It's a nice place but could rate higher with a little effort. The staff was great... Busboy was on top of everything, waitress was very pleasant and accommodating. The wings, kinda of a surprise... The original were excellent and done different than we are use to... With caramelized onions and maybe roasted... Very good... The dry rub ones were good as well. The pizza... 2 different kinds... One with a gluten free crust and the other smothered in different meat... Both very good. Where it became a only a three star experience unfortunately was in how clean it appeared... Tables shouldn't be left with sticky residue... Shouldn't be old dried food stuck to various things ( the pizza tray holders ). I kinda want to put this one on management... Didn't see a manger around and a team needs leadership... He/She would be pointing things out like a tables that needed more attention to detail. I'd go back for another try... But that might be about it if the tables look and feel the same and nothing changes... Hope it was just an off night because everything else was pretty solid.

Ally is the best. Everyone around us also talked highly as well. She had the whole dining room, if not most of it and got everything we needed effortlessly even when she had many customers as well. She was very attentive and informative, one of the best servers I’ve ever had, not only there but any restaurant. We asked questions about portions and she suggested the perfect amount for me and my friend. I’d be sad to go back and not have her be our server. Our food was hot and tasted great too, besides our stellar service.

I gotta say this has become our family's favorite Pizza spot.... coal fire!!!! That's exactly what caught my eye, it makes such a big difference in taste....this place is supper cute! dim light, modern, relaxing, cool, chill vibe...never falls short! From pizza to garlic knots, chicken wings, Sandwiches, all the way to dessert... Great Americanos, amazing tiramisu and cheesecake! Prices are great you can never go wrong on anything on their menu.

Relaxed casual environment, very friendly wait staff and all the food was delicious. It is a unique restaurant and with a limited menu. My friends loved a variety of their mixed drinks, their house Cabernet was of good quality. There caramelized onion smothered chicken wings were quite a hit. In fact it seems many people go there for that. I did not sample of their personal pan pizzas however if I do plan on going back.

They have wide variety of pizzas . Being vegetarian, I chose to eat cauliflower pizza , it was delicious and flavourful . We ordered salad , it was well done too. It is best for pizza , so enjoy if you are a pizza 🍕 lover . They have good ambience , great staff who services the food .

Great pizza spot in Islip! Definitely recommend the Hot Honey pie. Staff is very friendly, place is clean and really nice inside!!

We come here often and order online frequently as well. The manager is always so incredibly sweet and welcoming. The staff is very attentive and kind as well. They are always accommodating for my food allergies and always confirm our order is correct. The cauliflower pizza is incredible and always made very well. My husband orders the wings and says they're the best he's had. He also loves the Paulie pie. Definitely recommend the Italian Salad as well.

I usually Order to go ... when I can. I like that their pizza 🍕 is different from most places. Everything they make is high quality and fresh ingredients every time. Staff is mosty friendly and the atmosphere is nice 👌.

I've been coming here since it opened..I worked in the area then. And now our business has been moved back to Bohemia and I'm thrilled! Tara and Ashley are fantastic!!! And the food is outstanding... Thanks for the gluten free options now...my kids need that! See you soon!

What a great pizza. Even better was the friendly service I received at this location. When and if I’m ever in the Islip area again this will be on my list of places to grab a pizza. Fresh ingredients that are full of flavor. You have to appreciate this great pizza. Give it a try, I bet you won’t be disappointed!

Great food, great atmosphere, great service! Have nothing but love for this place. And Ashley gives us an exceptional experience every time we come! I definitely recommend this place to anyone looking for a delicious and customer focused restaurant experience.