We ordered spinach dip, fig, meat lover and Sicilian sausage (thick crust). The flavors were very good, and the fig flavor really stood out. If you like bacon-wrapped-dates type of flavor, the sweet-savory fig might be a good fit for you. The crust was okay, but we would prefer more texture. The staff was not friendly and always in a rush. Overall, a good place to quickly grab some food before taking trains!

This pizza store such big & one of the good quality pizza store in the city. employee behave so friendly and food also fresh if you order full pie. Slice is not a good idea such as a Sicilian Slice because it’s not good sale but chess pizza slice best. Or whole pie sure best idea to order.

Best pizza I have eaten in my life. New York street pizza. Large cuts, thin crust, served piping hot because it is reheated in the oven. Offers a huge array of variety and flavours. Relatively cheap pricing for new york city compared to those offering more than just the basic flavour. BBQ chicken was amazing.

I'm finally trying a NY style pizza and this place had lots of pics so off we went! It's near Madison Square Garden with seats on the inside. We had to wait in line outside, but it moved quickly. I suggest you look at the menu outside because once you enter you're already being asked what you want so they can throw it on a pizza tray to heat up. I had the meat lovers and spinach dip. My choices were a little upscale so I paid $7 each including tax. No change to worry about here! And the slices were large enough to do the NY fold!

Happened to be around the area and decided to go this famous place Tried the signature pizza and white with garlic. Mozeralla over garlic base was absolutely new thing that i tried. Loved both If you are over scars pizza, joe pizza, di fara etc This is the next gem that one should try

This place does not look fancy from the outside, do not let that fool you! Best NYC Pizza I have had yet! Decided to give it a try as I was going to a Hockey game at Madison Square Garden. They DID NOT disappoint! I will be back, for sure!!!

Location location. That’s what makes this pizza joint bustling. Above average & good pizza for a premium price. $7 for mushroom slice. I enjoyed it but I can get same elsewhere for $5. This spot is ideal next to MSG & PENN STATION. I came here cause I always see a line outside when cycling by. Ample seating but it can get crowded especially if there’s an event at MSG. If you are hungry & intoxicated and don’t mind paying a premium for convenience then it’s definitely worth a try 😇

This place often sees quite a hefty line forming, and it's no wonder why. They serve up these massive slices of pizza with delicious marinara sauce that's simply irresistible. The pizza selection is seriously extensive, even offering some fantastic vegetarian options. I was pleasantly surprised by the Hawaiian pizza; previously, I couldn't quite wrap my head around the combination of pineapple and meat, but now I get it – you can just appreciate them as separate flavor profiles. When I dropped by, there was a bit of a wait, but it didn't last long thanks to their efficient service.

Amazing pizza. Great taste. It's very difficult to find many varieties of vegan food or vegan pizza in NYC but here we had the best pizza till now we had ever. Please try to have it whenever you come to Times square.

I was looking for a decent pizza place as there are so many in New York and this had many good reviews, so chose this place. I also liked that this was family owned, so it's nice to support local businesses and family. There were so many options you could choose from and the slices are big (compared to the UK, one slice here is about two slices in the UK). You queue up and pick if your type of pizza on offer, whether by slices, half a pizza or full pizza. You then choose if you want a drink when paying up, they take cash, contactless and card. You then wait for your pizzas to be reheated, but you can ask for them to remain cold. Despite having the queue, it went quite quickly. Ordering and paying was easy enough. Staff were nice and efficient! I got two Meat pizza slices and a large coke cola for $15, which was enough to fill me up! We sat inside, quite a good amount of space and lovely atmosphere. So worth visiting here for a reasonably priced pizza dinner!

Hands down THE BEST pizza I have eaten in my entire life!!! Absolutely delicious. Come here order anything and you’ll be happy. They have a quote on the wall ‘do one thing but do it better than anyone else’ and do they ever. Incredible!!

Large, fast slices. Nothing fancy inside just a classic pizzeria. They have a lot of interesting pizzas some of which seem to be trying too hard. Stick to the classics and you won't be disappointed.

It was fun in there, very lively! I got my pizza to go. I think I got a grandma, a sausage and a fig pizza. All the slices were delicious. The service was super fast and the cashier was fun and engaging. Nice pizza spot with a huge selection of pies. The toppings were great. The slices were not greasy and the crust had a nice thin crispness. Delicious.

My very first NY pizza and I loved it!! Such creative pizza slices and first time trying hot honey! I had the bacon, basil, fig pizza slice and mushroom slice with the hot honey on the side. The mixture of savory and sweet was on point! And they used fresh mushrooms!! Def gonna miss this place!

These guys were moving so fast! I swear they took 5 orders in less than a minute and kept the line moving. The white pizza with garlic was tasty. Slices are on the bigger size (like Joes). Lots of available seating inside for a pizza place. This place has a $10 minimum for card.

Super glad I visited this place because the pizza was well worth it. I wanted to try the cheese pizza first since that's what I've been getting in different shops and it was good. We noticed that people weren't ordering the cheese as much and instead, they were doing specialty slices, so we got the hot honey, which was even better. I'm not a fan of honey, but the slice gives it a nice spicy sweetness and it compliments the cheeses very well. Next time I'm in New York I'd like to come back and try out new slices.

My personal favorite pizza place in NYC. This can be heavily biased due to nostalgia but I believe the pizza is genuinely delicious. The dough is nice and crunchy and the toppings were fresh. You can get a slice from the counter or order a pie with sit down service. I loved our server the last time we went. Denise was an absolute delight.

Simple and best NY style pizza in NY. Quick service, good ambience. Tried all the veggie options and they turned out to be great especially the Hot Honey pizza. Portion sizes are huge. Value for money. Felt full after a single slice.

What a slice! Stopped in for a quick bite and was blown away. They asked what we wanted right away and threw it in for a warm up. Came out nice and hot. The flavor was incredible! Just can't beat that crust.

Phenomenal slice's. This place has all the NYC charm a traveler would expect while having a taste that even a local can recommend. This place was recommended to me by a life long New Yorker as the best possible stop off coming out of Penn Station for a quick and incredibly delicious lunch, and she was spot on. The location was prime, the service was quick, the NYC Round Cheese Pizza and White with Garlic slices were to die for and the staff was far friendlier than you'd expect if your only NYC exposure was from TV. Highly recommend you stop in for a slice...or two when you're near by.

We came all the way from Melbourne, Australia in 2019 for this Pizza. We had heard it was one of the best in NY. It may not be the most fancy place in the world but this Pizza was AWESOME. Definitely deserves its reputation. Definitely will be back once the world allows us to return to the Big Apple!

Best pizza in NYC. Had to come back after 6 years after discovering it leaving Penn Station. The crust is crispy, airy, yet soft. The sauce is fresh and savory. The cheese is excellent quality and perfectly dispersed and melted. No other pizza place does it like this. And when Anthony Bourdain and Andrew Zimmern approve, you know it’s the best quality! 10/10 coming back every time I’m in the area. Do yourself a favor and go here.

One of the best pizza slices I have ever had in NYC! Although this is not my absolute favorite pizza spot, they offer a wide selection of fresh and thinly crusted pizzas, several toppings and vegan options also available. Always busy and no wonder why, service is friendly and quick, plenty of seating inside.

Great pizza by the slice in the midtown area. A bit pricey (especially whole pies), but the slices are decent size! The upside down and spicy pepperoni thick slices were really tasty. The freshest pizza was best, as some of the others were unevenly temperatured due to being reheated. All were super crispy, but the tops of some weren’t hot enough for me. The service was fast but a bit hard as you have to order through the glass or they skip you. It was nice to be able to sit in, and I don’t think any other pizzas around have this variety, history and quality in the area. It’s worth a try!

Perfect location for a quick slice of NYC pizza. Across the street from Penn Station and MSG. Quick service, tables inside, and the pizza is good. My favorite was the plain but the margarita and burrata slices was great as well! If you’re seeing a game or concert at MSG this is your the place for a quick slice before or after!

3.5 stars. Weird I've never been here before but was reminded of it on Kenji Lopez-Alt's IG pizza journeys. It's cool that a legit slice place is right there for tourists showing up at Penn station. I ordered a plain slice, but was told it'd be a wait, so I asked for Sicilian, also not ready. So, I got the upside down square slice. Then found out they had a TEN dollar card minimum (get with the times, guys) so I also ordered a plain to take away. The slices are expensive, most are $6.50, so just stopping in for a quick slice I ended up spending 13 bucks on pizza. The counter service was oddly hostile- a lot of those passive aggressive "SIRS", and it wasn't really like NY charming, just kind of off-putting. Cool seating area, nice throwback vibe. Pizza was fine. Again, good enough that I'm glad they've stayed in biz, but I'll walk a few blocks to the superior Upside Pizza from now on.

Heritage place to get pizza. Their thick crust pizzas are a specialty. In business since 1964. Must try their grandmother pizza. I tried the chicken parmigiana and the cheese was so good. Highly recommended if you are near Madison Square Garden.

I am a pizza snob. Always have been. This is hands down the best Slice ever. Crust is airy and incredible. But the sauce. Oh the sauce... Just heavenly. I am talking travel back to NYC kind of amazing pizza here.

The pizza was OK. The NY style cheese was pretty crispy on the bottom, but the sauce was extremely sweet with a hint of herbed seasoning. The square pepperoni was thick, fluffy, and really, really good. However, the experience was terrible. As soon as we set foot in the door, the staff was aggressively shouting at us demanding our order and would not even give us a second to look at the types of pizza. Then when we ordered to go because it was extremely crowded and there was absolutely no seating to be had, they just stacked our slices on top of each other in one paper bag... So when we took them apart, half the cheese on my slice went with the bottom of the top slice... you can get better pizza and better service elsewhere.

My husband and I loved this place. Tasty pizza, fast service and an extensive menu. Better yet, besides the conventional pizza flavors, they do offer vegetarian and vegan pizza. I loved the vegan marguerita! My partner eat the fig and prosciutto pizza, he also enjoyed! I highly recommend it!

Delicious pizza, tasty! Lots of various pizza also for vegans, vegetarians. It was a long queue but it went fast. Only minor problem is you need to say your pizza options 3 times. There is a restroom facility as well. Worth to try!

Amazing NYC pizza spot. One of my favorites. Right across the street from Madison Square Gardens. Open late and lots of seating. Pizza by the slice or whole pies available. Lots of variety always available..good price and amazing flavor.

A must visit pizza central while here. There are so many varieties that you may need a week to relish them all. A decent meal of 2 slices and a drink will set you back by around 13$ or so... There is ample sitting room too if you wish to dine in.

This is a typical New York style pizza place except that the prices are a bit steep in my opinion. Yes it is thin crust; crispy and chewy crust with decent texture. Also just the right amount of sweet tomato sauce and cheese. I don’t think we can call this one the best but it represents New York style pizza properly. When I was growing up in New York there were many joints with this quality of pizza. This place gets crowded due to its high reviews and history. There are some tables in the back for small groups and condiments for pizza opposite the cashier table.

While I've certainly had better pizza, I've also had much worse. Everything is hand made, the tomato sauce is chunky and fresh (a tad too sweet for my taste) and all the slices are hot and crispy when you get them. Service and ambiance are great, too. Overall certainly good Pizza.

This pizza is quite good for a NY style slice. Their pizzas are large, and the quality of the ingredients is solid. We had this pizza at an event, and their pepperoni, cheese, and vegan pizzas were all great. The only reason I didn’t give it 5 stars is because the cheese wouldn’t hold on to the crust below, so each bite you were removing almost all the cheese on the slice! The quality of their dough is incredible. So much flavor in that which makes eating the crust a no-brainer!

My favorite slice of pizza in NYC. Lots of options and all of the slices I’ve had have been perfect. It’s right next to Penn Station, so perfect for grabbing a bite while you’re coming or going from the city.

Comparable to "boardwalk style" pizza. Definitely not bad, but nothing special either. While I did enjoy the crispy crust, the sauce was a bit on the bland side, and the cheese created a tad too much grease. Again, NY Pizza Suprema was not terrible by any means, but other than the fact of it being conveniently located close to Penn Station, I don't think I would return. One recommendation: get a freshly cooked, entire pie if possible. As with any pizza place, REHEATED slices are garbage!

It was good pizza but the crust wasn’t that good. It was way too crunchy and the staff want that Friendly but there was a line of people so I’m sure they did the best they could. Make sure to take napkins for the pepperoni grease!!

Best pizza I've ever had in my life. Incredible variety. They have the classics. They have unique options with more complex flavor profiles. I had the potato and the hot honey. Their pickle and bacon ranch were great too! Also great service!