time here, and it's just like I remember it. I hope to enjoy it for many more years. Thank You for the amazing Pizza

Food was great. Had the Calzone. The staff was very helpful and friendly.

For $35 I expected some kind of greens on a plate not a small soup bowl. The ravioli looks empty inside. The silverware is limp plastic. It took about 45 minutes to get an order of just two items. Aaarg matey, it's all theme but no dream.

Good solid tasty pizza, fresh ingredients, good selection of pizza combinations with medium thick crust. Fun atmosphere for kids, a local hangout with good customer service.

Read great reviews about this place so we drove out and ordered the Walk The Plank pizza and a regular salad. The chicken is claimed to be marinated in their creamy garlic sauce. Chicken tasted like plain unseasoned chicken. The garlic sauce was on the pie and had no garlic taste. It also said to have garlic on the topping, no garlic. The Italian sausage was flavorful and there was no cornmeal on the bottom of the pie which was wonderful, old school pies didn't use cornmeal. They also have a service charge for using a credit card.

We were invited to try this place through a letter welcoming us to the neighborhood with a coupon. Interesting offer, so why not? The pizza made us sick to our stomachs. It felt like eating a hot and ready pizza: You know it's been sitting a while and pretty greasy. I don't think I'll be giving this place another chance any time soon. They actually sent a follow-up post card thanking us for our visit. It was cute and sincere, and I'm sure they have a great staff, but I just won't take another risk.

Slow place. Would of expected more out of the raviolis and bread twists with soda we got for around $30. Food is not too bad. Clean place though. Could be better. By the ways what up with this all genders bathroom sign and the third person?

We had a party in their party room. Jessica did an amazing job catering to our group. Made for a stress free event! The food was great! All the staff were friendly and accommodating.

It's a homey themed pizza parlor. They've been here forever and actually keep a clean restaurant! The food and dough is made in house. I'd recommend the personal pepperoni and or Anne Bonnie (pesto penne with cheese)* can ask for no cheese* It's fantastic and my friends and I have gone here for the past 18 years. The bathrooms are also themed and stocked with hygiene goods for baby's to adults. There is a mini arcade that gives tickets for redemption.

Have gone to many birthday parties at Pizza Pirate and have always thought it was a good venue for kids. BUT today I waited for bathroom...out came tall, big employee. I went in, there was urine all over the seat and floor. Thinking maybe not his fault then noticed toilet not flushed. Busted!! Do you think he washed his hands??? Told young lady about mess and she was very polite & said she would get cleaned. I'm just not sure I can feel comfortable with another visit, ever!

Clean good atmosphere, nice play to socialize, I always order take out from here but the dine in I had a diferent experience. An order of 6 buffalo wings took nearly an hr to come out, im hoping that it was just a forgotten order.

The place is super pirate themed, it's great if you're looking for that sort of an atmosphere. There was a game in the back and there seemed also like there was more stuff for kids in another room further back. I had garlic cheesy bread sticks and a build your own calzone. The bread was fine, the sauce it came with was very cold so it was congealed and more of a peanut butter consistency than a marinera sauce. My calzone admittedly had tomatoes and bell peppers in it which might have increased the liquid content but it was super soggy. I picked it up and it fell apart, I couldn't pick it up at all and it felt very soggy on the bottom. The taste for all the food was fine, it's hard to get cheese and sauce wrong but there were too many issues for me. Also the food took an extremely long time to come out so don't go here when you're super hungry. The staff seemed nice. We didn't get any menus or anyone coming over but maybe they don't do that here? We just ordered at the front after waiting a bit. I did see staff cleaning after other patrons, but my booth was a bit sticky.

Disappointed we order a family style salad and ended up with a small one. Pizza took forever to come out. As patrons I was also disappointed no one said anything to the Benicia Wolf Pack baseball team kids throwing balls in the hall near the arcade. My daughter got hit as wall as I kids were pushing the machines around and no staff said anything.

First time visit…. Ordered “walk the plank” and when I received my pizza, first thing I saw a long brown hair embedded in a slice, second thing I noticed no green onions on my pizza. I tried a slice (no hair in this slice) and chicken tasted dry, didn’t taste any fresh garlic and the creamy garlic sauce tasted like something out of a can. Very disappointed and I will definitely not be going back there ever!

The pizza was surprisingly good here! If we're in Benicia again we would definitely go back. Service was good and staff was friendly. Plus they have TV's with games on and an (over priced) arcade.

We arrived on Monday 1/20/2020 at 6:16 pm. My wife placed an order for a small personal cheese pizza and a large combo Pizza. We filled our water glasses and found only one dirty booth to be available that would accommodate the four of us. We sat and waited for over 45 minutes, waiting for at least one of the pizzas to be delivered. We were literally the only table in the restaurant without food. I went up to ask about the wait at the counter and there were two other customers in front of me also waiting. Nobody was in the pizza prep area by the oven, multiple employees in the back kitchen area. As I stood at the counter for a few minutes there were multiple pizzas backed up in the oven presumably burning. Finally somebody came out front and I let them know about our wait and inquired about a refund. I was asked to wait just a few minutes more as the pizzas were done. The pizzas themselves were fine, no complaints about the food itself. An employee did ask if we wanted them to give us a free desert to make up for the hassle but we did not take him up on the offer.

Probably the worst tasting pizza I have ever eaten in my life. It's absolutely horrible. Good place for children's parties because they have no idea what good pizza tastes like. Spaghetti with I guess meatballs not much better. You have been warned ⚠️

Good stuff! I ordered the weekly lunch special that included a salad, slice of pepperoni and a small drink. The pizza had a thick crust. I went in at 11:30. There was plenty of seating and the food was fresh!

I am particular about my pizza, and had pretty low expectations about a place with games, pirates, etc. I was happily surprised. This isn't artisan Italian pizza. And I didn't love the crust (I am picky about crust). But this was a delicious pizza, with a good crispy crust. The toppings were generous, and it wasn't sloppy with sauce. I definitely prefer this to any pizza from the usual chain operations. Staff were helpful and the wait time was very reasonable.

We ate here because of a coupon for a free pizza and omg it was absolutely amazing the pizza was delicious we opted to get a couple of extra toppings added on and they did not disappoint even though my friend that I had gone to visit was a vegetarian so the options were very limited they had more then enough verity to satisfy!! And it was delicious!!!

1st time here. We ordered a salad with bread sticks and a medium pizza... chicken, tomato, green onion, fresh garlic, added sausage, with a cream sauce. The salad was pretty big. The bread sticks were quite old and dried out. The pizza had no flavor. Hardly any garlic, very little sausage, and chicken was bland. Not impressed, especially for the price. We got a medium to have left overs for lunch... wish we'd got much smaller.