First time we went Chicken Riggies & a Pepperoni Roll, then Calzone & Meatball Sub, then tried different slices of pizzas... always got the garlic knots- sooooo good. everything is served hot and made with quality ingredients - everything was delicious! The owners are very friendly, great local authentic food! Love this place! Great staff!

Crust was cooked perfectly. Fresh and tasty ingredients, friendly staff, clean establishment. My family enjoyed these truly large pizzas. It's been a while since we've had a really good pizza.

Very good pizza and wings, and the garlic knots are a must. You can stop by and get a slice or 2. check the special board inside.

We were visiting family there in Chittenango and we wanted to try traditional pizza 🍕. Ordered one of their pizza slice specials: 1 slice of pizza w/drink. Kids enjoyed it. They wanted a 2nd slice. And chicken riggies with side salad. Good portion salad. Chicken riggies was good (a little spicy for me). Texas out of towners.

The owner of this place is Amazing Speaks to everyone , he putt his heart and Soul into his New Building and Pizzeria He's been making Pies in thee area for Years the Product is Excellent and the Service is even Better . A MUST Stop Pizzeria .

Watch out Chittenango you just got legit pizza in town. Amazing crust, and sauce. Dough has great crisp and hands down best ingredients used Ricotta broccoli cheese slice is my staple 8.4 rating and the cheese slice 8.1 worth the stop. You'll be happy and the service is top notch always greet you. Great undercarriage and crisp

WOW.. Forget about it. ONE OF THE BEST PIZZA PLACES. MUST GO HERE. I WOULD EAT HERE EVERY DAY.

Chittenango Pizza Shop is a hidden gem when it comes to delicious food. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. But it was the food that truly stole the show. The pizza at Chittenango Pizza Shop is simply outstanding. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside, yet chewy and flavorful on the inside. The sauce is tangy and robust. And the wings oh boy, they are the best in Central NY! I had the mild and bourbon wings and they were cooked to perfection, with a crispy exterior and tender, juicy meat on the inside. Overall, Chittenango Pizza Shop is a must-visit for any pizza and wing lover. The food is undeniably good, and their pizza and wings truly stand out as the best in Central NY. They also have really good and affordable pizza and wing deals.

The best pepperoni pizza I’ve ever had! Excellent service and I recommend it to everyone!

Best pizza in the area! What an amazing place to get a pizza. The service is very attentive and really goes the extra mile to make sure your food comes out hot and fresh. I had the pleasure to be waited on by the owner, Jimmy. He was so polite and professional. You can really feel his passion for his business. I highly recommend Chittenango Pizza