Absolutely worth the stop for some delish pizza. It was cheesy, yet foldable for the perfect NY style bite. I got pepperoni and mushroom this time. We also got the spicy sausage roll. The sausage rolls comes in spicy or non spicy and with a side of marinara for dipping and it’s crazy good. Only upset that we didn’t buy more sausage rolls. 100% worth the stop.

Moved to NOVA from North Jersey last summer and tried over 20 different pizza joints and none were anywhere near as good as NJ/NY/PA pizzas. Not until today. This pizza is the best I’ve had outside the tristate area and by a long shot! Great crust, flavorful sauce and the cheese blend is perfect. Truly authentic NY style, thin and crispy pies. So if you’re from up north and miss that back home pizza. Give em try. You’ll finally be happy.

Just had their Calzone and it was delicious. Dined in and service was very nice. I would recommend this restaurant!

Food was great. We got cheese fries with bacon, large Hawaiian pizza, and a Steak Stromboli (plus 4 drinks) for around $45. Servce was excellent and food was great. Only drawbacks was that they didn't accept credit/debit cards (good thing I just stopped at an atm prior to ordering) and the inside location is small (5 tables o believe). Seeing that this is a popular place, we were extremely lucky to have found a table once we walked in, where several others coming by to dine in were not that lucky and had to take their orders to go instead. Overall I would give this place a 4.5 if I could.

I am far away from my home in Brooklyn NYC and Pennsylvania but found Brothers Pizza and went there because of their great reviews . Absolutely perfect , owner was so friendly and we had so much in common , the cannolis were amazing , the steak and pepperoni pie to die for .... I felt home 🏡

I asked & multiple people recommended this as the best Italian pizza around Fredricksburg. Service was very friendly, fast & food was cooked right but everything we ordered was completely disappointing & basic. The sauce on our pizza & the marinara sauce we received had little to no seasoning or taste. I've found one excellent Greek pizza place in Fredricksburg so far but unfortunately, we still haven't found great Italian style pizza here.

I moved here from Wv about 5 hours away after my mom passed in 2021!! When I moved here, my kid brother introduced me to Brothers Pizza!!! It's becoming an every Friday thing after I'm done with my arrends for the day!! Best pizza around! I've been here 3 yrs now and have had pizza at other places and this guy tops them, and let's not forget the hippie rolls, Pliant and chewy pizza dough held sweet roasted peppers and onions and a smidge of mozzarella cheese wrapped in a thin baked breading of some type!!! My point is this place is great!! Great folks are always ready to fill your belly, so you leave feeling stuffed with great homemade ITALIAN food!!! Try the carot cake, the icing on the planet!!!

We order here often. We get the Medium Brother's Special, and we love thier subs as well. You know that food is of high quality, amazing taste and smell. The car and house the next day still reminds you of Brother's. Local and owned by the family.

Brother’s Pizza has become our number one pizza joint in all Fredericksburg and Spotsylvania County! They have absolutely one of the best NY style pizzas we have had rivaling places in Brooklyn!

As a former New Yorker, for me this is the best pizza around, and has been for a long time. Really NY style, good crust and sauce and still foldable! The only downsides are that it's cash only and that there's only a small area for eat-in. By the slice or whole pies, subs, calzones and good desserts.

Excellent place definitely a family environment. Definitely good food and definitely my family and me will continue to go there. I love the environment. I love the family atmosphere. Great for pizza night on Friday.

Best pizza in Fredericksburg with a very tasty sauce!

Love the food I was skeptical about the wings but they were real good and the the culzone was real good. The only down side and complain I have is that they only do cash or checks. Something I hardly use anymore. Overall food was well cooked and delicious.

Ordered pizza during lunch time. Pizza was the traditional New York style slice and was pretty good overall, but it could've been cooked a little more. Very friendly staff and they seemed to know just about everyone that walked in.

Love this place it's close to my job so I eat there quite a bit always outstanding pizza and I love the sausage rolls

I grew up eating at this mom n pop pizza shop. The original owners are straight from Italy. Best pizza I've ever had in my life. ❤

As someone born and raised in NY this is the most authentic NY style pizza in Fredericksburg. I have seen multiple imitation NY style places in the area and they are full of lies and blasphemy.. This pizza makes me feel like I am at my local NY pizza place. 5/5

Hands down the best pizza in the area, nowhere else I've been is even close. I've been going here for decades and have never had a bad meal or interaction.

I too am a transplant from up North and a good quality pizza has been difficult to find in Virginia. I discovered Brother's Pizza several years ago and they remind me of the good Italian family run pizza places from NY,NJ,Philly and Delaware.

Delicious pizza. Gotta try the sausage and green pepper rolls. I want to try their sandwiches; they looked delicious. They do not have a lot of seating and do not accept Credit or Debit cards so please plan accordingly.

Nice joint! Love the food and the staff is very friendly. I noticed they know their customers by name. It's a home away from home kind of atmosphere. Just an FYI: They do not accept credit cards. They only take cash and checks.

I still love this place for when I just want a slice or two. I have only ate in once and not a fan, prefer to take my food and go out maybe sit outside if it is nice enough. They are CASH ONLY, something you have to remember when you go.

This pizza has potential. The cheese is VERY good, and pepperoni tastes fresh. However the dough is very tough and chewy.. You cant just bite it like a normal pizza, you have to rip it hard with your teeth to get a bite. If the dough was softer this would be a great pizza.

Very family oriented and the best Pizza in Fredericksburg! The owners and staff are always friendly. The atmosphere is warm and inviting and have the close community feel. And the Pizza is amazing if you like that New York/New Jersey style of pizza. The slices are big and plentiful with whatever toppings you like. They don't take credit or debit cards, or payment apps. So make sure you have cash or a check on hand when you order.

The side salad was so good. The pizza is NY style. Very good. They have beer in the bottle. Desserts. Not a lot of table / chairs. Maybe sitting for 12 people total.

Awesome pizza. New York city/NJ style and very good. Great crust, sauce not overly sweet and cheese just right. Thank you. Finally after many tries over the last five years to find pizza like we easily found in the Northeast, we found our favorite. Our only suggestions: more seating and open a place in Stafford. Very friendly and welcoming staff.