OUTSTANDING!! Ordered a Christmas Birthday cake with strawberries, bananas and custard inside and buttercream outside. Owner took his time on the phone to explain all choices and helped me to make the correct decisions. Totally impressed with quality and freshness of the cake. The customer service went above and beyond. Will be back for more. Thank You

Was having a serious sweets craving and decided to try them and definitely did not regret it! They probably have the best black & white cookie I've ever had. The birthday cake rainbow cookies are super delicious as well! Would recommend if you prefer sweets on the sweeter side!

Fresh pastries, great Italian icy , loved the fact that it’s family owned since it’s a rare find. The family enjoyed coming here and we will continue coming here I definitely recommend to those who are looking for a old style feel and taste.

We had our son’s 4th birthday cake made here and everyone at the party raved about how delicious it was. This was our 2nd time using their services, so we knew to expect a yummy treat for our guests ;) Thank you Lyndhurst Pastry for helping us make our Bluey themed party a success!

The best Italian Ice around! The staff is very friendly and the chocolate chip cookies are very good. 7/12/23 Went for my first Italian ice of the season. As usual, it is delicious!!! You can tell from the picture that the chocolate is my favorite but the lemon is also outstanding!!! Anybody that eats Rita's Italian ice is a fool! As far as I'm concerned, Rita's ice is fake!

It's been years since I've stepped foot inside and it's just as I remember it and most importantly just as good. Amazing cookies and treats but most importantly the best Italian Ice in the world. Come for that at the least.

Ordered a special occasion cake with photo on it for my daughters engagement party. The pastry shop has been a staple in my area for decades. Traditional Italian pastry, cookies and cakes as well as breads. The cake I ordered was a double half sheet cake. Plenty of chocolate filling, cake itself was ok and whipped cream icing held up surprisingly well considering it sat out for a few hours prior to being served. Decorations on cake we're a bit underwhelming considering the price of it. Picture was nicely done. Everyone loved the cake.

My Grandma used to bring me here as a kid, every birthday would be celebrated with a cannoli cake, or we’d make a trip over for some yum-yum vanilla Italian ice. The pastries are my absolute favorite thing, you can never go wrong with a cannoli, sfogliatelle or eclair from here. I live in PA now, so I only get to stop in occasionally but every time I do it’s like a little taste of heaven and my childhood all in one. This place is a gem.