Been coming to this hidden gem regularly to get my pizza cravings fix. The pizza have is amazing. They are very generous with the toppings. The flavour is amazing compared to other pizza places in town. You can tell they make their dough fresh and only use the best ingredients. I've tried their wings a while ago and it's alright for what it is. Will get their pasta next time around and write another review... For the location, they're found right across the Highland Farms. They are a bit hidden but once you know, you know. Aside from the pizza, the people who work there (or owners?) are the nicest people ever. You can tell they're very passionate about their business. I highly highly recommend you to give this place a try if you like pizza.

Had an offer from Ubereats that I couldn’t resist. I have also been wanting to try this independent family-owned pizza place for a while. Read lots of great reviews and now I know why. Next time I will order direct to support this small business. Their pizzas are AMAZING, loaded with so much toppings. • Hawaiian - Small - thin crust • Tandoori - Medium - regular crust - well done. (This is spicy for me but it’s really good.) I have to visit the store soon. The staff on the phone was very nice and helpful. Can’t wait to meet her in person! 👍🏻

The best pizza joint in Scarborough without a doubt! Small family run business with amazing quality pizza and friendly service. You will pay more than chain pizza restaurants, but it is completely worth it and you can see and taste the difference. We always ask for well done pizza which is cooked perfectly. My picky father who doesn't eat pizza will only eat the pizza from Pizza on Fire. Highly recommend trying their classic or gourmet pizzas

I have to say this really could be the best pizza in Scarborough. The crust is so light and crispy. The toppings are the best around, real sausage and delicious stringy cheese. The pizza looked small for an XL but was so rich, so much toppings and flavour, incredible. The sauce is a little on the light side. The cheese is the star here, so good. It’s hard to get your mind blown by a pizza, but this comes close. The wings are very good. I think it’s called Tempura style, I have similar wings anytime I go to a Chinese restaurant or Mandarin. So crispy and cooked perfect. Maybe not the best wings I ever had but top 10. They staff are super nice and friendly. It’s like you’ve been going there your whole life on your first visit. Thanks for the brownies, super delicious and moist. For the money I spent $62 on an xl pizza and 20 wings and was super happy with the value. If you order from Pizza Nova it will cost $10 more and you will get half as much. Cheeper pizza places now feel like cardboard, ketchup and processed cheese. This is my go to place from now on.

Little tricky to find and parking is a nightmare, but glad I took the risk as the pizza was bloody fantastic! Got a large cheese only for $20 and couldn’t be happier. It didn’t even give me heartburn! I love that they aren’t cheap w the amount of cheese. Check ‘em out, you won’t be disappointed.

Definitely one of the best pizzas I had. I enjoyed everything about the pizza. The dough, the cheese, the perfectly cooked toppings. Even the service, my friends and I were waiting outside in the parking lot and they brought the pizza to us. I would definitely come back here again.

This is not pizza that you use to fill a hole. This is pizza you sit down to a table and eat with a knife and fork. The toppings are great, the flavour is fresh, and the dough is light and flaky. It's a beautiful creation.

The owner/cook/cashier was super friendly. The place was tiny with one small square table and two chairs. It appears to be a pizza takeout/delivery place. Ordered their Philly steak pizza. The dough and the ingredients were fresh. The toppings were generous. It was pretty tasty, a little oily though, the crust was a little too soft to my liking. The place could use some tidy up.

My neighbor Peter has been saying good things about this place. He loves their burger and said I should definitely give it a try!! Tonight I ordered their deluxe pizza on Uber Eat and it was delicious!!! It’s different from the usuals that you get from the chain stores. The crust has the right thickness and chewiness. It was a bit greasy but that’s inevitable - they did put lots of green pepper to balance it out. It was just so yummy 🤤 Then I saw they have free delivery on their box. Next time I would just give them a call. I think it’s within 3km. Would definitely try other pizzas (e.g. tandoori chicken) next time! Gotta get my little one’s buy-in though lol. Or maybe I can ask if they can do half and half. 😝

What a find! The pizza was delicious I got a half cheese and half pepperoni pie to share with my kids The staff was so kind and opened up a foldable table for us to sit in and eat The pizza itself was fresh and truly one of the best I’ve had in the GTA The quality of the ingredients and care in preparation clearly came across in every bite I highly recommend this spot

My pizza experiences in Scarborough haven't been the greatest @ any of the typical pizza franchises. But finally, I have found a pizza joint that understands how to make the proper crust. Not too thick, not too thin, crispy and carmelized just right. I ordered an XL and it kind of looked like a Large to me at first, but when I held the box, that bad boy was heavy :) I ordered a half garden/half meat lovers pie, so I can try their meaty and vegetarian styles, and it was awesome. And oh, they have Halal Peperroni, Halal Sausage and Halal Ground beef (chicken etc). They give you a little sintul chocolate brownie with the pizza, and that was a nice touch (wish they threw in 2 or 3 more with this XL pizza). But its cool, I found my Scarborough pizza joint, its a wrap.

Decided to try this place out as it was one of the best pizza in Scarborough. In my scale it was okay as I'm not a fan of the conveyor very passionate and friendly owners and very knowledgeable. The cheese pizza was better than most conveyor oven Pizza. They are not shy on the ingredients

The pizzas are really good tasting! And the owner is so nice, they informed us they didn’t have bacon, so they added extra sausage for us! Good service and delicious food 👍👍the taste is very similar to pizza I tried in China!

Heard of this place and finally got to try it and extremely happy i did, this pizza is amazing! Super generous with the toppings, it was loaded! It's definitely the go-to pizza spot in Scarborough, in my opinion!

Wow, my medium pizza weighed about 6 pounds! Crust is fresh and crispy, even the bottom was crispy. I normally don't eat the crust but today I did. Generous toppings. The place looks kinda shabby but don't let that stop you. Friendly staff.

A Scarborough hidden gem! BLOG TO got it right! Best in Scarborough! Tried because of Google ratings and oh boy!! It is sooo good! Quality over monetary, for sure! Give it a try! Absolutely worth it. Ordered large BBQ chicken and it is amazing! Plenty of toppings prepared so well. The dough is so soft and delightful! Just "try it" like I did and you'll see!

Had to stop by before heading home! Ended up grabbing a meat lovers pizza. First time I must say! Pizza was delicious! But the amount of oil was crazy! Ended up getting oiling on my seat, too! Would I go back? Yes! But I will definitely let them know about the oil level!

The nicest man always answers the phone. He seems genuinely happy to be working and taking my order every single time we call. The pizza is AMAZING! Lots of toppings, the crust is more like a bread and easy to chew. The pizza toppings are all the way out so there is only a small pizza crust not like most places. Everyone including the kids in our house even eat the crust, it’s that good. We all get excited to order pizza from here. THANK YOU for making a pizza that we LOVE Still the best pizza I’ve ever had

They are amazing! Great fresh ingredients and support tasty. They always go above and beyond. I had made requests on how I like my pizza and they went above and beyond to accommodate. Made my day. Love you guys! Wish you all the success. Thank you so much.

Ordered a small Mediterranean w/ extra cheese, pretty pricey along w/ dipping came out to $26. It was just good, I especially loved how the crust tasted so soft and crunchy made me want to keep eating it. I am willing to come back and try a different pizza with other toppings. Very polite staff, be weary as this pizza shop is Located in a very tight and busy plaza might be hard to find parking at times. I think it’s a bit too expensive but I’m willing to give it another chance.

Ordered a pizza and wings and both were amazing!!! The pizza tasted so great! it was very fresh, well made and I noticed the pizza had a generous amount of cheese which was awesome to see But the wings though, please get those! They are so crispy, juicy and have the perfect amount of batter on them. I suggest getting them untossed and dipping them into the sauce later, they stayed much more crispy that way! Will definitely be back soon

As a Scarberian we all know that pizza is everywhere, but this folks is not your average pizza. I love the fact that these people keep the passion in pizza making. Honestly the finest pizza on the East side. It's very rare that I can become full off a medium pizza, and not just because of the dough but the vast plenty of toppings. They aren't shy. As for quality I wish I had taken a picture of my za before I inhaled it. A pizza has textures and layers and you should be able to differentiate between them also whilst enjoy them all at the same time. These guys are hitting the proper notes. You can mod your pizza basically anyway you like. The fact is this is a cut above any pizza out there. They are worth the extra couple mins wait and honestly their price point is amazing considering they are mom and pop! Forever you have me Pizza On Fire!

The pizza was amazing! We got chicken mushrooms and roasted tomatoes on our pizza and it was maybe one of the best pizzas I ever had.the chicken was real chicken and generous amount. The flavour is amazing!!! It’s Not like those cubes chicken you get from pizza pizza at all. We REAL CHICKEN REAL PIZZA. WILL Definitely be coming back

This was good pizza and everything tasted great. If you’re not into heavy pizza like deep dish this won’t be your favourite but my pizza was very tasty. Would definitely recommend you give it a try. My only negative would be a little more well done on the bottom. It might be a balance as well since the top has so many toppings. Either way it was really good.