If you get a meatloaf sandwich, get ready for some serious meat. Great portions for the price. We got a portabella mushroom sandwich too (no meatloaf) and it was also very good. Got the chicken fingers for our kids. Pretty good, but they were roasted, not fried, which out kids didn't like as much. They came with fang sauce too, which is a mayo based sauce. No indoor seating. 3 outdoor tables, but more down at Giant Eagle.

Finally got the chance to try Newfangled Kitchen. I got The Big Deal sandwich which was a huge, all-beef fried bologna sandwich with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, mayo, and red onion. It was AMAZING. The only other thing I would change next time is to sautee my onions.

This place has become a goto quick meal for me and the family. Reasonably priced, the sandwiches are very filling, and the salads are generous as well. If you like your spicier selection, try Lucifer's hammer. The service here has always been friendly and they have been very accommodating with custom orders. I am very happy to have them as a local food option.

We love this place! It's a must-stop every time we head north to Ohio. The menu selections are uniquely crafted and the food is great. We also enjoy the vibe; eclectic decor and cool music. Love the vending machine! BTW, Lucifer's Hammer is the bomb! This sandwich is not your mother's meatloaf!!! Although it's primarily a take out service, they do have a couple of outdoor picnic tables, which we really enjoyed.

The reviews were RIGHT surprisingly never heard of this joint till browsing uber eats and it might be the best sandwich joint I've had in columbus don't know when I'll try their meatloaf sandwiches but this sandwich was full of fresh ingredients and made amazing and gets you FULL actually taste like real fresh food and not fast food definitely my new go too

Guys, run to this place. Service is impeccable- they wrapped my drink in napkins and foil to stay cold and not get my toasted Augusta Birdie sandwich soggy. Fresh, delicious and fast. I can't wait to go back to try the meatloaf sammies.

Im a meatloaf fan and this is the Best meatloaf I've ever eaten. I've asked over and over for the recipe but to no avail. Nice people too. Also enjoy the chicken sandwich, hunter s chicken. Highly recommended

A quaint sandwich shop located in Bexley, I've driven past on numerous occasions and finally decided to stop! I am so glad that I did, they are known for their meatloaf sandwiches but I myself am a Reuben fan. I ordered the turkey Reuben and a bag of honey Sriracha kettle chips. My order was fast and fresh and Oh so good!! And the cashier was very friendly and welcoming. I can't wait to go back to try something new . I'm sure I won't be disappointed!

Our favorite lunch place. Best salads and sandwiches in Columbus. When my wife has a hard day at work, she asks me to pick something up from here to make her night feel better. Beautiful food and wonderful owners

I can’t believe I’ve overlooked this place for so long. I got the Reuben, fried bologna sandwich, pecan salad, and a side of meatloaf and all items were excellent. Quality super fresh ingredients, very fair pricing and portions, and super fast and friendly service. Even the packaging is outstanding. I love finding privately owned neighborhood gems like this and they are rare. Thank you guys

I order from Newfangled Kitchen on UberEats all the time because it’s so good! I always get the Georgia Reuben and the dill potato salad, it’s a perfect lunch combo and really delicious. I love a turkey Reuben but they can be hard to find, so glad I discovered this place! I look forward to trying other menu items some day, I'm sure they’re also excellent, but every time I think I’ll try a new sandwich I just can’t turn down the Georgia Reuben again 😊. My husband has gotten the High Five a few times though, he says it’s very good. Definitely would recommend this place for a great lunch!

There food is always good. And they’re very nice people. Family own business with fresh salads, and sandwiches and the potato chips are 🔥when you come in they greet you with a smile.

Love this place. I had "The Fang" and my wife had the "Bella Donna". Both sandwiches were incredible. Never thought a meatloaf sandwich could be that good. The sandwiches here punch way above their weight. Bravo to Newfangled Kitchen for providing fresh ingredients, tons of flavor, and great service. Can't wait to try more on their menu.

One of my favorite restaurants close to my work. I love the family, the food and the atmosphere. I'd definitely go there again.

Best meat loaf husband and I have ever had! I'm not even a big meatloaf person but there's is so juicy and full of flavor. The white bbq sauce is my favorite, love the NA drink options, and customer service is always stellar.