Ordered a pizza and garlic knots yesterday night after reading all good reviews. While eating, we realized that garlic knots bread was white, dry and stale inside. Garlic was just a joke. Pizza was also not well baked. We all had stomachache last night and my kid did vomiting and diarrhea in the middle of night. This afternoon, my wife and I are feeling same had several visits to the restroom. Not sure how to trust those good reviews anymore. Surly not coming back. Update next day - I also vomited next day.

We got Saltimbocca and Classic Combo pizza, all small size. We got two perfectly small just enough delicious pizzas, each with her own fresh and savory flavor! Italian sausage- best ever! The place is cozy retro style, nice atmosphere and friendly service:) Also we got the 2 scoop tiramisu- best tiramisu so far8) Sorry, tiramisu was gone before i started my phone to make a picture… P.S. The sweet and salty bread pudding was also veery good😊

takes forever to get your food (they might estimate 20 minutes and it's closer to 40 minutes), whether you're picking up or in-store. manager is a catty person who acts like it's your fault for complaining. will say "We are busy!!" when literally no one is in the store. "OH BUT WE HAVE A LOT OF PICK UP ORDERS TODAY!" she shrieks. Yeah then don't tell people it takes 20 minutes to get their food. Totally corrupt

I need to check the deductible on my HMO bc the flop on this pizza is giving me scoliosis. After that I’m goin to the neck Dr trying to get this slice in my mouth. This slice of pizza has my neck like the shotgirls on bourbon street get you. I’m looking like a baby bird ova here. I’ll never get respect from my kids again after what they just whitenesses. No crispy bottom. Some sort of plastic brand of string cheese came sliding off and turned itself into spaghetti somehow. That’s why I gave it an extra star. I was amazed! I can’t tell if there’s sauce but I got enough chunks of tomato I could start a ketchup farm and make Heinz bow down. The toppings are fresh and the pepperonis & Italian sausage kept me from playing pie frisbee with the dog. I want Reginelli’s to be the best pizza spot in Metairie. We can do betta. 🤌🏼🇮🇹 your pal Chris P. Piezonli outta Greenpoint Brooklyn.

We had heard how good this place was so we ordered Uber eats for my wife’s Birthday. The food arrived $78 very overpriced for what we got. The gnocchi was too greasy to eat threw it away. The Margarita pizza was ice cold, the tossed salad was a big pile of unwashed spring mix threw it away. It was so bad that we ordered from That’s Amore Pizza just so her Birthday dinner would not be a bust. This Reginelli’s was horrible and would never order from there again. What a waste. Very expensive too. Overpriced

Food was exquisite, service was great, Amazing restauraunt 10/10 WILL return, DEVOURED the spinach dip

This was an uber eats order. Excellent muffuletta and caesar salad. Their pizza looks amazing I will try it next time.

The pizza was cheesy but dry. Next time I will let them know to cook for less time please. A first timer expectations 🙃