Great place with terrfic food. Just like going to your family home to eat. So delicious!

Food is always great. The pizza and the Tony salad is what I get. My daughter usually gets a pasta dish which is always good and fresh. My wife says the gluten free pizza is the best she has ever had. This is one of our go to spots. It never disappoints.

My favorite place to go since I was a kid! Great food, portions are HUGE! Best tasting pizza I have ever eaten!

You're a fan of thin crust pizza. This is one of the very best places to go. I only gave service three stars because they're very old school and only take cash. You don't realize that until you get there and of course they have an ATM. You going to double the service charges cuz it's not your bank. It's a little small and to take out area so when it gets very busy it can get cramped but again their food and their pizza out of this world!

The only reason why I’m giving Reservoir three stars is because of the food. Otherwise, I have to be honest and say that I am completely disappointed with the disrespect I have received from the staff. My family and I have been going to Reservoir for 20+ years and have had multiple parties there. The last few parties we had/tried to have there we have been treated poorly by the staff as if we were bothering them or inconveniencing them for going there. We have been treated as if they are too busy to work with us. Incredibly disappointing and I would discourage anyone to try to have an event there. You won’t be welcomed and will be rushed.

I'm kind of a bummed out because my fiance was really excited about this place and the pizza. This was mine and my mothers first experience and my fiance was pumped! We ordered the pizza and When we got it it was undercooked so we communicated to the server and they brought it back. When I went to pay the owner(?) She Asked me how everything was and I communicated that everything was good but the undercooked pizza. She said "oh just immediately call it back". I said "that's what we did" and she said "oh I'm sorry just next time immediately tell the server and call it back" and I repeated "that's exactly what we did". Being over it, I just paid and thanked her and went home to find out that what was put in the box was now an over cooked burnt pizza. The thing that bothers me is that they didn't take the pizza off the bill or anything and now we are home with a non edible mushroom pizza.

Always loved this place and the food is delicious. Definitely a family oriented place, loud, busy so get there before 6pm if possible. Simple Italian menu mostly known for their tony salad and pizza. Only reason I didn't give 5 stars was the flies.

Best pizza in NJ! I am a pizza crazy person and it’s my favorite food. They have the perfect combination of sauce and cheese! You will not be disappointed!

A great place. The aroma in the restaurant was enough to make you hungry if you weren't already when you walked through the door. Pizza was awesome as was the service. I'll definitely be going back. Delicious. Cash only by the way.

Love this place! Classic and homey Italian food. Brought my family here for my husband's birthday, there were 7 of us plus a baby and it was the perfect spot for our group! Our server, Christi (I think?), was amazing and made sure we were always comfortable and happy. Made sure to accommodate the setting so our little one wouldn't get her hands on anything hot or dangerous and kept our table tidy always! Delicious food, big servings so lots of leftovers and sharing. Overall incredible spot!

Jersey Italian food at it's finest. Great pizza. Great Italian fare. The potato and peppers are phenomenal. Love it more each time I go.

What a great find! We had their pizza, antipasto, and the shrimp parmesan. Cash only. Fast service, and great bread to start. Loud, for those sensitive to sound. People are talking and having a good time. You can bring your own alcohol. They also give you water.

Best meal i have had in NJ. This place is amazing. Relaxed family enviroment, amazing food, like grandma makes, i will def be going back all the time.

Best pizza ever. Grew up in WO, lived all over NJ and other states. In 34 years of my life, has forever been my favorite. I still drive an hour to SO just to get this pizza.