The decor of Goodfellas Pizza is humble as typical pizza spots in the neighborhood but also clean & bright. The owner was super friendly, welcoming and introduced everything in details. There is a good variety of flavors and we had 2 slices of original cheese & tomato pizza, 1 slice of meat lover deep dish and 1 slice of chicken ranch pizza with 2 Diet Cokes to share for dinner. The pizza was overall decent with a great amount of ingredients.

First let me get this out of the way. I was given the opportunity to have two slices for free here via Yelp Elite. I did however also buy 4 other slices that were not complementary. I went in with high hopes of this being a great spot for a slice, and especially since this is my first time having a Yelp funded experience. The 3 stars is solely for the food. It would be 3.5 but you can't do half a star. The half would be for the friendly staff & clean place. The atmosphere is nice. It's a small spot with some decent decor. Nothing screamed "GoodFellas / Mafia" from the name. Two large tv screens with the menu & a third with their business name. Food: Regular slice is ok. Nothing that would make me come back, or sadly tell anyone about. The specialty slice I had, chicken & ranch, was good. It tasted fresh & the crust was nice. It was lacking in flavor a bit. I ordered the Sicilian / Grandma slice. It wasn't that good. It has a weird after taste to it. The Buffalo chicken was meh. The chicken on top was kinda mushy in texture. Now the star was the vegetable slice. That was yummy. It was fresh & tasted good. Sadly not enough to warrant the drive here. Overall not a bad spot to hit if you're nearby, but not worth a drive. Parking is hard around here. **My Yelp review I stated I didn’t get my drinks. I know the sign says “cheese” however the guy serving me said he’d give it to me. Didn’t say you we’re being petty? @Andres/Owner —- you say you want criticism but your attitude & response says otherwise.

Had slices all over the neighborhood, and this spot is easily one of the best. A+ customer service. Great pizza. Reasonable prices. Can't beat it!

Love the pizza, but lately when paying by card … they pass you the tablet for you to leave them a tip? They usually just swipe the card and that’s it. Pizza is already pricey and now you want a tip? I’ve come here less often due to that.

The sauce was filled with herbs and spices that tasted fresh. Cheese wasn't overloaded and greasy, just the right amount AND NOT OILY. Will definitely return if I'm in Sunnyside, definitely a must try if you're in the area!

Well known pizza place. #letsguide

Decent size for $3. Thin crust, with good coverage of sauce and cheese. Seasoning more Spanish than Italian. But good flavor. Crust is a little gummy Crust edges crisp, but kind of bland, like they left out the salt. Give it an 89.

Will be going back to try more from the menu. Very friendly service, GREAT value for money and the food was amazing. So yummy!!!

Best pizza place in the neighborhood. The sauce is very good and not too acidic. Great customer service & clean place. This will be our go-to pizza place.