I've gotten pizza here twice now and its been the equivalent of a cheap arcade pizza with more topping options. The pizza base dough/bread, sauce, and cheese taste extremely low quality like worse than something you'd get at a theme park. The two pizzas I got were one half pepperoni and bacon half mushrooms and onions. That was decent but not good. The second just plain pepperoni which was pretty bad. I honestly only got the 2nd pizza because there was a promotion for a $5 pizza so that was a fair price to me for a bad quality pizza. But buying the pizza here at their normal price of $16+ is an absolute no from me. Honestly I wouldn't buy it again even if it was just $5. It's just really bad. Definitely don't recommend. Also, the tiramisu tastes weird and is $6 for a super tiny cup. I'll add a picture of the empty cup and a quarter for scale and for reference. In summary, there's better pizza everywhere else.

Was greeted the second my family walked in. Gabe was a great server and went above and beyond to make sure our visit was great. The wings and Pizza were amazing 10/10. I don't understand why this places isn't packed. My only tips is to open the shades and let some light in. It was super dark and gloomy. It didnt match your staff great positive energy. Will definitely be back.

After coming back from Upnorth, where the pizza and ranch is just so much better and experiencing hot honey pizza for the first time.. I’ve been on the hunt for it down here ever since. So when I found out Anthony’s was adding it to their menu, I was super excited. My expectations are set high so can’t blame them for not reaching them but a few things I will say about this pizza. I love that the crust is baked and fresh. However, whatever cheese they use is kind of gross.. it certainly doesn’t taste fresh. Once it start to dry, it turns to like a hard plastic texture. Actually not sure if that would be a sign for it being more real or fake? And then the price. It’s pretty expensive for this small basic pizza… compared to paying the same price for a large NY style pizza back home. Overall it was good to try but would not come back just for it.

The food is incredible scratch made Italian pizza and sides. Best chicken Caesar salad I have ever had, with their own homemade croutons and Caesar dressing. They offer great perks as part of their email club but the prices are on the high side due to the high quality ingredients and everything made to order. This is not fast food, so expect wait times equal to that of your average sit down restaurant. After many incredible experiences over the last 3 years, both dine in and takeout, our most recent visit on a busy weekend evening was disappointing as there was minor allergen cross contamination, overcooked chicken, and not enough dressing on the salad. Hoping it was just a case of an overly busy dinner time service and not an indication that quality is headed downhill.

The best fired pizza in town. I am a frequent customer, my household loves pizza! Anthony's coal fired pizza is consistently excellent in both service reliability and quality of product. You simply cannot find a better deal. My favorite combination is the pepperoni and hot fingerling peppers. Mamma Mia!!!

I found the food was okay to poor. Pizza: liked the crust but the broccoli was clumped and a bit soggy. Fairly easy to remove though. Wings: All but two wings were burnt quite badly (more than one would expect even given a coal oven). Service: The person attending the take out orders was a bit overwhelmed. I saw my order come up (did not know it was mine until handed to me), but noticed the gal looked at it and then went on to something else three times before handing it to me. Atmosphere was lively and folks seemed happy.

It’s been awhile since dining at Anthony’s, and I must say, it’s better than I remembered. The wings are absolutely fantastic as I’m a sucker for caramelized onions. The meatballs are some of the best I’ve ever had and they are huge. Katie was me and my families server and she was attentive and great for us. Will not be waiting so long in between visits again!