Nostalgia is a wonderful place to have breakfast or lunch. You walk into a warm & friendly place with generous seating & a cozy kitschy atmosphere. The dining room is spotless & well kept. Even with the vintage decor it’s not all beat up or worn out. Great homemade menu items served with a smile. Lots of selections to choose from that arrive fresh & fast. Our favourites are the Ham Egg n Cheese croissant & the French Toast. The fresh homemade soup will warm your bones on a cold rainy morning & is delicious. There are pastries & great tasting coffee if you’re just looking for a light takeaway breakfast or you can sit down & tuck into a full breakfast. The decor is warm & inviting. The large & small tables are perfect for a couple or a group. Art on the walls & large windows gives the dining room a warm & inviting vibe. The canned music playing in the background is not too loud so you can enjoy a conversation without having to talk over it. The coffee station is fully stocked so you can make your go juice just the way you like. The wee patio is nice on a summer morning. The staff are always friendly & make you feel welcome. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ stars is not enough for this hidden gem on the East Side.

I was craving a ham and cheese omelette this morning and found this cute and cosy cafe. Really liked it and hope to be back soon.

Awesome place to have some great coffee. Shame we went there during covid so couldn't sit inside. But the ambience looked so nice! Coffee was great! They were really nice people!

I have been here multiple times and I absolutely love this cafe. The vibe, the service, the food everything here is so lovely. I love their hot chocolate with oatmilk/ almond milk. Their cappuccino is also really nice. They have a lot of options for food and especially there are options for vegetarians!! Lot of varieties of teas, coffees and icecreams.

I love this place for an early coffee or a light breakfast. Very cozy interior and the price is very reasonable.

What a neat discovery!! Absolutely loved this quaint coffee shop but a nice menu spread and a cool ambiance to stay and do my work. Looking forward to coming back.

A quaint cafe with lots of charm. A quiet atmosphere, good to enjoy a lovely breakfast, brunch, a book, or getting a bit of work done. Service was friendly and quick. The Monte Cristo French Toast is delicious! Must try! An assortment of sweets and baked goods are available. Kawartha Dairy ice cream is a big plus!

Food was great, lattes were great and very very wonderful service!

Great atmosphere, free wifi and the montecristo sandwich was delicious.

We started our journey today to discover the best place to enjoy a cup of coffee. We are looking at atmosphere, customer service, and, most importantly, taste. Today, we visited Nostalgia Coffee Company at 855 O'Connor Dr, East York, ON M4B 2S7. Steve Arnold had a medium roast large black coffee, and I had a medium roast double double with a swig more cream to get it to the "exact color." We split a butter tart, and I had two scoops of pistachio ice cream. The service was great. They were friendly and fast. The atmosphere was cute. The walls were done in blackboard paint with the menu written them. The coffee was good, butter tart good, and ice cream good. Nothing spectacular, other than the service, and nothing at all was bad. On a scale of 1-10, the following is my rating: ☕️ customer service 10 ☕️ atmosphere 8 ☕️ taste 5 Steve's rating ☕️ customer service 10 ☕️ atmosphere 6 ☕️ taste 5.5

What a nice surprise! This cafe is warmly decorated, and features an extensive menu of breakfast and lunch options, including French toast, breakfast burritos (which I tried), pastries, and sandwiches. My burrito and oat milk latte were delicious and I think cheaper than getting a premade breakfast at a chain store. The service is friendly and the space is comfortable. The large community board gives a sense of place and belonging. If only I lived nearer, I’d be back!

Lovely place for a home style breakfast. The ambience is super chill — like it is a country cafe in the city. Friendly service and great value. The Americano I had was brewed really well!

I've been on the hunt for a good breakfast sammie in the GTA for years. This place is IT. real, thick roasted ham??? Butter croissants?? AND we're coffee snobs, and the espresso 🤌🤌🤌🤌 top it off with great vibes and lovely service... Hooked.

Lived in the area for 1+ year before discovering this gem! The pastries, bagels, coffee, and tea have been amazing. Happy to have this cafe be apart of our day-off routine and excited to keep sampling the menu.

Such a great coffee shop! A family owned business run by siblings. Very cozy atmosphere, so many drink options from their own herbal blends of teas to protein coffee! Lunch items are always delicious and at a great price. Always have to get a pastry too

Cute little coffee shop! Was surprised at the amount of food options! Great quiche and bevie. They also have a boardroom available.

the most beautiful cafe in this area! I wish they could be open till 5-6pm 😔😔 I love here! You can eat home made snacks and even protein coffee!! 0 sugar!! I am feeling like I am at home! I love this place!

We went as a small group and had french toast, sandwiches & lattes and it was wonderful. Lovely people running the place, great food and cozy atmosphere. We’ll definitely be back! 💕

Such a nice vibe. Cozy and very welcoming. Loved the food. Had a egg salad sandwich and my friends had French toast. We loved it. Can’t wait to go back

I love this coffee shop. They have a wide selection of items to choose from. They consistently have the kindest service and everything always tastes great. The atmosphere is also very welcoming. If you're looking for a friendly spot to read, study, meet up with a friend, this is definitely the spot. 100% would recommend Nostalgia Coffee Company to any and everyone!

Lovely little spot with such charm! A vast menu of excellent food - made to order or frozen. You can tell everything is prepared with care and quality ingredients. A bonus is the availability of Kawartha Ice Cream! Will definitely return and recommend to others :)

Beyond my expectations. Best espresso in town!

One of the best independent coffee shops out there. One of the best places to enjoy a proper Americano.

I just discovered this gem today, what a fantastic spot. Great coffee and baked goods and a huge menu of meals. The owners are lovely people.

A lovely welcoming atmosphere. Great food! Delicious treats. Met the owners a lovely charming couple . Definitely would recommend.

Their iced coffee is my favourite. So light, so refreshing. So good. Love the atmosphere, cozy and staff is incredibly friendly. A little bit of light music in the background would be a nice touch

Great place for a bite and coffee. Reasonably priced and very nice ambience.

Such a cute cafe! Have passed by it so many times and i’m so glad I went in today. Great chai latte & Western Sandwich. The owners are so sweet, definitely will be coming back!

The coffee is good, delicious home made treats and bagels. Good prices and very kind service :) a community feel type of place

I was looking for a cute local coffee shop to go to and came across this gem! The owner is so friendly and the food taste great and fresh. I’ve had the breakfast wrap and her homemade cookies. Yummm

Nostalgia Coffee Company is a coze cafe for people seeking a local cafe to haunt or searching for a good coffee. There is a enough space to grab a table and sit to do work, meet up for a date, or have a coffee with friends. The owner is lovely, and the drinks are great. The food is pretty good too.

Appropriately named and wonderfully friendly service with a tasty menu

We live in the area and finally decided to stop by thinking it's just a coffee shop.... But wow... it is so much more. From the Great customer service to the Amazing food quality, it*s a hidden gem! Way to go and thank you for a gr8 experience.

Simple but delicious and high quality food and drinks. Very reasonable prices, free WiFi, and a nice spot to just sit and work or study. Very good amount of seating available inside and outside.

Cozy, homey cafe with delicious pastries and the kindest staff. A spacious, clean, and quiet environment to read and work. So nice to know about a local cafe which I hope to return regularly.

What a gem in the neighborhood! I regret not discovering them sooner. Great food at very low prices. And awesome customer service. Always very friendly and welcoming.