Leigh Jay Nacht Inc. image

Leigh Jay Nacht Inc.

Diamond dealer

Fine jewelry showroom known for unique antique engagement rings & other vintage diamond pieces. People often mention ring, Leigh, engagement, experience, rings, vintage, Nacht, wanted, perfect, wedding,


Address

115 W 45th St #504, New York, NY 10036

Website

antiqueengagementrings.com

Contact

(212) 719-2888

Rating on Google Maps

4.90 (71 reviews)

Open on Google Maps

Working Hours

  • Friday: 10 AM to 5:30 PM
  • Saturday: Closed
  • Sunday: (Easter), Closed, Hours might differ
  • Monday: 10 AM to 5:30 PM
  • Tuesday: 10 AM to 5:30 PM
  • Wednesday: Closed
  • Thursday: 10 AM to 5:30 PM

Featured Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: ring (45) Leigh (42) engagement (20) experience (19) rings (15) vintage (12) Nacht (10) wanted (10) perfect (9) wedding (9)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 5/5 Joseph F. 4 years ago on Google
    Really a top notch experience. A few months ago I found myself running through the gauntlet of finding an engagement ring in NYC. After several aggressive visits to the diamond district I found Leigh Jay Nacht while searching for antique engagement rings online. Upon the first visit I was very impressed with their well priced selection and genuinely friendly, non-pushy approach to finding the perfect setting for a family diamond I had. I rarely leave reviews, but this very relaxed and informative experience left a lasting impression and I recommend them to whoever will listen. Many thanks.
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Amanda S. 6 years ago on Google
    Leigh Jay Nacht is a class act. They have stunning rings, and even better service. My fiancé purchased my engagement ring here in 2015, and we just recently came back to purchase my wedding band, and it was such a great experience. Leigh and his team specialize in vintage, and their selection is outstanding. I was able to find something that matched my 1930s engagement ring perfectly! And best of all, no pressure whatsoever! Leigh let me try on as many bands as I wanted to so I found that one the fit me perfectly! HIGHLY RECOMMEND if you are in the market for vintage classics!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Arya M. 8 months ago on Google • 52 reviews
    Simply put, I wouldn't even bother looking for jewelry elsewhere. If you're in the market for a ring-- a vintage (or vintage-style) engagement ring in particular-- this is the spot for you. Leigh and Sarahjane make the whole experience a pleasure. This is a family run business, and it shows. Concerned about being rushed through the experience, pressured to buy, or sold something less than stellar? You needn't worry here. The team at Leigh Jay Nacht will make sure that you are comfortable and well informed every step of the way. They'll also be sure that you (and your loved one) are satisfied with your purchase. Need a re-sizing? Ours was done and returned to us on the very same day. As for the goods themselves, they've got an unmatched selection. I was particularly impressed with their retro and art deco rings from the 1920s-50s, though you can also find newer and older options, as well. Best of all, the prices are fair. You can walk out with a beautiful piece of history for less than the price of an iPad. Do yourself a favor and come by. *Pro tip*- make an appointment first. They're very accommodating, and you don't need to worry about booking far in advance.

  • 5/5 Ashlye U. 7 months ago on Google • 21 reviews
    Leigh is THE. BEST. Not only is he simply an amazing and kind person, he has an incredible selection. A year ago I upgraded my engagement ring to one of his antique settings. He had so many rings to choose from (antique and new) and not once did I feel pressured to go over my budget. I also just bought an anniversary band and once again, A+ experience. Thank you Leigh!

  • 5/5 Maria T. 6 months ago on Google • 21 reviews
    My fiancé and I went ring shopping a few months back and loved the service we received. Scheduling was easy, and the person who helped schedule our appointment was very sweet. Once we arrived for our appointment, Leigh was very knowledgeable and helped me choose the ring. I am obsessed with my ring!! Will definitely recommend!

  • 5/5 Howie T. 9 months ago on Google • 15 reviews
    After looking around at countless engagement rings, we finally found Leigh and he had a ring that was obviously “the one.” He actually had a few that could’ve been the one but that’s just a testament to all the great options he has. Each piece has such character and charm. And the heart that he puts into the craftsmanship is fully apparent. He also spent so much time talking through each piece to make sure it would all be exactly as we wanted. In an industry where it is so easy to get overwhelmed, Leigh makes the jewelry process so seamless and the quality of his product is just unparalleled.

  • 5/5 Sarah B. 1 month ago on Google • 14 reviews New
    Stop searching if you want a vintage style ring. I looked at rings for over a year. Never liked anything. I am quite picky. I was stopped in my searching tracks when I found this website. My fiancé and I were shopping for 3 rings. A band for her and an engagement and band for me. We found everything we LOVED including Leigh. I was shocked at the service and timely replies from the owner. We have never stepped foot in his store, and shopped from out of state. And let me tell you how much I want to hug this man. My fiancé fell in love with a ring. Leigh found the perfect sapphires to match her engagement ring. When it arrived and she slipped it on, it swallowed her engagement ring. She loved the ring but it just didn’t match with hers. I felt horrible after all the communication time and work that went in it and now I had to tell Leigh that my love didn’t love her ring. He made returning it easy and worry free. We are going to try styles near home and sending him videos and photos he will make my fiancé her perfect ring. Leigh was more than understanding. He actually wants you to love your piece. Not just make a sale. We love him so much. My rings… my engagement ring was gorgeous! It was too tight and Leigh noticed in the photo I sent him. He offered to resize it for no charge. My wedding band was also stunning. I liked it so much I wanted it made into an enhancer and Leigh was again, more than happy to oblige. Other things need mention- This man truly loves what he does. Never once was I asked to go higher on my budget or felt pressured. In fact, everything was under budget. We live in quiet country. I was having a hard time getting my finger sized. Leigh sent a sizing set to me!!! The shipping is amazingly well packaged and fast. He even sends videos as well as photos. He truly understands service and communication. With never stepping foot in his place to try anything on or meeting him; we felt truly cared about and were comfortable with him instantly. So if you are still debating where to shop, this would be the end of your search. You will not be disappointed.

  • 5/5 Lisa K. 2 years ago on Google • 7 reviews
    I can't express how grateful we are to Leigh Jay Nacht for the gorgeous engagement ring! We were referred to Leigh Jay Nacht Inc. after getting an heirloom stone appraised, as I mentioned I wanted a vintage inspired setting with some modern detail. Leigh's shop provided wonderful inspiration for us to participate in the custom design process. They have countless gorgeous vintage and vintage reproduction settings. Leigh worked for months with us to design exactly the ring I wanted, and I was not an easy customer with a straightforward idea. He spent a lot of time and personal attention walking me through options for various aspects of the design, and incorporated my own idea for a recessed Hexagon Halo to the exact specifications I wanted. He also let me choose the exact rose gold shade I wanted, and made multiple models for me to try on before finalizing the design. Best of all- he managed to keep the exact finished ring design a surprise, so there was still an element of traditional surprise involved in our proposal. Leigh and his wife are wonderful folks who provide personalized customer service and my Fiancée Patrick and I are grateful to have them and the custom ring design as part of our story. We highly recommend them for both custom setting designs, and for anyone shopping for vintage or vintage inspired settings. We look forward to adding better photos when we get them taken- the photos just don't do this gorgeous ring justice!

  • 5/5 Helen L. 11 months ago on Google • 4 reviews
    We LOVED our experience with Leigh--couldn't be kinder people and my god their work is beautiful! They took such incredible care of us. I have literally never written a google review before to my memory--but i wanted to write one for Leigh because of how amazingly grateful we are. We love our rings and we are so thankful for his kindness and help.

  • 5/5 Lucy G. 8 months ago on Google • 3 reviews
    I have been looking for the perfect engagement ring for the past 35 years when my husband proposed to me with the wrong one! i’m so glad i waited because the ring i finally found here is indeed the most perfect ring! they also kindly fixed my husband’s wedding ring that had gotten too small. we were able to pick both up in a few hours. we had a great experience visiting the city and seeing the beautiful show room. leigh and his wife are the loveliest people and all the jewelry is incredible. i am going to ask them help me redesign another ring and i can’t wait. i feel so lucky to have found this wonderful jeweler! i have been telling everyone about them!

  • 5/5 Natalia S. 4 months ago on Google • 3 reviews
    My husband and I had a wonderful experience viewing wedding bands. Leigh was incredibly helpful scheduling and preparing the appointment for us. My husband selected a vintage band that they resized, engraved, and shipped to us out of state. Highly recommend shopping and supporting this establishment.

  • 5/5 Gloria C. 3 years ago on Google
    So thankful to have spent my first ring trying-on experience here! Safe space with appointments available to people who are cautious about going into stores during the pandemic. Super knowledgeable owner/staff who answered all of my questions, knew the inventory quite well, and taught us so much about buying rings in general. They have a great selection of unique vintage rings that are stunning and worth trying on in person. No uncomfortable "salesman" vibes or pressure to purchase at all. Super welcoming, kind, clean, and professional atmosphere.

  • 5/5 Timothy S. 1 year ago on Google
    I can not say enough about the overall experience, expertise and comfort they bring to what can be a stressful experience. I have told all of my friends and family, if you’re looking for that one of a kind wedding ring/engagement ring that embodies the love and uniqueness of your partner, look no further! They are the kindest and most understanding, respectful people I have met in the industry. A pressure free experience that leaves you with a completely different outlook on the industry. Look no further and don’t waste your time with anyone else, they are by far the best !! Much love and appreciation for all of their help.Trevor & Irene

  • 5/5 Igor N. 1 year ago on Google
    I would encourage everyone to consider getting a custom engagement ring from Leigh. Leigh is very unassuming and doesn't pressure you at all. For me, Leigh matched a beautiful sapphire with one his replica settings and the result was a magical engagement ring. I got our weddings bands here as well. Highly recommend.

  • 5/5 Angie H. 4 years ago on Google
    Decided last minute to elope, my husband to be has a size 13 finger and I was determined to find him an antique ring...I was so frustrated and starting to panic when I spoke to Leigh and she just said I have the perfect ring and she did...it was so simple and easy I had the ring the following day. My now husband loves it....one of my best experiences purchasing anything... Set the wedding off on a great foot.

  • 5/5 Kelly H. 2 years ago on Google
    Wonderful experience to work with Leigh Jay Nacht staff!!! Beautiful and unique pieces and always something new. We have purchased from here several times. This is the only place we go and never disappointed. Look here for that special piece for that special person!

  • 5/5 Kristoffer R. 4 years ago on Google
    We have been using Leigh Jay Nacht for Engagement ring, wedding band and first anniversary necklace. Both my wife and I are very happy with the product, service and shipping. As we live in Europe I was nervous ordering a ring online but it all worked out so well. I am sure that we will keep using Leigh.

  • 5/5 Amy S. 4 years ago on Google
    My fiance and I went shopping for engagement rings together, not knowing what we were looking for. Leigh's store was our first stop, and nothing we found surpassed his rings. Both Leigh and Kiesha were also lovely to work with. We enjoyed it so much, we also bought our wedding bands with them. Leigh waited for us on a Saturday to come by and spent time with us choosing the right bands for us. When my fiance went to pick them up, Kiesha went out of her way to make sure his size fit perfectly. I could go on about our experience, but I highly suggest anyone shopping for engagement rings and wedding bands visit Leigh Jay Nacht. We are getting married one month from today, and we are so glad our experience began here :)

  • 5/5 Lauren T. 7 years ago on Google
    I could not be happier with the ring or service that my fiance and I received from Leigh Jay Nacht. Leigh spent close to two hours with us as I tried on every ring that caught my eye, and he was unfailingly patient. Once he got a sense for the style of ring that I wanted, he pulled a setting from the safe in back and brought out the most perfect piece--I even got a little emotional the second I put it on my finger, so I knew that was the once. Since I wanted a pink sapphire for my center stone rather than a diamond, he sourced several options until he found the perfect stone. It arrived in the mail today and I could not be happier with it. It is stunning. The team at Leigh Jay Nacht is amazing. Beautiful jewelry selection, incredibly kind and patient staff, and an incredible value for a unique, heirloom ring. Highly recommended!

  • 5/5 Christine S. 2 years ago on Google
    Every experience is amazing! The jewelry is elegant and beautifully unique ❤️

  • 5/5 Justin N. 2 years ago on Google
    I visited a bunch of designers but ultimately worked with Leigh on a custom engagement ring for my fiance, which came out perfectly. Leigh was incredibly easy to work with and openly collaborative in the design process. The style of one of his rings, and his design sensibilities, inspired it; but his willingness to bring a modern touch to some key details resulted in a truly special ring that we couldn't have gotten anywhere else. Very happy all around; great experience and stress free

  • 5/5 Jack S. 11 months ago on Google • 1 review
    Had a great experience working with Leigh to purchase my engagement ring for my fiancé. He was great at offering suggestions and communicating and being wonderful to work with such a big milestone in our lives. Highly recommend.

  • 5/5 McKenzie Carter C. 9 years ago on Google • 1 review
    This place is perfect in every aspect. Winona was so patient, kind, knowledgeable, attentive, professional, everything you name it! My now finance and I knew immediately when we sat down to speak with her that our search for jewelers was done. I was looking for something extremely specific when I first began my search. I sure do wish I had found these awesome people from day one. Everybody and anybody in the market for a truly unique and vintage ring please, do yourself a favor, save a lot of time, headaches and anxiety and just go see Winona at Leigh Jay. You won't find a better price or quality anywhere and you won't find such genuine people anywhere else in the industry. One of kind they are and I am thrilled to see in the above reviews that Leigh Jay and his staff also resonate to so many other happy customers


Call (212) 719-2888 Open on Google Maps

Amenities


  • Payments
    • ✓️ Debit cards
    • ✓️ Credit cards
    • ✓️ NFC mobile payments
  • Accessibility
    • ✓️ Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • ✓️ In-store pickup
    • ✓️ In-store shopping
  • From the business
    • ✓️ Small business

Trends



Last updated:

Similar Diamond dealers nearby

Rare Carat, Inc image
1
Rare Carat, Inc
Diamond dealer
👍👍 I wanted to upgrade my engagement diamond, after all it was over 30 years ago when I received my beautiful ring. I wanted a bigger and better quality diamond. After a lot of research, I decided to purchase a lab created diamond through Rare Carat. I was very pleased with the customer service and "Wo...
4.90 (2K reviews)
TraxNYC image
2
TraxNYC
Jeweler
Gold chains, watches & custom pendants feature at this retailer of jewelry & watches.
4.40 (2K reviews)
Lauren B Jewelry image
3
Lauren B Jewelry
Jewelry store
Open since 1978, this retailer specializes in engagement rings, custom designs & loose diamonds.
4.90 (1.5K reviews)
James Allen Showroom image
4
James Allen Showroom
Diamond dealer
😠 I've waited a long time to write this review because I was hoping James Allen would right their wrongs but so far this has not happened. In a nutshell this is what happened with my engagement ring. It's an engagement HORROR STORY! My husband purchased a ring from JA back in 2015, in 2020 I decided t...
4.60 (1.1K reviews)
Cartier Fifth Avenue Mansion image
5
Cartier Fifth Avenue Mansion
Jewelry store
Luxury brand founded in 1847 specializing in high jewelry, jewelry, timepieces & accessories.
4.20 (820 reviews)
Last updated:
()