Worst pizza ever, cold, toppings were raw.. raw onion, raw jalepeno. Instead of giving me a refund.. will lose my business... told me since pizza guy wasn't there he couldn't verify what I had stated, Basically calling me a liar. I picked my pizza up... it was cold...I think it had been pretty made even though this was 1pm... they warmed it up and threw the typing on it.. barely any sauce.. disgusting. Thru 30.00 in trash.. order from willys, or tiramasu.. this place IS THE WORST

Ordered 3 pizzas over the phone, they even repeated that it was 3 pizzas, then gave us a total. We get here. They messed up our pizzas and then charged us more for their mistakes!!! Lady at the counter said yeah I'm charging you for our mess up. That's not how you run a business. You messed up I shouldn't have to pay for your mistakes!!! Don't go here!! NOT worth the money!!!

OMG! Get a dozen of the garlic knots, they are so F'ing good. Ambrosia. This is the best pizza I have had in years, and that includes in Italy and New York...

The food was ok, but a little cold by the time we got it back to our hotel. The fried mozzerella had solidified, the spaghetti was ok. Pizza was overcooked. Garlic knots were cold. Service when we ordered by phone was curt and gruff. Check for napkins and utensils! Wr didn't get any and got back to our room with no way to eat! We received everything the way we ordered it.

Terrible service, rude older lady was completely overwhelmed and ignoring or talking over patrons, including myself when I asked why my order wasn’t ready yet after waiting an excessive amount of time. Chaotic atmosphere - this level of bad service isn’t acceptable. Will not return to this restaurant. Too many other good pizza places in Jupiter to mess with this place.

I moved here from New Jersey so I seen goodfellas pizza and thought I'll give you guys some business, so I ordered 14 pies for Easter.... and yes I confirmed it 2 different days that the pizza will be ready and delivered by 1:30 to gumbo park. Well, I guess the person that took the order didn't realize what day April 17th was because we were waiting around for 30 mins and no pizza. We called and no answer, so we had no other option we just gave up and had to order from another pizza place. Lack of knowledge and lack of common sense of your open and closed days almost ruined a bunch of little kids Easter. I have to say due to this experience I'll never recommend or do another event with this company.

They delivered rancid and undercooked food and refused to give a refund. Been here a few times and it was good. Tonight was the last time. We ordered two subs, a stromboli, and chicken wings. They forgot the blue cheese sauce we paid extra for. Not a big deal, but annoying. I took a bite of the Italian sub and it tasted weird. Upon inspection, the salami was grey and green, looked slimy, and smelled awful. I cut off one end of the stromboli and what I thought was a golf ball sized hunk of cheese was actually uncooked dough. We called the store and said they could come pick up the rancid sub and raw stromboli to see for themselves. The manager declined and offered a $20 credit instead. We said we would prefer a refund because we would likely not be using that credit. He said we could come into the store, but they would just give us a gift card. What?! Really?! We ordered over $50 of food for delivery, you forgot something we paid for and could have potentially sent me to the hospital, but you won't put $20 back on my credit card? I'm still sitting here grossed out and hoping I don't get sick. That's the last time we will spend our money there.

An absolute hidden gem of a pizza restaurant! Tucked into the corner of a Publix plaza is a tiny little pizza place run by a couple Italian dudes who couldn’t possibly be any sweeter! I tried a slice of pepperoni, a grandma, and the everything. I couldn’t finish them all, but they were tremendously good! If you’re in the area I’d highly recommend it. I can see why Dave rated them a 7.5! It’s got some good crisp, but the guys inside are a 10!

Very good pizza with one of the best crusts I have ever had. I am from the north east where we have many good pizza options and this one is very good.

I used to be a regular. I decided to no longer patronize this establishment. Recently, I had disappointing experiences and at least twice there were issues with the quality of the food. Additionally, I found the customer service to be unfriendly and unaccommodating. I felt hesitant to bring up any concern, as I was worried about potential pushback from the staff. With so many other pizza restaurants in the area, I feel confident that one can find a better option.

Wasn’t planning on grabbing a slice but as my kids were getting ice cream at Whit’s next door I grabbed the 2 slice and soda combo for $7.75 and it hit the spot after spending the day at Dubois Park. My daughters probably won’t admit it but they probably liked it more than the ice cream as they ate most of the pie. NY style pies if you are wondering.

Very small quantity of toppings. This pizza sucked. The toppings are really sparse, it appears someone was trying REALLY hard to save money. At nearly $3 a topping, I want to see more than 20 pepperoni on a whole 18" pizza. There were maybe 4 or 5 tiny mushrooms per giant slice. And maybe 4 or 5 pepperoni. Some of these slices have THREE pepperoni on the entire slice. You've got to be kidding me. The mushrooms are almost non-existent. I'm not mad about there not being a lot of banana peppers on there. But the pepperoni and mushrooms - you get way more toppings at Domino's 🙄 It looks like they paid someone $8 an hour to make this and told them if they use too many toppings they're fired. This is one sad pizza with a sad quantity of toppings.

Great staff - very accommodating. Indoor seating that is perfect to cool down from the beach, but also has shaded tables outdoor. Seems like outdoor world be dog-friendly. Most importantly, authentic Italian pizza that tastes amazing. Will definitely be back.

Did not have a good take out experience there. 3x it took to get the small order correct. Must have been an off day. I tried calling for take out one thursday and called many times with no one answering the phone. Had to use another pizza place.

Ordered via phone call, the girl who took my orde4 was friendly. The pizza was tasty, hood crust, good sauce.

Best pizza place in South Florida by far! Not only are the various slices amazing. The calzones are huge and phenomenal. The homemade sauce is incredible as are all of the Parmesan sandwiches and baked pastas. Joe the owner couldn’t be nicer. He always knows what we want every time and gives my mother extra Caesar salad dressing

Overall a very great tasting slice of pizza. Great sauce to cheese ratio. Although the crust was a little soggy. A lot of flop. Only thing holding this slice from being a 5 star slice. But as a New Yorker. Its great to find some decent pie around here.

Went in for some take out tonight for the first time. Got a 16” pizza and some wings and they were both great. The vibe is casual, warm and welcoming… old school NY photos cover the walls. Would recommend for sure if you’re craving some NY style pizza in Jupiter.

Saw Barstools reviewed (with a high score!) and had to check out! Impressive NY style pizza! Crust was perfect from a crispness and char standpoint, just enough sauce, we had green pepper as a topping and loved it! Super easy online ordering too. Looks like a great menu - will make this my Jupiter pizza go to! Woo hoo!

I’ve been here for the last 7 years and it’s good pizza. We always order an 18” cheese and it’s baked perfectly. I highly recommend their garlic bread knots with fresh garlic on top. I wouldn’t recommend the cheese ravs as they can be under fried and just not very tasty. Cannolis are very solid and not mushy. The price has always been considerably well priced and deliveries are usually early and carry out is done on time.

Wowed that i Finally found NY style pizza. For me there’s No going elsewhere!, Mom and Pop joint at it’s Finest!, dine in, takeout, it’s All good!

I’m a very picky pizza person, but I have to say the pizza was pretty good. The sauce had a great flavor. I would probably order it again. The biggest problem was the garlic on the garlic rolls. Who uses jarred garlic in an Italian joint?! Made the rolls taste sour. Gross. Always use FRESH garlic, Goodfellas. Always.