Smooth transaction with Jason. I bought an Omega Seamaster 1957 and sold a Rolex Sub. Fair prices all around. Thank you. I’ll be back.

I really don’t like to leave bad reviews but I have tried to get this resolved and this company just does not care. I was sold a watch with the wrong dial. I have attached pics of what I received and what the watch is supposed to be. I bought a Breitling Navitimer 806 AOPA which serial number dates back to a 1959 model. The watch I received has a dial that was introduced 4 years later. Jessica handed the phone to a person who claims their name was Chad. He declined my full refund as he thinks these dials were interchangeable. I disagreed and send him proof difference official sources such as 3 Breitling Historians, Boutique approved links to official websites as well as the Boutique confirming my claim. I called 7 times asking to please talk to the owner to plead my case but never received a call back. Since they will not tell me which store should take ownership of this issue and I bought the watch out of state. I am leaving this review on all related stores to the Collectors Coins Jewelry Watches. Again, I have emails, texts, invoice, phone history records and more to prove my claim. If the owner never received my many messages and emails please get with Jessica, Chad and Mike. Your website talks about earning a reputation as experts appraisers but yet you sold me a Franken and will not admit to your mistake. Originality is everything toma collector and it is sad you have people working for you who will not stand behind your own company motto treating people integrity and respect which are neither things I experienced.

Eddie made the jewelry selling experience convenient, speedy, friendly and stress-free. It was a little busy when we came into the store and he acknowledged us right away and greeted us and asked how he could help. Which made a difference for us. He was professional, honest and trustworthy instantly you can tell he knew what he was talking about and he was doing it with integrity. The prices seemed very fair and we were very happy with the experience. It was a little bit of a drive for us, but completely worth the trip! Thank you Eddie!

Top notch all the way! I was nervous about trading my Rolex with a company so far away. Vinnie made me feel very comfortable and did not pressure me. I did a little research on the company and found out they have an excellent reputation so I decided to do business with them. I’m very glad I did... excellent selection and they gave me an excellent price and trade on my Rolex. One of the most important things when you buy a luxury watch is WHO you buy from. These guys should always be on that list no matter how far away you are. I will be trading with them again for sure.

The best transaction I’ve ever had! SO SMOOTH SO EASY AND SO WONDERFUL! I wired them money and had my watch the next day! EXACTLY how it was described! The experience was 10/10 i am already looking to buy me second watch from them! Shipping was so fast and the customer service was amazing! Everything went amazing! Thank you guys so much I love my new Rolex!

Kevin did a fantastic job helping me acquire my new Rolex. Customer service was excellent throughout the entire process. Pricing was very fair. The watch was delivered next day in the exact condition as advertised. Very happy with our transaction. I will be a repeat customer.

Bought 2 watches today from Jessica at the massapequa shop. What a absolute pleasure. Super professional and knowledgeable. The only place for me when I add other Swiss Watches to my collection. 5 Star rating for Jessica and her associates.

Bought a sub 2016 birth year watch for my son and Kevin was amazing and very kind. Gave me an amazing clean / almost new looking sub at a fair price, shipped lighting fast and secure . Definitely coming back again for the gmt.

Sold some gold bullion here for a very competitive price and was able to trade it for a Daytona white gold here. Mint condition been a great addition to my collection. Eddie has helped me collect all my dream pieces one at a time

ABSOLUTYLY 100% Satisfied with my purchase. If I could add stars to this review I would. Jason was extremely helpful and patient while I did my own due diligence in confirming the store's legitimacy and was a consummate professional from start to finish. The process of purchasing the watch of my dreams (one that I have wanted since I was 17 years old....I turn 50 this month) was seamless. I can not stress enough how happy I am with the piece, and the customer service that I have experienced with Jason and Collectors Coins Jewelry and watches. 100000000% recommend! KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK!

Fantastic service, and experience. Kevin made the process as smooth as can be. I purchased my first ever watch with Kevin, and I have no regrets. He gave me a great deal and now has a forever client that will always keep coming back to do business.

I purchased a Rolex Skydweller today from Eddie. The price was better than any competitor near my office in NYC. I traded in a Rolex Submariner and the price her offered in trade was also better than any competitor I spoke to and if I sold on EBay I would’ve netted less. Pleasant and knowledge and fun to work with. Highly recommend

I recently purchased a beautiful, perfect condition Rolex GMT from Jessica. She was helpful, patient and provided me with exceptional customer service. Thank you Jessica!!

Came in to purchase and trade a watch. Dealt with Jason and Eddie. I was very satisfied with the purchase and trade. They both were great to work with and seemed like genuinely good people. Eddie definitely made me laugh even though Hes a tough negotiator, but i got a fair deal. Originally i was not 100% on this place because i had never heard of them but after dealing with them I’m confident in everything and would definitely return to do more business. Thanks guys!

I purchased and sold quite a few watches from Dan here at coin collectors. Each time he was honest, fair and exceeded my expectations with excellent customer service. I would recommend him to friends and family and I already have, my brother also purchased from him and had a great experience as well! Thank you collector coins and Dan we appreciate you!

My experience was beyond 5 stars! I was searching for more than just a Luxury timepiece I was searching for a place that I felt deserved my hard earned dollars... Eddie made that happen! Shortly after making my online purchase (about 30 mins later) Eddie called me to let me know he received the payment and it was being shipped that day Two days later it was at my door This Timepiece has exceeded my expectations Thank you Collectors Coins Jewelry Watches!

Five stars for Sam and Kevin, great guys, not pushy, great price, i had my Batgirl! I will buy a Daytona next!

Bought a Rolex Datejust from them about 2 weeks ago. Very friendly and knowledgeable. Didn't feel like they just took my money and ran. If your in the market for one I suggest you go to them. Went back and bought A submariner from Eddie. They are the best no BS what you see is what you get the deal you make is true no hidden fees no BS. Really a great guy and a great shop

Vincenzo is best in the business!!! Very honest and knowledgeable helped source me my dream Rolex watch . Customer for life

Eddie, Vinny, Jason & Arthur @ Collectors are the only guys & is the only place I’d ever buy my watches or jewelry from these guys know there stuff inside & out honest I’ve now bought 5 high end pieces from them & they blow the rest of the competitors out of the water. If you want guys who know their stuff, don’t play games, are honest & truthful this is the only place of all of the jewelry stores I’ve been to in the city or LI. Can’t say enough about how great they take care of their clientele & how they value relationship’s & appreciate the business! Thanks again guys!