The food is fantastic and definitely worth the price. We got the Rocco sandwich and added prosciutto, delicious! We also got to try out the rice ball special which was also amazing! Anthony went out of his way to make my boys mozzarella sticks even though they don't normally have them on the menu. My husband went back the next day for another sandwich and brought back some cheesecake cones which were also sooo good! We'll definitely be coming back often! Can't wait to try out their breakfast!

I heard a lot about this place so I had to try it out… I was absolutely blown away. One of the first things I always look at is cleanliness…I give them and A+ for that…very clean. The food was fresh and really had that homemade taste. I could sometimes be a tough critic when it comes to good food. Anthony’s did not disappoint…I will be back again! 2-20-22 Update: Food gets better and better. Chicken Cutlet fresh mozzarella roasted peppers and Balsamic glaze was excellent.

Outrageous is an understatement. The bread is legit Italian bread, the cutlet was perfect-not tough or chewy. Generous with the filling. Sauces were authentic. We ordered the nonna and the in law. So so tasty. Very happy to have a place like this nearby. You made this first gen Sicilian girl quite happy 😉

Can someone tell me What happened to Anthony's??? The sign is off and it's not the same !! They answered as Anthony's so I ordered but received some bootleg sandwich with hard old bread!!! :( I literally just ordered a catering platter on sept 2, 2023 and now today it's gone??

It’s a pizza place that is now there. It’s not nowhere near the quality. Got two subs. The The bread was not as good as when the place was called Anthony’s from Brooklyn. The place is just not the same. Don’t know why they still Say Anthony’s from Brooklyn on the menu board. Definitely not as good as what it used to be.

EDIT: NEW OWNERS!!! Not the same, won’t step foot in there again. So upset, Anthony’s food was the best. Tastes like home!!! So far we’ve tried the Italian hero, Nonnas special, and vodka pie which were all delicious. The Italian bread is from my go to place when I lived on the island and they use BOARS HEAD sliced thin…what more can I ask for?! Finally, I can get a good hero without having to drive an hour north!

Eggplant fresh mozzarella arugula and balsamic glaze. The bread was super fresh and the sandwich was so tasty. Also got the #5 the Santino. Sandwiches were delicious. Also purchased 7 layer cookies the best around. Highly recommend will definitely be going back

My wife and I ordered a full tray of mac&cheese and a half tray of potato salad for a party and those were the 2 items we were asked to bring. We were charged $200!!! We were pressed for time and had decided to just pay the ridiculous price. The Mac & cheese was definitely below average and definitely not what you’d expect for that price. The potato salad was also below average. I will personally never go there again nor recommend them. Absolute price gauging and below average food.

Bought two subs a meatball and an eggplant sub. 30 dollars. Left store opened subs and they were both ice cold. Took subs back and asked to speak to owner. I was told he would call me. 5 calls later and he still has not called me. I just wanted my money back for getting cold subs. I' would be careful buying from here. I was really liking the food. They don't want to take responsibility for giving a refund for sub standard food that was returned. I gave every opportunity for them to make this right before writing this. Customer service is horrible.

I came into the restaurant today and I ordered a whole cheesesteak. The employee was professional and my food was delicious. This place is definitely worth a try. 10/10 will definitely be back.

Ordered the beast, was one of the best subs I’ve ever had! These guys know how to make a good sandwich and are extremely polite and professional. Will definitely be back!!!