My wife and I stayed at the HH Creek Inn across the street. Looked at the menu on line and I walked over and ordered two regular calzones. I'm used to a calzone that fits on a paper plate. Huge mistake! Each was the size of the diagonal length of a large pizza box. On top of that, it was delicious, perhaps the best I've had! Give them a try and you'll be glad you did.

The place is a bit shabby, but that's to be expected of a gas station doubling as a pizza and sub place. Nostalgia has likely contributed to that fifth star. I had not had a Simple Simon's pizza in over twenty years. I was not disappointed in this one. We had a Big 10 and a Canadian bacon pizza. Both were made fresh, and tasted excellent. My girlfriend said she may have to make the forty minute trip again just for the pizza. You may have to ask for plates, as they won't likely remember to offer them to you otherwise. Fountain drinks have free refills while you are there eating. They had what they called homade gumbo as the special of the day, though this was not part of the Simple Simon's, but of the gas station. I took some to go. It was pricey, but pretty good. I wish this place was closer to home, but will still likely return.

This is a Friendly local owned quick stop/gas station that serves drive up pizza. Very Good pizza and I love that it is drive up! Makes it so easy to call in a pizza or calzone (also good) and then pick up when ready.

We ordered the pepperoni pizza and it was excellent.

Great place in and out within 30 minutes Fastest Pizza joint I've been in a long time. I would recommend this place to anybody

Greasiest thing I’ve ever eaten! Greasier than a bacon sandwich, but still better than the big chain pizza places......someone also stated in a previous review. Make sure you don’t set the pizza box on your car seat, possibility the grease will go through the box and soak into your seat or any other fabric.

Love this place! We have their number saved because we only go to them for pizza. We don't even buy it at the store. It's just that good and they always get the timing right for pick up. So far we've only had great experiences.

The pizza was a Big 10. It was very good and had plenty of toppings except the sauce. There was very little sauce on the pie. It was ready when we got there and was hot. We enjoyed it .

The most disgusting pizza I have ever eaten. I ordered a triple cheese pizza and there was barely any cheese or sauce on it. It tasted like cardboard. I am starting to think they are selling two-day old pizza .

Simple Simon's is great. Give 'em a call. Wait 15 minutes. Drive up to the window. Enjoy. If you're new to town, here's some tips: It's connected to a gas station, and you pick up your pizza from a drive-thru window. Hey, we're a small town. But it is quality pizza from a franchise with hundreds of locations. When you pay, ask for a menu for next time. I don't visit the gas station much, but I noticed that they sell individual slices inside the gas station. They are big slices. And it is the only pizza in town; so I hope you like it as much as I do.