The owner is very rude. Constantly swears. horrible customer service. Plus the pizza is doughy and taste greasy.. not worth it

Delish fresh rolled pizza dough that tastes so fresh your nonna could have kust rolled it out! Hidden neighbourhood gem in my opinion, although I'm sure everyone from this quaint town all know of it! Make sure to stop by and try it out if your passing through!

Quick, tasty, and I needed it 2/3 pepperoni - they were up to the challenge!

Brutal, pizza on Wednesday $8-10 cheaper than Friday or Saturday. But then the following Saturday it’s different again. What’s up with all the sketchy pizza box signs bashing your competitors all over the place at least buy some nice signs don’t be so cheap. If your pizza joint was better you wouldn’t need to explain it to people, just be better.

Love how calling since 7:30pm they close at 8 but no one picks up the phone great service indeed 1/10

First and last time ordering at Johnny’s if I can give -1000 I would. My order was incorrect which I understand mistakes happen, the manger called me and was absolutely rude, said that the business is failing and he’s tired of giving free away free food, my order was never repeated back to me and he was insisting it was. I offered to return the pizza for the correct one I originally ordered and pay the difference. Instead of making an effort and gaining a long term customer in the future he lost my business. I doubt that is how you run a business and treat paying customers.

Great pizza, good price, wish the Orangeville location tasted as good as this

Shelburne is totally different from orangevilles. The pizza doesn't taste the same and it's more expensive. States they are the cheapest pizza in town which is another lie. I would rate orangevilles location better

Never get enough! The best panzeroti you can have there is no comparison I've had 40 panzies and they can't come close you want authentic panzeroti goto Johnny's pizza the never disappointed 😉

If I order Pizza in town, it’s definitely Johnny’s. I have never had a bad experience with them. Always made fresh to order. If I crave pizza I know who to call. Staff have always been delightful. I’ve gone in and placed an order late night just before they closed after my shift of dealing with people all day and they were still welcoming. I highly recommend them. They’ve had amazing pizza ever since I was kid.

Tried extra large pizza with 3 toppings. It was 18 inches. They serve the largest size pizza with fresh dough. You can choose your toppings & service was good & quick Price - 3/5 - CAD 30 (for 2) Service - 4/5 Parking - available Ambiance - 2/5

Best Pizza Ever 🍕 Big Slices, Best Meatlovers Pizza I've Ever Had And Always Fresh. Also Their Chicken Wings Are Good. Workers Are Very Nice. 10/10

The Service is Awesome. Pizza is not greasy on the bottom like other places are. Prices are Good. If you order more items on your pizza you pay more for it. I fine Johnny's Pizza's are bigger in sizes then other places. Johnny's Pizza Sauce is the only one I can eat that doesn't upset my stomach. I have a friend who has Everything on his Pizza. Johnny's Pizza in Shelburne is the only one who will make it for him. Where the other Pizza Shop Won't.

This place is amazing the food is awesome you get way more than you can eat your money's worth I recommend this place to everyone

Amazing food and service! Great small town family style pizza shop!

I wish we came here sooner when we moved here! Plentiful toppings, great service, reliably delicious. Best pizza in town by FAR!

Can't ever go wrong with this pizza. Amazing all the time.