This has got to be one of the best fish stores I've *ever* had the pleasure of shopping at!! I moved from Indianapolis to a little town north of Evansville at the start of 2022, having grown up my whole life on the southside of Indy, I had to start over and find new places to shop at for my critters. I'm so glad that I stopped here on a whim in the beginning of January of this year to get back into aquatics - they quite literally blew my expectations out of the water, lmao. Out of all the fish stores and pet shops I've been to up north and here inbetween, this place takes the cake hands down! The guys that work here are absolutely phenomenal, they're well versed in what they do and are so friendly. It's a genuine place with genuine people. You'll never regret coming here, even if it's just to visit! The store is set up in a visually appealing manner, it's neat to say the least. It's cool seeing the vast selection of stuff from saltwater to freshwater, they've got great livestock selections available, even plants too! One of the best things, though? They have a rewards program now! 🤩 You can earn rewards everytime you shop! So if you're in doubt, local to the area or just visiting, and are looking for a place to stop at for any of your fishy needs.... look no further, **THIS** is the place to go!

The staff are very nice. I worked with Jeff to create an order for my 220 gallon fish tank. He was very patient and answered all the questions I had about the fish and coral. The order was shipped out in a timely manner that fit my schedule and weather. The fish and coral all arrived healthy in good condition. To my surprise there was a freebie coral in the package! I would defiantly order from Whitlyn Aquatics again.

Staff is always helpful and eager to help you find what you're looking for. They will answer all questions asked and give advice when needed. Highly recommend and will always go to Whitlyn Aquatics before any big branded aquatic stores!

Absolutely love the Whitlyn Aquatics staff, products, and definitely the CORALS! You won’t find better maintained livestock around I can guarantee that. Wish I could give more than 5 stars in all honesty. You won’t be disappointed.

I never have a bad experience here. I was immediately greeted by Jeanie (hope I’m spelling that right) asking me what I needed help with. Jeanie was so sweet to my kiddos, they love seeing the turtles and she pulled one out for them to see. I usually stop by every few weeks and the customer service is always great and the fish are healthy.

This shop has a good selection of corals at reasonable prices. Everything was healthy and happy with my purchase. Saw their coral farm and had a ton of great looking coral. It was worth the 2 hour drive.

If I could give them 10 stars I would. Their customer service was amazing. I ordered 5 Amazon puffers to be delivered in Texas and received my fish the next day! Before sending them out I received a phone call to verify that someone will be home to accept them and every question I had was answered either on the phone or through email! I will definitely use this company again!

Only purchased online and man are they good at it. Top notch customer service. Jeffs great to work with. Weekend auctions always run smooth with high end pieces. No complaints at all for me. Keep it up guys!

Amazing customer service. Orange Passion frag super healthy & 0 pest. Definitely adding to favorites. A++

Amazing experience! Their website is awesome (and looks great) with great prices for exactly what I was looking for. They reached out beforehand to give me a choice about what I ordered and were nice and professional. Everything came healthy but with one casualty (which happens with shipping fish unfortunately) that they made right immediately. Thank you! ^____^

Awesome store! Very nice owner! Drove from Vincennes and will again!

I recently ordered two freashwater catfish and had them shipped. After emailing back and forth for a couple of days the fish were shipped and arrived the next day. The package did arrive wet but that is no fault of Whitlyn Aquatics. Both fish were alive and doing well, it has now been a couple of days in a quarantine tank. Both of them are eating and swimming around well. Thank you Whitlyn Aquatics for making this easy and as stress free as possible for everyone (including the fish)!

First time buying from Whitlyn Aquatics and I am so happy with my order!!! They were exactly what I ordered and as pictured.. Corals came in on time and packaged well… I will be buying from this company again!! Thank you so much!!!

Went in here earlier today for a new tank I was setting up and ended up waiting for a really long time without anyone even acknowledging I was there. Nobody would help me.

Awesome staff, nice store, nice selection of aquariums and accessories. Nice selection of healthy fish.

They are so knowledgeable with their products and livestock. They help get what you want even if it's out of stock. They know you by name when you're there enough lol. Seriously, love this place and appreciate all they've done!

We just bought a sump from them last week and turned out we didn't need it, brand new and never used. They wouldn't take it back or refund in any way (in store credit or even a quarter of the price) because the box was cut open and they stated that they already restocked this product. Just so everyone knows since they don't have a sign posted that 'every purchase is final', don't try returning anything especially if its expensive because they won't do anything for you. bad customer service and I would not recommend this place. Great quality but horrible business practice and for a "small business" as they like to throw in, they don't seem to want to keep their customers

Very nice and knowledgeable man. Took his time to help use find just what we needed. Both fresh and saltwater fish and supplies. We will visit quite often I'm sure.....

Amazing store for salt water aquariums. The tanks are super clean, alot of beautiful fish. The corals are very good looking with alot of variety and good prices. The staff are super friendly knowledgeable and helpful. Recommend visiting this awesome fish store!