Park Avenue Pizza Company image

Park Avenue Pizza Company

Restaurant Bar Pizza restaurant Pub

One of the Top rated Pizza restaurants in Pewaukee


121 Park Ave, Pewaukee, WI 53072



(262) 691-0503

Price rating

$$ $$

Rating on Google Maps

4.30 (529 reviews)

Open on Google Maps

Working Hours

  • Sunday: 11 AM to 8 PM
  • Monday: (Memorial Day), Closed, Hours might differ
  • Tuesday: Closed
  • Wednesday: 4 to 9 PM
  • Thursday: 4 to 9 PM
  • Friday: 11 AM to 10 PM
  • Saturday: 11 AM to 10 PM

Featured Reviews

Frequently mentioned in reviews: pizza (29) good (14) time (13) chicken (11) minutes (8) Pewaukee (6) long (6) sauce (6) wings (6)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 4/5 Morgan 2 years ago on Google • 42 reviews
    We had the appetizer sampler (#2), broasted chicken dinner, and Alfredo with a California medley soup. I would not get the appetizer sampler again. I think we would’ve been better off trying the toasted ravioli. The soup was fresh and full of veggies. Cheesy base with broccoli, cauliflower, and broccoli. Alfredo was pretty delicious and so was the bread that came with it. Broasted chicken was also delicious and crispy, not overly greasy. I would do without the potato wedges and coleslaw next time.
    2 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 Steven F. 10 months ago on Google • 33 reviews
    Theming of this place is off I got one wall miller mirrors over a bar again it’s themed for movie theater were does fishing come into place? They should loose the beer mirrors and put put fishinng mount stuff l.then it themed correctly. We ordered a lot yes it’s what it’s called who knows how much your getting. The pesdent pizza small is size of a jacks pizzia.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 2/5 Sara B. 7 months ago on Google • 6 reviews
    Came for dinner at 530, sat at the bar, and WAITED!! The bartender is so RUDE. There was no acknowledgment until we approached the bar and ordered. Poor customer service. The food has always been a GREAT experience with chicken dinners, fish frys, and pizza. I understand things can be busy, but acknowledge your customers, look at them, and SMILE.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 Jemel V. 2 years ago on Google
    Usually get takeout, but dined inside... Very nice place. Had appetizer platter #2, it was good and filling... Also had a delicious large pizza... Definitely will return, gotta try the Alfredo and fried chicken 😉
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Lynn O. 2 years ago on Google
    Had a fantastic pizza Friday night! Crispy and thin crust.called The Company President. Mozzarella, sausage, red onion, green pepper, mushrooms, black olive, and pepperoni. We also enjoyed the beer battered fried mushrooms.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Barbie K. 5 years ago on Google
    While there are scores of good restaurants in Pewaukee, this is our go-to place. Located in an old movie theater, it has a wonderful, homey atmosphere, great food, friendly service, and is always clean. The pizza is truly delicious, and their Tuscan Salad, is my all-time favorite, which is saying a lot, being that I'm vegetarian and have eaten thousands of salads! We enjoy the outdoor seating, in the summer, as you're always going to encounter a friend or neighbor, walking by. Lovely place to enjoy an evening cocktail. They are, in fact, so neighbor-friendly, that they even have a guest water bowl for visiting dogs. Go. Enjoy! :D
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Queen 1 year ago on Google
    10 mins before someone came and asked if we wanted drinks, 10 mins later brought out only one drink and forgot my water, by minute 35 i finally had a glass of water. from the time we ordered our food to when we received it was over and hour and ten minutes. i almost left cash for the drink and just left i was so upset a measly appetizer sampler (onion rings, jalapeño poppers) took so long and tasted so bad i cannot believe i stuck around AND paid for it. nobody checked on us at any point. it was absolutely ridiculous
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Deplorable R. 8 months ago on Google • 293 reviews
    Came here with just over an hour left before closing on our last night at a hotel/waterpark in touristy Pewaukee. Anywhere my family & I go for a vacation or quick getaway, my wife knows at some point we're gonna be having pizza and obviously in the land of cheese it's definitely happening. With a time crunch at hand and with 2 of the higher or highest rated pizza joints in town closing at 9pm, this was the closer drive for us but I'm sure glad I chose this place. I knew I was gonna love it from the 1st glance outside. Once inside and seeing all the classic cinema posters and memorabilia, I fell in love with the vibe. At still reasonable prices, Park Avenue has a good all around menu and drink menu, clean/sanitized dining room and our server Abby/Abbey did exceptional. The pizza here is dee-lish, I think the Fourteen seasons may have made the pizza a bit salty for my wife but I still very much enjoyed it and my boys enjoyed their sausage pizza. We live more than a 60-mile haul south in Lake County IL and we loved this 2-night quick getaway in Pewaukee. I'm guessing the lake makes it a boaters' paradise during the warm months. Pewaukee seems to be full of surprises as far as the places and restaurants we visited. If ever in the area again, I could definitely go for some PAPC pizza!

  • 4/5 Todd 1 year ago on Google
    Cute little pizza place in Pewaukee by the lake. We only had drinks, but the pizza looked good.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 1/5 Clare D. 1 year ago on Google
    Fantastic pizza and garlic bread! Service was a little slow, but it was worth it! EDIT: My mom and I just went there tonight and it was supposed to be a 25-30 min wait. Two people walked in and were seated before us. Very disappointing as their pizza is amazing.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Michelle “Mimi Rossa” L. 8 months ago on Google • 54 reviews
    First time here, looking for some authentic Italian food. Met my expectations! I had the spaghetti and meatballs and the flavor was super good! We will definitely be back to try something different

  • 5/5 Jeff J. 4 months ago on Google • 24 reviews
    Every time I am in Pewaukee, Park Avenue Pizza is a must stop. The crust is original and I cannot find anything like it anywhere! Combined with their tangy sauce and generous cheese, it's always something I look forward to when travelling to Wisconsin. It's a family owned business and the people at Park Avenue make you feel at home. The restaurant itself used to be a movie theater, so it has a unique vibe. Wish they open one in San Diego, CA... then all harmony would exist in my life.

  • 5/5 Brian �. 5 months ago on Google • 15 reviews
    Tried this place for the first time last week on a whim and so glad we did. Plenty of toppings and the sauce was so good. Pizza was ready for pick up in under 30 min.

  • 5/5 Lisa Marie C. 3 months ago on Google • 15 reviews New
    Very fun and awesome local spot to enjoy a meal out with the family or with a group of friends! Met my girlfriends there for lunch and below is our awesome pizza creation! Love their spaghetti and meatballs too!!

  • 1/5 Carrie 3 months ago on Google • 13 reviews New
    Told 20 mins, was 45, believe someone 45 mins late for their reservations was given table, as I was told we would be seated, but took another 20, then sat in a back corner at a dirty table and forgotten about. 20 mins later, drinks were taken. Food took 40. Left house at 645, home at 10PM. Ridiculous. Then hair on my sandwich. Lovely. 🙄 Decide if you are a restaurant or a trivia place, not both.

  • 5/5 Andrew S. 10 months ago on Google
    Attracted by the outdoor seating due to having our dog with us, we were pleasantly surprised that they were so accommodating for our dog! They had brought out treats as well as a water bowl! We really appreciated that!

  • 5/5 Bourbon H. 2 years ago on Google
    The band stopped in here after a long day of recording, and we were so glad we did. The pizza here is excellent. Made from scratch. Also, great selection of burgers and pasta.

  • 4/5 Fam A. 2 years ago on Google
    Food was good. The wait was long, but be prepared for it as everything is made fresh to order. They're very flexible with special request for food as well. One of our party asked for sauteed onions and peppers to be added to their sandwich and the request was accommodated. I overheard another diner request multiple special requests on his pizza. Also accommodated. Nice atmosphere and staff as well.

  • 5/5 Debbie A. 1 year ago on Google
    First time there, for sure going back, excellent fish fry. Next time will be pizza

  • 3/5 Victoria K. 1 year ago on Google
    The waitress was friendly. There wasn't really anyone in the restaurant while eating there but the wait for food was still over 30 minutes. Pizza was subpar, pineapple wasn't ripe.

  • 4/5 Kayla D. 1 year ago on Google
    First time at Park Avenue Pizza. The food was good and tasted very fresh. The waiter was very good.

  • 4/5 Brian M. 1 year ago on Google
    First time customers, wait was longer than we would have liked for one pizza, but it was fresh and very good.

  • 1/5 Tony D. 1 year ago on Google
    The three of us walked in for dine in and waited at the hostess stand. The girl eventually came and said it would be 20 minutes until you can order your food but you can sit now. So, we went to a bar table and waited, and watched three separate parties (total of 6 people) get drinks and one person ordered food immediately. We sat there for 15 minutes and still got zero acknowledgement, so we left. Terrible service. No need to go back.

  • 5/5 rex r. 1 year ago on Google
    Loved it! Had pizza and broasted chicken. Both were excellent. You can tell it's homemade. Will be back for pasta!

  • 2/5 Ann C. 9 months ago on Google
    We ordered the broasted chicken for takeout tonight . When placing the order at 5:00pm, we were told that they did not have any more chicken breasts so it would have to be wings and drumsticks only. We received our order ($80.00 worth of food .. (2) 10 piece bucket dinners and our chicken tasted like cod. Clearly the chicken was cooked in the same oil as they make the fried fish. It was so gross that we ended up throwing most away. Don’t think we will be going back

  • 5/5 She Who R. 1 year ago on Google
    Such great pizza! My kids and I recently tried the Chicken Alfredo sauce pizza and oh my goodness was it absolutely delicious. All of their pizza is great but this one especially hit the spot.

  • 1/5 Joandy O. 11 months ago on Google
    This review is long overdue. When it's good it's good, but when it's bad it's very bad. Owners get angry and defensive easily. Also, buffalo wings come with cayenne pepper sauce and were likely invented in Buffalo New York. Buffalo wings aren't named for the sauce but they're named Buffalo for the same reason buffalo wings are. Where they came from. Fried wings have been around for about as long as this country has, frying them doesn't make them buffalo. It's a weird hill to die on. Let's pretend y'all were right, NOW, the term buffalo wings is associated with cayenne pepper sauce and you're just setting yourself up for failure. Honestly, I haven't been here in a long time because of my past experience so I don't even know if it's still an issue. But I saw a post that reminded me of my experience, so here I am.

  • 4/5 Barbara R. 1 year ago on Google
    Excellent food always but I would recommend turning up the heat for your dine in customers. Yesterday our party and all of the other customers in the restaurant were eating with their coats on. I mentioned something to our waitress but it fell on deaf ears. By the time we left we were frozen. A little warmer atmosphere and we would have stuck around for an after dinner drink.

  • 5/5 Lynne E. 1 year ago on Google
    Delicious gluten free pizza...traditional, too! Service great!

  • 4/5 Ron O. 1 year ago on Google
    Great food, service was slow, waited 30 minutes after order was placed, drinks were good

  • 5/5 R3D-1 T. 1 year ago on Google
    Wonderful little place, located right on the lake. The pizza was cooked to perfection, and my daughter’s burger was one of the tasting burgers I’ve had! I had a chicken parmesan sandwich, which was super juicy and tasty. This is a must visit spot if you’re in the area!

  • 5/5 Katie S. 1 year ago on Google
    Love coming here! The staff are always so kind. We always come for the pizza: the Pizza is delicious- thin crust and perfectly crisp every time. My dad loves the chicken and fish fry! Relaxing atmosphere. Highly recommend

  • 5/5 Peter H. 1 year ago on Google
    The food is really good. It's got a unique atmosphere and charm. The pizza and garlic bread exceptional.

  • 2/5 John M. 4 months ago on Google • 2 reviews
    20 minutes at the bar to get a drink. Completely ignored. Then 1 hr 15 minutes for a very average pizza. Another 15 minutes to get cocktail delivered to the table. Obviously under staffed. SO STOP SEATING PEOPLE. will not return.

Call (262) 691-0503 Open on Google Maps


  • Parking
    • ✓️ Free parking lot
    • ✓️ Plenty of parking
    • ✓️ Free street parking
  • Payments
    • ✓️ Debit cards
    • ✓️ Credit cards
    • ✓️ NFC mobile payments
  • Offerings
    • ✓️ Beer
    • ✓️ Wine
    • ✓️ Coffee
    • ✓️ Alcohol
    • ✓️ Cocktails
    • ✓️ Quick bite
    • ✓️ Hard liquor
    • ✓️ Comfort food
    • ✓️ Happy hour food
    • ✓️ Late-night food
    • ✓️ Happy hour drinks
  • Popular for
    • ✓️ Lunch
    • ✓️ Dinner
    • ✓️ Solo dining
  • Accessibility
    • ✓️ Wheelchair accessible seating
    • ✓️ Wheelchair accessible entrance
    • ✓️ Wheelchair accessible restroom
    • ✓️ Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Dining options
    • ✓️ Lunch
    • ✓️ Dinner
    • ✓️ Dessert
    • ✓️ Seating
  • Service options
    • ✓️ Dine-in
    • ✓️ Takeout
    • ✓️ Delivery
    • ✓️ Outdoor seating


Last updated:

Similar Restaurants nearby

Last updated: