We liked this place at first. But then steadily things just got worse and worse. We spent a lot of money with them every time we ordered because there are 6 of us. But then they stopped delivering even though people further than them deliver to us. Then the food seemed extra salty but my kid liked this place so we tried to order for her birthday party. I called two days in advance to place a large order. I was told by someone named Anthony that he'd call me back in 10 minutes. Never called so we took our $200 order elsewhere. We will continue to take our business elsewhere.

Delicious and loaded pizzas. Had the veggie pizza and the chicken bacon pizza were both amazing. Wings were small but spicy and yummy crispy. Highly recommend! Friendly place!

Guest Eater Evan Benn. I love the Greco family. They could easily be Delaware County’s 1st family of cheesesteaks. The grill person had skills. We got the garlic bread cheesesteak and a mushroom cheesesteak. Both were very good. Every cheesesteak gets toasted, I like that. Both had a lot of their named flavors. I would have liked one more slice of cheese and a better cheese melt. I feel like if I asked for an extra slice of cheese they would have given it to me.

Ordered two slices at intermission (15 min) of the Messiah. They got it out quick - made just right and provided plenty of toppings. Good guys, good food!

My most favorite Todd that I enjoy ordering from here are the hoagies. They’re fresh and also have a few sizes so you’re not overstuffing yourself or share the big one with someone.

Went here for first time today 1/26/24. Pizza was perfect Greek / New England / Philly Style. Very friendly and enthusiastic owner & staff. 5 STARS!!!

Stopped in for a couple slices on our neighbor's recommendation. Very good pizza, especially if you like a medium - thicker crust. Right amount of crispy and chewy. Pizza was very flavorful, staff was very friendly, upbeat, and they obviously cared about what they were serving. Would definitely go again!

I relocated from Devon and miss my favorite pizza place. The pizza, sandwiches, pasta and everything I've tried was delicious! They have the BEST eggplant parm sandwich you'll ever eat and no other restaurant can come close. I'm stopping in as soon as I can. The delivery guys are the best too.

This is the 2nd time I've ordered for delivery and have not received what I ordered. Called, asked for items to be reimbursed on credit card. Put on hold so she could "contact owner". On hold forever, called back, snarky response. Not acceptable. They lost this customer and I had to contact my credit card company to dispute the charge. There are so many better take out places in this area that are customer focused. Stay away from New Wayne Pizza.

New Wayne Pizza is my favorite place to order delivery from. The staff taking the orders are efficient and nice. Their food is always good, the square pizzas are huge, and the food is always delivered in a reasonable amount of time and at the correct temperature.

The food was quite good and the younger guy at the front counter was very accommodating and polite. I’d definitely recommend their mango chicken salad. The only real legit concern I have is… the way the owner/father berated his son in front of kids and customers. Loud, profanity, insults. He left, came back, did it again and took off. Completely unprofessional. Shows a real lack of restraint and lack of care for your business when social media is always paying attention. The son didn’t deserve that abuse in front of others and that man should be ashamed of his publicly viewed outburst. It was cringe worthy. Like I said, good food if you can look past that.

The pizzas and salads here are delicious! Love to support this local business.

Good food. Great portions. Great service. There's a reason why they are so busy. Definitely a go to.

This is a very clean restaurant. The staff is very friendly, prices are reasonable. And the FOOD is so GOOD. I DRIVE 30 minutes just to get food from this restaurant, anyone that haven’t tried this restaurant before you should definitely give them a try.

As an educator in the area, this is my go to spot for a quick lunch. The best pizza shop around- from food to customer service. I really appreciate the personal connections the owner and son make with their customers- always friendly and attentive. Great food and great energy. 10/10 recommend.

I've never been here before & I don't live up this way, but today I found this place & had a slice of pizza which was actually 2 small slices. I must say, it was very good. It almost tasted like pizza hut pizza 25 years ago when pizza hut was really good. Not the pizza hut today which sucks. If I'm ever up this way again, I will buy more pizza. I didn't give it 5 stars because the slices were kind of small, but they were still good.

If I lived closer to this shop I’d be there a few times a week. Unfortunately I’m 40 minutes away. The cheesesteak I ordered was packed with meat, greasy and delicious. I destroyed it in minutes. Very nice people working there. Will be back when in the area

About 20 years ago, this was my go to spot. The food and service was worth the trip. I then moved away. I came back and it seemed like the original owners were gone. I was worried but when I tried the food it was great. The grinders and strombolis are the best anywhere. The pizza is also very good, better than most. The service and staff are always super nice and friendly. They truly make you feel welcome. There is a small dine-in area but it might be better to grab and go. The only downside is the parking situation. If you are running in to grab food, there is temporary parking right out front. Other than that there is street parking down the street and a small lot down the way as well. I do need to try some other things on the menu but I find it hard not to get one of the three items that I always do. I find the food worth the drive. My top go to place.

My coworker put me on to New Wayne and it's my new favorite pizza spot! Extra cheese slaps if you like that rich, lustrous type of pie. The ricotta and tomato white pie is 10/10. Also great for parties with their big ol square pizza!

It’s 11:08 pm and I’m eating the left over slice of pizza (plain cheese lol..) I had left back since I had lunch at work 12pm . 5 stars the portion was big , can’t believe I’m writing a review , great quality

We order from NWP when we visit my in-laws almost every weekend. My go-to is the Chicken Souvlaki Salad! My kids love the pizza and burgers and the wraps and sandwiches are also great! Love this place.

Definitely shrinkflation, or they've always made small pizzas, in which case, I'd hate to order a small. New to the area and trying different pizza joints. New Wayne's offering has good flavor and a greek type crust. The sauce is a wee bit on the sweet side, but good and tangy. Nice helpings of cheese and pepperoni as well. The size is where they fall down. $16 for a 13.5" pizza (box is 14.5", and the pizza didn't touch the insides of the box, so I'm figuring about 13.5". If the owners read this, can you offer an extra large for about $20.00 and make it a traditional fill-the-box 16" pizza?

Ordered a pizza and I tried their Philly cheesesteak sandwich. Both were very good! My daughter who is living here said she didn't like the pizza here because she never had any that was good until she had the pizza from here. She said she will be going back. The business owner was a great guy and we had great conversation with him while waiting on our food. We will be back when we are in town.

Excellent food and fun conversation! We ordered a ton of food for a picnic, and chatted with one of the cooks while it was being prepared. Great vibes! When we went on our picnic, the food absolutely blew us away and we all had left overs ~ would recommend! We’re all out-of-towners , and really enjoyed this New Wayne cuisine!

Horrible experience. The girl at the register taking the order had no idea what she was doing. Very incredibly rude. No manners what so ever. The food was fresh and pretty good. The cook had to come and show her how to put an order together. I’ve had wayyy better experiences. No need to return there. She was the restaurant’s 1st impression of their business and worst. Talking about the girl in the black shirt cause it was 2 females there.