First off the ingredients are top tier, no joke. Second, the family atmosphere you feel when you’re there is second to none. Now to the most important, the wings. Get them double baked and they’re the best wings in Columbus and surrounding area

Wonderful family atmosphere. The staff was very attentive. My husband ordered the all the way pizza and the rest of us ordered the Italian subs. We also ordered the cheese sticks with the marinara. Everything was fresh and hot! It’s a terrific little spot and I highly recommend that you make your way here!

Take the kids on Little Tony Night. Great kid fun on Tuesday when an individual pizza is 99 cents including one topping. They bring the pizza with tomato sauce on it and the toppings that the kids picked. Kids assemble their pizza. Server takes it away and it’s baked along with the rest of the tables order. We sat outside on a lovely evening. Joining us were our grandkids and their parents. My wife and I had a large “all the way” pizza replacing the pepperoni with black olives. Pizzas are thin crust but not cracker thin. Good sauce and plenty of toppings. The rest of the adults got medium pizzas. One was buffalo chicken, it was mildly spicy but also greasy and a build your own pizza with artichokes. Easy parking. A traffic light at the corner makes for safe access to the parking lot during the late afternoon rush traffic. We’ll be back.

Nice little spot for a family meal. The pep and cheese pizza is really good. Nice thin crust with plenty of toppings. The boneless wings in BBQ were tasty also. The staff was all smiles and kept our drinks full. My only compliant is why have I not tried this place before. Absolutely worth a try!

This was my first visit to Antonio's, via word of mouth. The man that helped me was fast and friendly. The environment of the shop was inviting and pleasing. The food was delicious but the pizza was lacking the flavor I'd hoped for, could have been hotter in temperature, and the wings were soft and greasy. Overall, I think should visit the shop and make their own judgment.

Fine service for take out, nice location. The food is mediocre to good, nothing exceptional but if you live close and it's convenient it may be worth it. Boneless chicken is very average and the pizza is good but it wouldn't be hard to find better. The main problem is that the value is very poor; the food is expensive for what it is. The worst, though, as a ranch-loving enthusiast, is that the ranch (which I paid extra for) has a very watery consistency despite its good flavor to the point that not enough ranch sticks to the chicken when you dip it for it to be very enjoyable.

Great Food! Great Service! We live in Marietta and will be making the trip back to this magical pizza shop that is so much more. The garlic bread is great. Their side salads with dinners are huge Their award winning spaghetti and meatballs is excellent. The Italian sub was so delicious. I would call this place not only a neighborhood gem but an Ohio gem. The place was busy we were treated excellent and the food was served promptly for a very good and busy restaurant. So happy to see the support of the Westerville Police.

The services is and fast. When I with some of my family and we order, they bring it right out. The food was still hot when they got it out of the oven. I might go back there, I don't know when.

Local pizzareia with great pizza and cheesy garlic bread! They accommodated our large group of 20. The service was a little slow but as a group we enjoyed our experience

Placed in an unassuming shopping mall, the food here is the best. While I can rave about the pizza, I actually really loved the salad. They did a tremendous job and come in really big portions. The staff and the owner are also very friendly and consistently make sure that you are happy with your food.

The pizza is delicious!! I like the chicken wings and meatball sub, I have not had anything else. Also, I have not dined in so I can't speak to the atmosphere. Easy to get to, the staff is nice.