We had been to Rustic Buffalo in East Aurora and have to say that The North Tonawanda location tops it by a mile. A large sprawling complex with a lot to do (more available space given the rural location). Especially on weekends. Many artisans fill the multiple building with Buffalo themed items, but in some areas there are antiques, Christmas items etc. You can grab a coffee, have a desert etc. Leave plenty of time to explore the four main buildings. Each had it's own unique offerings. Pricing seemed reasonable and the staff was friendly (no pressure). There are additional vendor building at the rear of the property for weekends and special events (sip and shop etc.). I am not a big shopper, but there really is something for anyone here. Certainly worthy of a stop. You won't be disappointed!

Driving from Montreal, Canada (8hrs away) in our old RV and visited the East Aurora location looking to purchase an inflatable Buffalo! They didn’t have it in this location, but that gem Donna proposed to go get it at the other location and deliver it to us where we were parked near the Highmark Stadium. Wow! Buffalo… the city of good neighbors without a doubt! Plus we were able to buy so many cute stuff (clothes, etc.). We’ll definitely be back!!!!! Thank you Donna and thank you Rustic Buffalo Artisan Market!!!! Jay, Marie and Nathalie from Montreal Bills Backers! Go Bills!!!! :)

This place is awesome. I stop everytime I visit my daughter. So much great items

Lots of Buffalo Bill's and Sabres gear, handmade items and knick-knacks. Some stuff is reasonably priced. So m.j e stuff is expensive. Depends on what you're looking for. Large variety. And delicious baked goods for sale. I had an individual slice of carrot cake. Well worth the $4.00 and delicious.

There are tons of unique items. There are a lot of different buffalo bills items. A must place to shop. Have been wanting to come here for a very long time. I love coming to places like this because of the originality and that people made them instead of going to a big box store.

Wildly creative, high quality craft shopping with perfectly unique gifts for Birthdays and Christmas. Huge collections of Buffalo Bills, and Bills Mafia items. But it's expensive, honestly. Your purchases do support local artistisans. You'll find items from $1.75 like postcards, but most things are much, much more. Always worth a look.

I had the most amazing customer service and experience with Ashley and Sarah. I needed custom bracelets and within minutes had help from both of these ladies. I couldn’t believe how easy it was to get answers and find what I was looking for. The prices are affordable, and the customizations were exactly what I needed. If you need local products quickly, then you need to shop here. 10/10 recommend!

Love it there!! All the buffalo gifts and home decor as far as the eye can see. All local vendors and lots of handmade items. Definitely worth a trip out!!

Stopped in at the location in East Aurora and was surprised at how many things were inside! All of them handmade by local artists, which was very impressive and only.made me want to buy more! The man running the front was super friendly and helpful, and informed us of the new location opening on main in Williamsville! Can't wait to keep stopping in for gifts!

Awesome place, mist everything is Hand crafted. I bought a beautiful cement green plant holder.

Incredible selection and so much to look at I spent 3 hours there.

So much to choose from! Amazing Lil unique items!! I was looking for St. Paddy's gear which they had of course and left with Bills gear hahaha

If one is looking for Buffalo Bills souvenirs, they are well stocked. Anything from small trinkets to a Bison the size of a small car. About 4-5 small shops to visit. We spent about 3 hrs there. All ages.

Great selection of items for very affordable prices! Primarily home decor and some vintage items but the most important place to visit was this cute dog on the 2nd floor!

Unique shops with everything from Buffalo Bills decor and clothing, food, jewelry and more. Love the bar where you can get a drink or two while you shop...even my husband loved it!

I visited many years ago when this was mainly an antique shop and it has changed so much! There is a great selection of local artisans' work. Everything from t-shirts, pet merchandise, Buffalo Bill's gear and home decor to candles, soaps and a huge variety of Christmas ornaments and gifts, this place really has a little something for everyone. Definitely worth the trip and they even have a bakery and cafe!

Great place with friendly merchants. Love shopping for gifts here!

What a wonderful array of items! With 3 buildings, there is indeed something for everyone, especially if you are looking for Buffalo themed items ! Friendly staff. Tight quarters, with so much wonderful merchandise.

Sure to become a very popular destination! You'll be seeing a lot of Ontario licence plates in the parking lot when the border reopens.

Cool gift shop, you looking for something Buffalo or to gift a Buffalo item …. This is the place to go

Lots of unique and fun artisan crartisan craftware but also a lot of 716 in Buffalo crafts and souvenirs it's a nice mix of the area

Always can fine something to bring home that you can't live without..Great place to shop and lots to see.

Adorable Rustic barn & vintage shop! So many locally made items and gifts. Staff is friendly and the Cafe area has such tasty treats.

Love this place!!! Something for everyone. Prices are reasonable. I can spend hours there looking around. People are very nice and friendly.

They have a lot of cool stuff here and if you are a buffalo bills fan you will be in heaven.

Loved it. My niece and I were looking for a little adventure and decided to check out the shops. So much fun browsing and finding a couple of small treasures. We enjoyed a snack on the porch as well. Very nice place.

These shops offer beautiful, one of a kind treasures you won't see anywhere else! Beautifully merchandised and the staff are friendly and helpful. You could spend hours here. They even offer women's boutique style clothing at great prices. A must if you want lovely, unique gifts. They offer something for every taste and style. LOVE, LOVE!!

Its a really amazing store but their customer service & store policies need some improvement. Manager would not let me switch an item for a more expensive item & I had not even left the store. So if you purchase something from here make sure 1000% that you want it & don't find anything else that you like better.