Ordered panzerotti from the Carlton location and amazing. We were driving back from Niagara Falls and wanted panzerotti. We didn't know how big they would be so we ordered 2 small and 1 large. OMG! Delicious. Will def6order from here again.

Hands down one of the best pizza's in the Niagara Region. Paesano's never disappoints, the sauce is sooooo gooood! Little sweet, little tangy and a little salty, nothing over bearing but extremely delicious! I always ask for extra sauce on the pie and a little well done. One of my favourite pizza shops in the region without a doubt! Great work and of course I will be back for more!

Super pizza! We just moved to town and tried out this place, and wow, what a find. Very unassuming spot in a strip plaza, on the east side of town. We ordered one of the specials, 24 slice plus 20 wings. The sauce is amazing, and the toppings are abundant, but don't swamp the pizza. Chatted briefly, with, I assume, the owner. Very friendly and personable. This will most likely be our go-to spot for pizza. We will definitely return.

The owner is awesome, amazing pizza and prices Also just tried the panzerotti and it was incredible. Optional fresh garlic on top as well.

Second time ordering over the past few weeks, honestly the best pizza I’ve had in a while! We got a tray, it came as ordered, the sauce was generous but very tasty sauce that to me seems homemade, the cheese was the good mozzarella for sure.

Most consistently cooked pizza in St Catharines. Took me 3 years of living in the city for me to find it and immediately became my go to pizza. Priced right for a delicious pizza on a great crust.

Really good Pizza and excellent wings!!! But! I do not like the fact that they don’t allow you to go half items on a party tray. Makes it difficult when your children don’t like the same items on their pizza. They charge you $3 more per 1/2 item!!! This is the only pizza restaurant I have ever witnessed this robbery. Otherwise I would have gladly given this pizza joint 5*****

Heard good reviews but when I ordered a Paesano Special pizza, I wasn't expecting Paper thin crust, though. With all the toppings it was hard to eat as they just fell off the base of pizza. Not alot of sauce either. I will give it another try and guess I will just have to ask for a thicker crust. Toppings on pizza were good, hot peppers were spicy just the way they should be.

Honestly this is THE BEST pizza in town! You cannot beat the price and the food is always consistent. In my opinion they also have the best wings in town and many other excellent menu options. If you’ve left Paesanos on Carlton St a poor review , something is seriously wrong with you. Great job Paesanos, hard working people making great food.

Small little pizza place located on a plaza. Italian owned, this is the real deal. Great tasting food at an affordable price! Friendly staff, decent amount of toppings. Decent amount of parking available, overall i’d recommend giving them a try.

Paesano pizza is fantastic. This is our second time ordering. Very generous with the toppings and the sauce is definitely made in house. Delicious. Always a sad moment when everything is devoured. I highly recommend stopping in if you have never been, or get yourself back there if you have. Will absolutely be on our list when pizza is what we crave.

Best pizza in the city I pass 5 places to go here very consistent and the staff are so friendly!! Great daily Specials and pizza 🍕 is top notch They haven’t updated online prices yet but prices are still good value !!

best place to get pizza, its always good. cooked perfectly and always hot when we get it. staff is always so friendly as well

I’m at a loss for words Paesanos Pizza on Carlton st. (St.Catharines) knocked this right out of the park. 1 lg. 1 sm Panzo, 4items. 8.95 and 14.95 respectively….This is the absolute largest Panzo I have ever had..and super delish… 10/10 kudos to you guys👍

Had this for the first time today Crust is nice and fresh, cheese amount was generous, and followed my instructions perfectly(easy on the sauce). Very tasty will be back. Got it 3 more times since then, lockdown sucks.. but this pizza sure doesn’t. Delicious!

Awesome pizza. I ordered for the first time this past Saturday and was very happy that I did. It was delicious! I would highly recommend Paesano’s.

Delicious pizza every time. We enjoy a 24 slice every Friday at Parkview Equipment and can’t wait until the next Friday. Fantastic dough, sauce and toppings. Highly recommended.

Paesano quickly became our go to pizza place. The food is delicious, especially the panzerotti's when they add a little garlic sauce to the top of it. Not only that, but the owner is super nice and friendly! Will definitely keep returning for our Friday night pizza night!

My favorite pizza in town! The team here pour their souls into this shop! It takes a little bit longer than going to a chain pizzeria, but the quality is unbeatable! I love the wings. Granted, I don't prefer breaded, so when I ask for mine saucy, they are a cut above the rest! Not just a pizza shop! Everything on the menu is amazing! Try the pasta, gnocchi, subs! You can't go wrong! Service isn't with white gloves, but that's another part of the charm... Expect to wait, pick it up yourself and get real quality food at great prices!! Love you guys at Paesano Pizza!

Amazing pizza, amazing wings. And even better yet the prices are unbeatable. They have the best prices in Niagara. 20 bucks for party tray, 20 bucks for a panzerotti the size of your head and 10 wings or just 10 for the panzo that can fill a grown man easy. I drive up from Welland any time I need pizza , I can't recommend them enough

I love this place! Consistent pizza and service. Call ahead and pick it up takes about half hour. Very friendly. Everything I've tried is delicious. The sauce is amazing. Pretty sure it's homemade. Same goes with the sausage and meatballs

After all the hype on Facebook, I had to try…and they did not disappoint! Great people, the wait was long but the owner let me know before taking my order. The pie was delicious and very reasonably priced. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Called to order pasta which is on there menu but was told they don’t make pasta on Friday or the weekend…disappointing because it doesn’t state that anywhere on the menu. Take it off your menu if it’s not an option.

The staff there do a great job both with food an the time u wait the usually have it ready within 20-40 mnts great service .I say go have some good food an you will see it's the best .cheers

The pizza and wings here are excellent. The quality is always amazing. It doesn’t matter what day of the week you order or who is making the pizza it’s always excellent quality and exactly how you love it.

I love a good pizza and this spot certainly made my top favourite list! I am visiting St. Catherines and tried their pizza. Was delicious, love it highly recommend it.

Don't think I've ever received bad food from here. Can be a bit of a wait at times, but it never disappoints!

Best deal in the city for 24 slice pizza. Great sauce and flaky crust. Game changer for sure folks.

Absolutely the BEST homemade ricotta cheese Gnocchi I've had from a restaurant. I chose the Bologese (meat sauce). The sauce was incredible. Best kept secret... lol. Shhhh.

This is one of the best pizzas in the city by far. Using real cheese and a generous amount of sauce. The pasta is also very good, definitely try it

This is one of the best pizza joints in the city! Came here for pizza and Buffalo wings combo and it definitely hit the a spot. Pizza crust was perfect. Nice people too. Will definitely be back.

For anyone who is looking to have a family get together and have some pizza & wings, or just pizza. Or even for themselves. I highly recommend Paesano pizza. The staff are very friendly & family oriented. Great food & service is very hard to come by these days. Great job Paesano Staff!!!! & thankyou for the great food!

pizza was good and i enjoyed my wings. prices on the website need to be updated. guy on the phone spoke and hung up too quick to give me the order total. drove over and was surprised by the price difference. still would of got food but didn't appreciate the surprise

Amazing Pizza! I ordered some today for dinner, It was very warm and fresh. One thing i suggest is to keep it out for some time on how hot it is. Its very cheesy and saucy. Its so good! Highly reccomend

That has to be one of, if not the best pizza I've had. It'll set the bar to which you'll measure all other pizzas, and they won't compare. Very very very good. 6/5 stars.

Good pizza and sub and all food. The good customer service

Excellent pizza. Excellent prices, homemade sauce, fresh ingredients, perfect crust. Next time when I am in the city, I would definitely buy it again.

Paesanos on Carlton is the best pizza hands down. Love their wings too! The customer service is amazing. Whenever it's Pizza night, we order from Paesanos!!! Don't make the mistake of ordering from the Vine Street location though. The food and customer service are worlds apart. 5 stars for Carlton Street, zero stars for Vine Street.