They don't wear masks. *edit bc they replied* THE OWNERS FAMILY DOESNT WEAR MASKS. I recognize the daughter, she's the one who condescendingly spoke to me as I left. I can't remember her name but i know that face. I actually worked here 20 years ago and wish i could still patronize the establishment. The food is good, the policies are not. And now the disingenuous lying when it was the owner. Lol. I just want to protect my family feom a worldwide pandemic and I'm sure there's others who want the information I'm providing.

I am getting sick and tired of them using old meat on their sandwiches. Their bacon always tastes old and nasty, now the ham is bad and they thought that by cooking it, it would be alright. I hope someone checks the expiration dates at there location.

We came for bagels and cream cheese. Both were very tasty. Reasonably priced as well, $10 for 6 bagels and half pound of cream cheese.

There was something so satisfying about eating actually good bagels while staring out the window at Panera. $3 for a bagel with plain cream cheese, or $3.50 with flavored cream cheese. $5.75 for a bacon, egg, & cheese. The bagels are perfect—chewy on the inside, crispy on the outside. And the decor makes you feel like you’ve been transported to NJ. Highly recommend.

Great bagel place for breakfast or lunch. They have pork roll and crumb cake if you're from Jersey and need a fix. My husband's only complaint was that the everything bagels didn't have salt.

Used to order from here all the time. Just ordered a breakfast sandwich. They gave us 2 when we ordered 1. Both were absolutely terrible. The bacon wasn't cooked at all. Couldn't eat either sandwich. If this was my first time ordering, I would never order again.

Never been to stuff a bagel prior but stopped in because I know they had donated to my kids school and I am glad I did. Had a sausage and egg sandwich on everything bagel, it was really good. I love the east coast NYC ambience, what a great local small business. Will definitely be coming back.

Best bagels we've ever had! Stopped here twice on our vacation. Amazing food. Staff was so helpful and welcoming. I couldnt recommend this place more highly.

Best bagels in the area. Tasty, fresh cream cheese by the tub. Best bacon & egg bagel sandwiches. Good hot pastrami for when that craving hits. They deliver through UberEats & GrubHub, if you can’t get there in person.

The only spot for bagels in SW FL. Well they are the only place for NY/NJ bagels. I thought I had to compromise coming down here. Thanks for making a bagel not having to compromise on.

My boyfriend is from NJ and introduced me to what real bagels are supposed to taste like (honestly coming from the midwest I had no clue). This place easily is the best around. You know it's good when they don't toast the bagels. They are fresh, huge, and they do not hold back on the cream cheese. I dream about these bagels.

This has been My husband and My favorite bagel spot FOR 10+ YEARS! Not once have we ever gone and been upset about anything in anyway! We love their food it's not pricey the bagels are big and good amount of stuff inside!! I wish they stayed open later into the day BUT THAT'S NEITHER HERE OR THERE... ACTUALLY PLANNING ON GOING THIS SATURDAY!! PORK ROLL BAGEL HERE WE COME 😆🤤THE STAFF IS SO NICE AND YOU CAN TELL THE MEN WHO DINE INSIDE COME THERE PROBABLY EVERYDAY!! CUTE OLDER FRIENDLY SET OF MEN. I JUST LOVE IT HERE!!

Ham and egg and cheese on an everything bagel this morning. Delicious! I've had a pumpernickel before and that was great. The bagel had just the right chewy texture and the cheese was melty. The portion of ham was appropriate. Sliced in half, it was easy to eat though I would be careful around your computer as those poppy seeds get in the keys! Fresh food takes a few minutes to be prepared and yes, this did take a bit while I waited. Inside and outside seating. Arrows painted on the floor help keep things organized.

My fellow co workers and I are so great full for this amazing food. Stuff A Bagel is our go too when we’re in town. When you literally don’t care how long the line is or how long it will take to get your food…you know it’s amazing!! The service is always on point and we enjoy visiting with them. Thank you all for making our trip great.

Had the Mario breakfast and it was absolutely delicious! Home fries were cooked perfectly. And yes they use real butter on the bagels! Bacon was a generous portion for the price! Great choice

Very good bagel and cream cheese, it just missed 5 stars because of how incredibly messy my bagel to-go was in the wrapper. When I opened the wrapper, the bagel was half covered in cream cheese. Never had that before from other bagels I've ordered to-go

Wonderful place for a quick, yet not fast food, breakfast. Courteous and friendly staff. A very comfortable place to eat and not feel rushed. Love Stuff A Bagel!

I went to the Milton location after my Quest visit. Having fasted for 16 hrs, I thought I would treat myself to an onion bagel and cream cheese. It was SO delicious!! Reminds me of the bagels back home in NY. There were two people working that day, a young man, and a young lady, and they couldn’t be any nicer! So welcoming and kind. It’s really hard to find that at restaurants today, but they were wonderful! I will definitely visit this location as well as the Pine Island location. Closer to my home. The bagels and cream cheese are exceptional!

Stopped in on Saturday morning around 8:30 for a half dozen bagels. These bagels were far from fresh. In fact, I’m pretty sure they were yesterday’s bagels. They were stale, stiff, and cold. I thought it might just be me being overly picky, but my family all said the same thing. Disappointing experience for my occasional weekend bagel treat.

I have been going to this store for years and driving an hour to get there. They always treated me like family, and I’ve experienced great and quality service. However this visit was different. The cashier was downright rude. In addition, I didn’t get an itemized receipt, so I went back in and waited in line for one. When I finally got to the front of the line, she told me she had to help the people behind me first. I paid extra to have the bagels sliced because it’s hard for me to cut them. When I got home, I realized they were cut about 50% through, so I still had to cut them. There was also a sign on the door that said they are charging an extra 4% for customers who pay by credit card. Even after years of going there, I’m rethinking whether I want to go back after the rude service, extra wait, poor quality work, and extra charges.

The woman that took my order was not very nice..there was no smile or greeting she just took my order and left. When my order was done she called my name and tossed my plate on the counter and walked away. If I hadn’t payed for my order already I would have walked out. I asked for my bagel to be toasted and it was not. The sandwich was decent that’s why I’m giving this 3 stars. I’m visiting from NY and I expected better service. Will not come back here again.

Wow what a bagel !!! Super yummy and great value for money. we were in Cape Coral for 2 weeks and sadly only found this place in our 2nd week but still managed to get take out 3 times including one for the flight home. Lovely family atmosphere.

it’s tough to find decent bagels outside of the NY/NJ area but this place is as close to a taste of home as you can get.

If you've never been here - go. You won't be disappointed! The food is so good and I'm getting hungry just thinking about it

Love this place ! Arrived at 5am, quick friendly service : ) Got the Mario’s special and it was delish ! Amazing that this NYC style joint is in Cape Coral : ) Thank You Brothers and Happy Holidays 🙏

I absolutely love stuff a bagel!!! Been a regular since 2010 and wouldn’t go anywhere else. Staff is very friendly and accommodating to people with food allergies/sensitivity. Love the Tuesday special. One time my mask broke at the register and the sweet woman behind the counter offered me a new one immediately, bless her!

We eat here probably three times a week. Great local place for authentic boiled bangles. Great service. Family atmosphere...can't beat it.

Excellent breakfast, I am originally from NY and the breads are delicious, mentioned this to my son and he informed me that the owner tankers the water in from NY to make the kaiser rolls and the bagels. I guess it really does matter.

Phone number does not work. Last 3 times I came in something went wrong. First,, they never gave me all of my food I ordered but she charges me. She did not toast my 4 bagles when I asked. Lady was impatient. I come in to try to support local business also my daughter loves there bagles. I don't know this happens. Good food but service is not so great

Love this spot! Everything bagel and whitefish salad is my go to :) They are so friendly I love going whenever back in the Cape! I wouldn't go anywhere else, even my dog Wrigley is a fan!

I got a egg and cheese on an everything bagel and it was to die for! The bagel was the best, so soft! The coffee is really good too. Can't wait to try it again

Great bagels. I'm from NJ and the owners are from NY, so they know how to make bagels. Loved all the sports memorabilia on the wall.

Got bagels, lox, and cream cheese to go this morning. Very tasty. Staff was friendly. Definitely going back while I’m in town. Support your local businesses folks.

I went with my boyfriend and it was our very first time going here ! The scenery and decorations captivate you. I loved the service and everyone was so kind. I loved the food I got and will be going here when I can :) great establishment HIGHLY recommended!

Absolutely the best! First time visiting this location and I unfortunately dropped my bagel order on the floor. I felt terrible, but the staff was so incredibly kind. They quickly replaced it and even threw in some extra, which they did NOT have to do. Food is amazing-just like Jersey. Can’t beat a family-owned business with great product and great people. Highly recommend and will definitely continue to support this place!