This is probably one of the best little pizza places I have ever been too, the pizza has a very good oven crispy taste and fresh ingredients blend well with this pie. If you’re a big fan of fire brick oven style pizza and like that style this is a great friendly place to try. The staff was super helpful and friendly and the prices were very affordable for any budget!

When Maxies in Twin Falls closed, we were left without a way to satisfy that craving our family had developed over decades of patronage. When we heard of the connection with Monterey Jack's in Kimberly, we had to try it out! And I'm pleased to announce that the crust and toppings are nearly identical to what we remember. The herbs recreate the flavor we love, completing the package. It's our new go-to pizza place when in the county.

Lovely home town pizzeria and so much more more! Delicious pizza , especially if you liked Maxie pizza , and their pasta sauce s are just like you remember. The burgers and other menus items are very delicious. The staff is courteous and helpful!

Was not impressed to walk in and see 3-4 employees glare at me today, I do understand everyone has their bad days so I'm not mad, hell I do it at my job every once and a while, looking at other reviews and from personal experience attitude is a big problem that needs work. My rating is only high because food was great as always and service time is great every time I come here.

Ordered two Calzones for delivery. The order arrived and discovered that I had been delivered two individual pizzas. I hailed the delivery person as he was entering his car and told him of the mistake and went to hand him the pizzas. The nice young man told me to keep the pizzas and said he would return shortly. Sometime later he returned with the calzones with "sorry" written in marker on one of the boxes. What a refreshing change from what I have experienced in what I believe is a decline in customer service in numerous industries over the years. I also think that the new owners are putting out a far better product as both the calzone and pizza for lunch the next day was delicious. I will defiantly recommend this establishment. Good job , Russ

Great little family run business. Prices are reasonable, everyone is friendly and the food is great. They have a loaded salad bar. I've had the Ruben sandwich and pizza. Both are top notch.

The lasagna is insanely good! You absolutely have to try it. Salad bar if good as well.

Good food. Nice menu. Italian but something for anyone (anyone reasonable). Pleasant staff.

Stopped in on our way through town. Best gluten free pizza I have had! Such a cute place.

Ed Bryant is a genius and he prepares such incredible food. In the evening they deliver but honestly the lady answering the phone can be short and seem unfriendly....push through because the food is phenomenal. I just wish she was more polite....but I can't short this place on starts because of one unkind employee- most do but not this chic. Use to be known as Maxie's....now Monterey Jacks....same great food !and owner. May I say more? Probably but I am about to devour perfect spaghetti!!! NumNum

New name, still awesome pizza! When we want awesome pizza we drive to Kimberly! Always busy, for good reason! I have never had an issue with freshness, quality or taste. We haven’t dined in but take out experience has been good. Sometimes there is a short wait (small crowd) for carryout but at least you know your pizza is hot and fresh! Consistently awesome!

Friendly and on time, delicious! I'm glad we are still able to have the pizza we've enjoyed for 50+ years. :)

Been here a couple times and felt the pizza was very overpriced, low quality, and they messed up my order one time. I'm easy to please, but this is one place I know I won't be back to

Impressed with their quality of Italian food. Their pizza is amazing and their Italian plates well done and tasty! Great place to eat in Kimberly, Idaho! Thank you Monterey Jacks!

The general vibe from the waitress was "Why did you come here? This place sucks." And she was right. Two stars for your honesty.

Very nice and I like that they are honest. Sometimes people will tell you an order will be ready in 10 minutes and it takes 30, when this place stops 10 to 15, it was right on time! Thank you!

Hadn't been here in years. And other than some changes in the decor, it was the same as I remembered it. Truly one of my favorite pizza places.

Best pizza, homemade ranch, and warmed up marina sauce! I give 5 stars for the food but while waiting for our pizza to go, I noticed the inside could use an update or deep cleaning. Staff were beyond helpful and very nice!

Very pricey, but get what you pay for nowadays. Food is above average although not by much. Quite atmosphere, friendly employees. Must at least give it a try decide for yourself. Location is convenient to driving and foot traffic. I would eat the more often if I could afford to, that is the only draw back for me, otherwise it would have got five stars.. Price may not be a barrier for you so give them a try.

Omgoodness Yes!!! Don't let the name fool you - it is so much more than just pizza! Every town needs a great Italian restaurant and we found it here. Great specials, awesome pizza selections and yummy pasta offerings. The salad bar is so fresh, cold, and clean. It is full of delightful dishes. The baked tortellini is delicious as is the spaghetti. The folks are so nice. We cannot wait to come back and try everything!