I appreciate you not cutting a single slice. or even an attempt at cutting the pizza aswell as charging me for extra toppings you definitely didnt put on. way to go assclowns..Oh yeah i guess nobody checks what they're doing right? I did try to call the store. Im not about to drive another 30m each way to pickup your mistake. thanks

First visit to this pizza joint, we noticed tons of pizzerias in this area and decided to go ahead and try Fat Cat's. Very impressed with the flavors in the food. Fellow co worker got the meatball sub and slice of pizza. The slice was a bit greasy and had a NY flop to it but crispy, still very enjoyable. The meatballs were definitely made in house and had a home made taste to it. I had the Eggplant and Zucchini Panini, perfectly created and filled with tons of beautiful flavours. Very authentic Italian taste with fresh vegetables. Overall great experience for us, definitely come check this place out !

First time visit here, was a bit nervous because I was with my kids and the restaurant is more like a bar. But the bartender who served us was so sweet and friendly, and the people hanging at the bar were friendly and chatting up my son. The menu is very inexpensive, and you get a mountain of food! It's not a fancy presentation but the taste makes up for it. Their small pizza is more like the size of a medium, and it has a home made taste, the pizza sauce was delicious and flavorful. I also ordered a Caesar salad, the croutons were warm and buttery, and the salad was plentiful and well dressed. Had deep fried pickles, the pickles themselves were good but I found the batter a little soft. They did however seem to be batter dipped and fried fresh, which was nice. The most impressive thing we ordered were the "cat paws" which are garlic bread bites with a marinara dipping sauce. You get a mountain of them, and they are only $4.50.. they are delicious and buttery and it's hard to stop picking at them! This place is great for hearty food that will please both adult and child on a budget.

Fantastic service and top notch food. We had lunch with our toddler and truly enjoyed everything. We ordered fries and a side of gravy for the table, they came out hot and fresh. The gravy was great. We also ordered a medium pizza, the toppings were fresh, great cheese pull and crispy crust. The side of garlic dipping sauce was amazing and complimented the za perfectly. Overall a delicious, welcoming lunch stop.

The pizza here is the BEST! It's absolutely our favourite pizza in the city. I love pizza with a million toppings and this is a great place for that (it's not Italian-style pizza, so don't order from here if that's what you're looking for). I've only ever had the pizza, and I've never eaten in, only ordered delivery so I can't speak to the atmosphere. Seems like a small place from the outside. But you've gotta try the pizza!!

An amazing 🍕 experience, although our choice of Hawaiian pizza happens to be a build your own choice, unlike other common pizza chains, this time it was way more delicious and had their own twist. The pizza shop and pub next door seems to be under one management and was quite busy on a Friday evening. If you happen to be in St Catherine and crave for pizza, this place is definitely worth a visit.

How can you feel good about selling a pizza that is burnt and looks like this. Also, I don't know a single place that gives 2 celery sticks, not that big of a deal but just saying. You lost a regular, I've gave you so many chances and you never seem to want to fix the issues. Hope it was worth it.

Within a span of two week, we have order twice from this restaurant. Their calzones are amazing. We got the medium pizza with half cheese and half green peppers and onions. It was way better than any big brand names. The person at the front is very friendly and takes time to explain things. When you go in say hi to Marty Junior.

First time I’ve tried fat cats and honestly I think it’s probably the best pizza and wings in Niagara. Pizza was fantastic, cup and char pepperoni with perfect crust. Cooked perfectly. Wings were big and they have an awesome selection of sauces. Calzone was great too. I’m not easily impressed and both myself and my wife really enjoyed the food. Definitely ordering from here again!

Pizza is very good, bar side, service is terrible, basically need to walk to the bar to ask for a drink and interrupt the personal conversation. Used to be a blonde girl and dark haired one, they were awesome, have not seen them in a few weeks, service has gone down hill.

What a great spot to enjoy a drink and have some amazing Pizza.. We tried the Mac Fat Cats pizza with the fried Jalapeno dumplings served with cherry sauce and it was delicious.. I will definitely go there again. Plus the bartender was really attentive and gave us great service.

Ordered a tray pizza tonight, half cheese and half with pepperoni. Barely any cheese on it at all. Ive personally given this place many chances, but after today, we are not coming back. Way too hit or miss with quality of pizzas. More often than not, they are disappointing. I go out of my way to avoid chain pizza shops and support locally owned and operated, but after getting so many lousy pizzas from here due to them being overcooked, very cheap on toppings, or having orders screwed up depending on how high the kitchen staff are, I am definitely done with this place.

Food was great - fresh, hot, very tasty! Portions were HUGE, prices extremely reasonable and staff was fantastic.

Possibly the best pizza in town. I'll drive out of my way for it. Fat Cats is owned by some of the hardest working locals you would ever want to meet. This business love for there community and its pets are very apparent by the community board. We love looking at all the pet pictures from staff and patrons posted on the board. They have a huge covered patio and are prompt when serving out there, you won't feel forgotten. If you are looking for our best pizza here in Niagara look no further then Fat Cats

Honest order from here every Saturday and hands down the best pizza and wings around!! Both my kids (4&1.5) love it as well and devour it. The garlic dip I'm assuming is made in house as it is the most garlicky deliciousness I have ever had lol. Honey Cajun is a surprising twist that taste awesome and the cat paws are pretty damn good to. Everything I have tried from the menu has been 5star

Been a longtime customer of Fat Cat's and its so disappointing to see this place go downhill used to be so good.... Very inconsistent the pizza has been terrible lately... I ordered 2 medium pizzas it cost over $50 and barely had any toppings on the pizza? Overpriced dough....

We stopped by on our way home from the Niagara outlets for a quick bite. When you walk in you’re greeted with the average bar feel, but Also greeted with super friendly service. I was not expecting this meal to be one of the best pasta’s I’ve ever had, but it was and that put’s a smile on my face. The prices are more than reasonable in today’s economy, I got a pasta and a beer for under $20. The cat paws are great as-well, But I already wish I had another bowl of Cajun Alfredo. Shoutout to the Gentleman who served us, who was busily working the bar and still had time to check in on us every 10 minutes. My only disappointment is I live an hour away! Will be returning, 10/10!

Went in for drinks with some buddies later at night. There was a family hanging their baby over the bar at one point which was weird. Bartender was using the same glass for new drinks and made the wrong drink a couple times. Big Mac Pizza was really tasty though.

Ordered a large deluxe pizza, that was cold by time I picked it up and the kid didn't even know what went on a deluxe and only gave me green peppers and pepperoni, and had the audacity to ask me what I wanted on it after I said a deluxe... like I don't work at the pizza shop, I'm not going to remember what goes on a deluxe 100% of the time... that's literally your job

It was a good place to be on a Sunday night. Pizza was ok. Not the best I've had nor the worse. I'd probably go back

The only pizza and wings we get anymore. We've tried them all and nothing beats Fatcats. If you're looking for great takeout with great service at a great price your search has been fulfilled!

We stayed overnight in Niagara-on-the-Lake but arrived late in the evening. We decided to order a pizza from Fat Cat's Pizza and were pleasantly surprised. The pizza was loaded with toppings and full of flavour. I LOVE hot sauce (the hotter, the better for me) and I definitely recommend the "9th Life" hot sauce.

I saw the pictures from other reviews and I knew I had to come try it. The workers there were very friendly. I ordered a large pepperoni pizza (Monday & Tuesday special) and it took 20 minutes. The pizza had some char marks on the crust, couldn't taste them and made the crust nice and crispy. Cheese, sauce & pepperonies were very good as well. My grandpa is picky with pizza and he gave it the seal of approval.

Amazing food and pricing. Friendly environment and nice staff. Well worth it to check it out!

I've enjoyed everything out if the kitchen so far.

My favourite pizza place in Niagara. 4 stars for the cost, and I'd you get the new York style wings they will leak out of the cardboard box everytime. Really wish they would have different takeout packaging for there wings

I think they changed their recipes. However, it is still the best place for cheap drinks and friendly staff! I really like the owners too :) My half pepperoni, mushrooms, onions/ Tex-Mex pizza on a thin crust tastes different. :(

Some hidden gems of food at this place. The cat tails are amazing and pasta is most of the time also amazing. 9/10 recommended unless your getting the cat tails then 10/10 recommended.

We got 2 large veggie pizzas and it was more than enough for 7 people. The dough was delicious. If you are a cheese lover, you should definitely check this place out. If you don't like a lot of cheese, you could request for less.

My wife and I love their pizza and pastas. We drive 15 minutes from Niagara falls to pick it up and it's worth it. They have great hard working staff and the prices are amazing!

Love there 🍕 wings. And double shots Rye@coke. Great atmosphere , will definitely be returning, for another family night Ty again cheerz

Came here to get away from the overly crowded and way too expensive niagara falls. Only 15 minutes away by car, found this small local place, with hospitable workers, delicious and very affordable food. Had a large pizza, which was excellent, wings and a wonderful putin. Highly recommend this place, especially (but definately not only) if you want to get some peace and quiet while in niagara falls.

6.00 slice and a pop, was easily the best slice I've had in a long time! Thin crispy crust, great pepperoni and the garlic dipping sauce is to die for! Great, dedicated staff. Burned himself while checking on our slices and kept going like it was nothing. The man deserves a raise!