What can I say.... First off, when my family & I walked into the restaurant, we were greeted & felt welcomed by an elderly man, which I guess is the owner. He seems like the kind but no nonsense kind of person, eager to serve, but doesn't waste a moment. My wife & I ordered meatball sandwiches with double cheese, and ordered a mini cheese pizza for my little one. The food was great! Even my picky little toddler ate majority of it, and she is usually not a big eater. When we decided to order another mini cheese pizza to go, he was very adamant about how to carry out the pizza, since it was still hot & didnt want moisture building up and possibly ruining the pizza, which is cool I guess. Overall, I'd say give this place a try, even if you've may have gotten a bad experience or not (according to some previous reviews). That's all I can say...for now.

Stopped by from out of town, and honestly wasn’t expecting much. Boy was I wrong. Got a large pepperoni pizza with bacon for the family. Fantastic! Honestly, some of the best pizza I’ve had in years, and it didn’t break the budget. The good pepperoni, and bacon. Not the cheap stuff. Yes, they seem short handed, but had a very nice front cashier lady help us today.

Was not happy with the service and portion size of slices. I ordered a large and small pie, and the crust was overcooked and tasted burnt. Also, the pizza was very oily and salty. Our server knew that we were dining in, and as we sat waiting for our pizza, she rudely dropped the two boxes as far from us on the table as she could. Then, when we asked for plates (enough for seven people), she barely acknowledged us and returned with four plates, then did the same by dropping the plates on our pizza boxes and walked away. It was just very unfriendly and made us feel unwelcome. I overall did not enjoy my visit and left with a bad taste in my mouth.

Came here in the midst of our road-trip on my wife's 25th Birthday. The store is in a great location & being in Carmel, it is a beautiful location. Decent Customer Service. The staff helped us with a first timer discount. The pizza was fresh & really delicious & enjoyable. The store was clean as well. This store really made a lasting impression on my mind for just how fresh the pizza looked. Pretty close to the highway. Definitely recommend for a decent, affordable, quick bite of pizza.

Pizza was good. But the place is really dirty and nasty. Even the utensils that are used there for customers look like they still had food on them. Really need to work on cleanliness

Disappointing. Not up to Mountain Mike's standards. It's a nice looking restaurant, except for the flies that seem to hang around the west end of the restaurant, near the salad bar and soda machine. The pizza buffet had chintzy slices, which seems to be the norm for buffets these days, and the slices were salty and not very good. The diet soda was very watered down from the machine. The service was average. I love Mountain Mike's pizza when I visit, but I won't be coming back to this location.

Delicious Pizza; we had Pikes Peak and Mt Veggymore, both loaded with ingredients. Really friendly Staff there, too. Thank you.

We order here every week and not only is the customer service great. The pizza is always perfect. Thanks!