I Love everything about Goodfellas! They have a huge menu selection of Italian cuisine, subs, salads and pasta dishes with huge portions at reasonable prices. The food at Goodfellas always comes out as ordered and is always delicious, but what really makes this restaurant worth the visit are the people that work here, you won’t find a better group of guys then the ones at Goodfells. They always go above and beyond to make sure everything you ordered is just right. You can see and you will feel how much they actually care about their customers. A Big Compliment to all of them and I wish them continued success for many years to come! Definitely a must try for anyone looking for delicious Italian food!

Goodfellas is the best. The lobster ravioli was fresh and the sauce complimented it very well with the array of delicious vegetables. The pizza crust was perfectly golden yet crunchy. We ordered half cheese/half buffalo chicken and both sides came out extraordinary. The staff were very kind, quick and attentive. They were helpful in guiding us through the menu to help satisfy a certain craving we might have had or a certain taste palette we enjoy. The place was extremely clean. I noticed once someone(s) got up from a table, the staff would clean and sanitize everywhere in that area. If you are craving great food, helpful staff, and a wholesome place all around then head over to Goodfellas. You won’t be disappointed.

My wife and I absolutely loved the food here. Buffalo chicken pizza was the best I had ever eaten, and the chicken parm sandwich was amazing! The sizes of these sandwiches are great for the price as well. Staff here are very friendly, and the business is very well kept and organized. Can not wait to try more of their menu!

I would say this place definitely lives up to its high rating! We got the steak and cheese, margherita pizza and curly fries. The portions were big and the food was really good! The staff was very friendly and nice. They have a huge menu and I would love to go back try some of their other dishes!

I Have to say, we always enjoy every single bite of our meal. The beef kabob wrap is by far my first option and it never disappoints. But no matter what we order we are always delighted with our meal. The menu is extensive and price is reasonable. The service is amazing and employees always efficient, polite and professional. This is our absolute favorite pizza place. We highly recommend it.

Best Shrimp Scampi I’ve had in a while. We also had the chicken buffalo pizza. Everything was delicious. We dined in. Staff were friendly and attentive. Will definitely be back.

The food was amazing. Make sure to take your appetite because you’re going to get fed like you are going to Nonna’s house. Paulo was very welcoming and friendly, even giving us some helpful ideas for activities in Boston while we visited.

My husband and I are visiting from Kansas City and decided to stop in for a slice. I'm originally from NY and I haven't had authentic East coast pizza in many years. I am SO glad we stopped here!! The pizza was fantastic!!! It was so foldable and reminded me of home. I also had some very authentic tiramisu. The whole experience left me with a big smile and a full belly. My husband had a slice and a shrimp dinner....and he loved it. They were beyond busy and yet we were treated as if we were the only people in the place, and we could see that was true for everyone who walked in the door!! This place is a gem!!!!

Had a pizza here and it was fantastic, I really can’t think of something that could have been improved. I will definitely come again in the future if I’m in the area.

Food was delicious! We had chicken parm and cheese lasagna it was amazing. I would definitely recommend to check it out.

Amazing! Ate here twice in 5 days... the buffalo chicken might be the best pizza over ever eaten. The owners made us feel welcome, and we can't wait to come back again!

We visited Goodfellas on our way back to Boston from Gloucester after a day of whale watching. The high reviews and food photos helped our decision to give this restaurant a try for dinner. This place definitely deserves the 4.9 rating that it has! The service was absolutely impeccable! We were greeted the second we stepped foot in the door which provided a very welcoming vibe. The staff was very polite, friendly and helpful. They explained a little about the restaurant, menu and provided recommendations. We started off by sampling a slice of their cheese and Buffalo chicken pizzas. Both were great, but this was THE BEST cheese pizza my husband and son had ever tasted! The crust was super thin, yet crispy. The crust had a great taste even on its own. We ordered the BBQ Chicken Ranch salad, cheese lasagna, Chicken Broculetini with mushroom tortellini and a couple of slices of cheese pizza. All our food was amazing! This was the best meal we have our entire vacation. This crew works hard to prepare everything fresh and they take a lot of pride in their food and it shows! All our food arrived steaming hot and the flavors were incredible! The chicken broculetini was something you would find in a fine dining italian restaurant, it was that good! We will definitely go out of our way to stop here next time we visit the Boston area! Run, don’t walk to try this hidden gem! Great job guys!

This pizzeria is a gem!! Visiting from out of town, we found it based on the reviews and it did not disappoint! Huge portions, great taste, awesome service. And the Deluxe pizza was so good! I thought it was just going to be a standard "works," but I was so pleased when it truly was an everything pizza! Again, this spot is a gem.