Love it!! First time and surely wasn’t disappointed on our first orders. The dough had a nice taste and texture; just the right balance. The calzone topping was overloaded. Ambience was very homey and with a friendly crew giving good service. Surely will drop by again to taste the pizza and other dishes on the menu.

We just moved to Winston Park and after a VERY long day of cleaning and unpacking, finally realized around 8:30pm that we should order some dinner. Craig, the owner, picked up the phone and let me know that they had been closed for over half an hour. I must of sounded so bummed because he offered to make us a pizza even though he had already begun cleaning up. I was so surprised someone picked up the phone, let alone making a pizza after closing. It brought tears to my eyes. He didn't have to do it but the fact that he did really speaks volumes to his character. We were really worried we wouldn't be able to find pizza like back home and this pizza did not disappoint. My hubby and daughter usually don't eat the crust, but this crust was so light and crispy, they ate it. The sauce was perfectly seasoned and there was plenty of cheese on it. Just the way I like it. We definitely recommend Amici's and plan to order a pie every weekend. Thank you Craig for the warm welcome to the neighborhood and the yummy brownie surprise, you're the best!

The best pizza in Florida! I am from buffalo NY where pizza is amazing and hard to beat, but Amici's comes pretty close to being one of my favorite pizza spots as well! That says a lot because I have lived in FL for 18 years. The customer service is great, the pizza is always hot, and I will gladly spend my money there anytime!

Stopped tonight for the first time. Was very much impressed with the service and food. Taylor was very attentive, prompt and checked on us before we needed anything. Excellent. Craig stopped by and checked on us twice. He ensured we also had everything we needed as well. Had a great conversation with him. For dinner, we had antipasto, pizza, and chicken and pasta. Everything was superb. High recommend. We will be back....

Placed an order Sunday evening during the torrential downpour. Young lady on the phone told me it would be 20-25 minutes. Since I was already out and in my car I headed over and waited in front of the restaurant. The owner came to my car, asked me for my name and took my money. He then sent a young lady out to deliver my dinner and change so that I would not have to get wet. As always, the food was delicious and I truly appreciated that they went above and beyond in getting my order brought to me at my car. Great restaurant and staff. Highly recommend them! Debbie

Since we've lived in South Florida (24+ years) we've always been on the lookout for pizza that's as good as you'd get in NY. Amici's pizza is the best we've found. And their pizza isn't just amazing (the upside-down pizza is our fave), all their food is delicious and tastes home made. The owners, Craig and Tiffany are super nice and always make sure the customers are happy. But our absolute favorite, and the real reason we keep coming back week after week, is Anna. She's not just an amazingly attentive server, she's a sweet young lady. We think of her as our third daughter. If you're looking for a great local pizza (and everything else) joint, look no further.

Family owned and operated and you can taste the passion and love in every bite. Hand tossed pizza dough, home made ravioli, soups from scratch, hand made salads. (literally saw someone peeling carrots) It's my new favorite. Don't miss this place, the owner has as much passion for making food as I do eating it.

This place is amazing. Food is incredible. Staff and owner are SO polite. Hands down best pizza spot in the area. FYI - try the wings. They’re one of my favorite items on the menu.

The best pizza I have found in Florida! Have been going there for years. You will always get great food, service and atmosphere. Must go and try for yourself!

Just had our first Amici Pizza during our Quarantine and it was the BEST Veggie Pizza we've ever had. The other Veggie Pizzas around the area don't compare. We'll be back for more soon.

Literally the best wings and pizza I have ever had. The owner is very friendly and a funny guy. Me and my girlfriend love this place and it’s our go to spot!

The truth of the matter is; the sense of Family dining has lost both its luster and glory over the years. I’m a millennial, I know what it’s like to read long posts and reviews, but for you that’s reading; Amici’s Coconut Creek; warrants a genuine paragraph or two. Service is not what it used to be! In my experience One can find a pizza joint within two mile of one another, though I highly doubt you will find one as heartwarmingly Nostalgic, such that is Amici’s. If I were to elaborate, we have lost a sense of the meaning of family friendly establishments. That’s what you will be reminded at Amici’s Coconut CreeK. Life is a family sport and the family at Amici’s; encompasses what dinning in a true family setting is to replicate. Though, of that tight nit family four individuals continue to raise the standard and rise to heights of great achievements. These four individuals stand out most to me. Their names are as followed: Craig- Owner, Jordyn- Hostess/Cashier, Guy- Executive Chef, and Nelson- Executive Chef. A disclaimer, very seldom; you will find individuals like the four wonderful names I mentioned above. Kindness has become a commodity in todays culture. Upon finding kind souls, like Craig, Jordyn, Guy, and Nelson; which is then centers around outstanding cuisine; what you then have is, Paramount! If you wish for one-of-a-kind Service, memorable experiences, and an open plate at the table; pull up a seat. Allow Amici’s to find a place in your heart, like they have found a place in mine. Craig (Handsome), Jordyn, Guy, and Nelson, thank you for your friendly smiles, thank you for your service, more importantly thank you for the meal; I will be back… 5/29/2022 Boca Raton, FL 33432 Jéan Teneus

Ordered catering for a work event and the manager Craig was so accommodating! The staff helped me bring my food to my car although it was small and helped me! Love Amici’s

Oh boy, where do I start. Well it's very clean, food is amazing, staff is quick. Craig, the owner makes you feel homey. I love that. Jordyn was our server and she was awesome! So many options on the menu, I can come here everyday and not get bored of the choices. Yummy...

Arriving at this little Italian restaurant was a total alternative stop....I started heading out for a steak restaurant, but the place i chose was so over crowded I ended up here on a fluke! But, to my surprise I found this friendly quality Italian joint...and I say joint because its small inside with limited seating, with a few tables outside...so if your eating in you might have to wait for a table if they are super busy....I sat down right away, no problem. I ordered veal parm meal, and the portions were just right from the salad to the bread sticks...and then the entrée and side of meatballs were perfect. My eyes were bigger than my stomach, but I finished as much as I could....enjoyed it all, I think the meatballs were a combo of meat and pork....I favor all meat WASP still like my mom used to make, but these were really good too, and the sauce everything was in tasted homemade! I'll be back soon. Thanks all, be safe. Charles

I was referred to your restaurant by my partner who had eaten the night before and was so impressed with the food & owner Craig and staff, I decided to give them a try for myself, I ordered a whole mess of these incredible tasty BBQ wings that were like no other I had before. I can’t wait to go back there with my wife and have another meal I would recommend this restaurant to anyone who wants great food and great service. Sincerely Scotty Davis Pool Pros Of Hollywood

The best pizza and wings!! And im from Buffalo. I know my pizza n wings! The only place that has not disappointed me.

I wish I would have taken a picture of the meatballs with ricotta and mozzarella for your viewing pleasure, but let me give you a visual........4 little meatballs overly mixed with breadcrumbs, to the point where the inside of the meatballs were incredibly moist. On top of it, the chicken in the parmigiana should have been removed from the oven about 15 minutes earlier so I could actual swallow the food. I definitely will not be a repeat customer.

Moved away from coconut creek to east delray....My wife and I still make the 35 minute drive just to get their pizza....the upside down pizza is incredible and don’t get me started on the Sicilian. I would give Amici’s 10 stars if I could. Bravo

Really couldn’t be any better! Thank you!

My family and I have been eating at Amici's for a little over 3 years, we haven't been in a while, and my 4 year old was literally asking for their lasagna (I can't believe she remembered) so I went in with her today. From the warm welcome from the owner and his daughter, to the amazing food and service, you haven't had the best pizza in town until you've had Amici's! Also try the lasagna 😉 you won't regret it. Ohhhh and of course the brownie! Needless to say, they had to roll us out of there today.

Best pizza and Italian food in the area hands down ! My wife and I usually go weekly to eat and ofcourse to see Mr. Craig. Awesome food, very clean and nice inside and awesome service ! If you want pizza or Italian don't walk...RUN to AMICI'S !!!

This place is so tasty! I gave it a try because of the google reviews and boy oh boy they are not lying! I tried a pizza with mushrooms & pepperonis and I could not get enough. I also had their wings & HIGHLY recommend the Buf-a-Que wings. They are perfectly cooked with just the right amount of sweetness and heat. 10/10 will order again. I recommend giving a call to avoid the online order fee, but either way, it is still worth a try.

We use to come here frequently but we change our Friday’s pizza night for a different day and for sure we are not going late (8pm) because the waitress were rude and in a rush and not nice. The Pizzas are great!! The minestrone soup and the brownies are delicious. I came last Friday early and something funny happened. The waitress were really nice… I was surprised and happy but after the 4th time she came to us to ask if we were ok was weird and not just that, I started to count the times she came and in total 16 times… so annoying!!

Not only is this without a doubt the best Pizza/Italian food in the area it’s also a spot where you can Guarantee you’re going to get incredible service each and every Time you come in! There’s something special going on here! Thank you Taylor for the amazing service!!

First time ordering from here. Delicious pizza. Had the bbq chicken. Crust was crispy and tasty, not soggy at all and bbq sauce was delicious. Will try again.

We order here all the time and first time ordering these Mozzarella Wedges (they didn't have mozzarella sticks) anyways... These were bad... This thing was soo burnt it was hard to bite into and there was no cheese inside the first one, it was nasty... 2nd one had cheese but it was all the way at the bottom.. The pizza this time tasted different... It wasnt the same taste... It was sooo greasy and just not that good this time... I still give this place 4 stars cuz food here is good but mayb that night they were just having an off day.. i dont know... We didnt eat it all..

Absolutely fantastic food. Our waitress, who was super sweet, suggested the basil tomato pasta and it was out of this world. When the huge bowl arrived I thought, I’ll maybe eat 25% of this. I couldn’t stop eating it. Great food, wonderful waitress :). I live in NY but I’m a pilot and plan to fly back just for this.

I wish there were 2 meatballs instead of just 1 but its was good.

I am originally from the area but now live in Chattanooga, TN. Every time we are back in South Florida we make it a point to go to Amici's at least once, but usually more than that. The best pizza and Italian food you will get anywhere, plus friendly service. This family owned restaurant is a must visit! Go once and it will be a weekly event!

I've been going to Amic's for at least 10 years and their food never disappoints. My absolute favorite is a classic margarita pizza- beautiful dough, delicious fresh mozzarella, and the sauce adds a perfect amount of acidity.

Located in the Westcreek Plaza next door to Duffy's, Amici's Pizzeria reminds me of those family owned pizzerias in The Bronx where I used to stop in for a pizza slice and a can of soda after school. It's a small business with a casual ambiance and limited seating. Other than pizza, Amici's also offer: * Specialty pizzas/calzones/panini/wings * Hot & cold subs * Entrees & pasta dinners * Salads/antipasti/sides * kids meal/desserts * Daily lunch specials * Hot & cold beverages/beer & wine I approached a friendly female employee and asked if pizza slices are sold at this time. She replied "yes" and showed me various pizzas in the display case where I can make my choice. I didn't get the name; yet I chose a no sauce slice topped with ricotta, spinach, and plum tomatoes. Waited a few minutes while the slice got heated. Never had a pizza with no tomato sauce before...it was unusual and something I would have to get accustomed to, but it was tasty. The crust was hard but I didn't mind. Prices are moderate, but their lunch specials are reasonable.

This place is a truly an authentic Italian pizzeria restaurant! We stumbled across this place by accident and so happy we did.. The owner is such a pleasant man and his daughter is a doll! The good the best you will get in Boca! I have never had a bad experience in all the time coming here! It is truly perfection!! Thank you for bringing Italy to Boca my friend!

We had 2 pizzas, and they were both way over cook, almost burnt. This was our 2nd time, and now remember why we don't go there. The sause was very tasty, but the burnt bread and toppings no so much. While waiting for the pizza, I noticed that even the premade pizza was a little burnt. The place itself was nice, reminded me of Jersey. Employees were polite and nice.

Friendly and accommodating service and staff. This New York style pizza place has such a wide variety of pizzas, pastas and more to choose from. Everything we ordered was absolutely delicious. The Garlic Parmesan Fries are a must try! Thank you Craig for being so attentive. We will definitely be back soon.

My neighbor recommended this restaurant and I finally made it there last week. Best eggplant parmesan I had. I asked for the sauce on the side and it was just perfect. The sauce is out of this world. Great service, friendly atmosphere. Strongly recommend. I have gone twice in one week.

Always Good 👍

Cozy! Fantastic service and fantastic food! You must try this place!! Highly recommend!

BEST local pizza spot! This is a weekly pickup/delivery for us and an EASY decision.

Best Italian restaurant around... I recommend the “Upside Down” pizza and they Izzy Pizza... Their Meatball parm subs are also my favorite.

Amici's has the best pizza around. After several weeks of ordering the same thing, we decided to try the upside-down pizza. Amazing! The cheese is on the bottom and the sauce is on top. I don't know why, but it makes all the difference! So good!! In the years we've been going to Amici's, we've never had a bad meal. Everything is delicious! In addition to the great food, the staff makes you feel like part of the family. It's the perfect local Italian restaurant.

Amici's has one of the best Pizzas I have had in years! The sauce isn't too sweet. The crust texture is a perfect melody of crunchy and light fuffyness. The choice of cheese compliments the other flavors in a very satisfying way. We had multiple Pizzas with multiple topping combos. All delicious symphonies dancing across your pallet. Their glutten free crust was a huge hit with my Glutten free girlfriend. I tried it myself and it was actually delicious. It is way out of the way from where I live, but I will be making the journey happily again and again!! Note* The glutten free crust is NOT made in house. It is made by an outside local company and brought in on their own metal trays. This is done to prevent cross contamination between the crusts made in house. Amici's takes serving their Glutten free customers safely VERY seriously. They have separate tools for making the GF pizzas and your crust never directly touches any surface associated with "normal" crusts. I personally thank them for this dedication.

Delicious pizza it’s the closest to NY/ NJ style !!! Ana who works there is wonderful!! She makes it thin xtra crispy well done just the way I order it!! They have lg. Pie Monday/Tuesday for $12.95 . Give it a try I did I’m hooked!! There sauce is has a nice sweetness to it just a hint nothing overbearing or powering!!!! I don’t think you’ll be disappointed!!!

This place never let's us down! Their pizza is the best around town!

I live in Georgia but was told by my brother to try this place out when I came down to visit. The food was amazing !!!!! The pizza is fantastic but the Tom Jenkins wings are my favorite. The owner and the employees were extremely nice and made me and my family feel welcomed and most importantly we left with full belly’s. I go here every time I visit South Florida. Try it you won’t regret it.

Pizza was crude and dry, way overpriced.

Food was good! Unfortunately we walked in and noticed the cook was not wearing a mask while making all the food. We watched him the whole time never covered his face so we won't return.

Pizza was fabulous. Like there Monday and Tuesday pizza special.

I love their pizza by the slice options and also their deserts are awesome!

Upside down pie. Amici’s has the best pizza in town! Excellent service, delicious pasta and pizza. The owner Craig and his family are awesome. Just love this place!

Best Pizza and Wings in Coconut Creek! Wife and I luv to indulge every now and again. Great staff, great food and atmosphere..

Ordered Spinach and Chicken salad was wilted and all in corner of box. Tom Jenkins Ribs were without side sauce nor celery. Ripni had no red sauce side ...Plus no bread etc. Paid 38.00 for this. Plus tipped 6.00 Won't do that again..That was God Awful

Amazing sauce, food and pizza! Everyone is treated like family and friends!!

Fresh ingredients. Pizza done right.

Amazing food and staff!!

Pizza was ok for florida

My fav place for pizza. I was so stuffed. Looking forward to returning with my coworkers. Prices are reasonable.

Amici’s not only has the best pizza in town but they make you feel like home no matter where you’re from... The fact that they have Boston Red Sox decor on the wall in honor of Jairo made my heart happy. A lot of us miss seeing him there. I like thin pizza so I usually order it thin and crispy and the pizza brothers Izzy or Nelson always knows what to do. The pasta dishes are also really good, especially the Penne Alla Vodka and Penne with Chicken & Broccoli. They are never shy with the garlic... yum but don’t forget to order dessert. The Homemade brownie is to die for! The NY Style Cheesecake is also very delicious.

Food was excellent and staff superb

- Pizza is too small and too thick to be called NY style. Largest size is 16" but the amount of dough they use could easily be stretched to 18" for a nice thin crust pie. - Very generous with toppings, but because of the smaller, thicker slices, it becomes difficult to fold. - Crust is crispy, bends when folded but does not break, but not much flavor to it. - Mushrooms are from a can. - Meatball parm hero: big meatballs with good flavor - a little heavy on the sauce and light on the cheese. - Nice, cozy dining room atmosphere, but seeing both Red Sox and Yankees stuff on the walls is a little confusing. - Staff was pleasant, food was prepared quickly. - Better than any pizza chain, but there are other local joints with better pies.

Italian Panini is the best around! Family run with a personal touch.

PIZZA...MMMMMM

The best pizza in town!! Great costumer service!!

Delicious 😋

Awesome food, the chocolate explosion was the bomb

I just had a Chicken Parm dinner delivered. It was one of the best Chicken Parm dinner I ever had. Amicis food and service is constantly excellent and the best. The staff are all friendly and professional.