Extremely overpriced… I’m never one to complain but my jaw dropped at the prices. Some clothing was ripped with hefty price tags as well. Also, some of the “designer” being sold was inauthentic. As someone who used to be in the streetwear business, it’s easy to tell the difference. Do yourself a favor and don’t shop here. edit for the reply: My complaints about other businesses having unfair pricing is correct. However, where does that give you as a business over the audacity to tell me I can’t afford your items? This snarky reply is another reason why no one should shop here. Yes, I am in the streetwear business which means I understand correct pricing. Don’t ever shop here, and give this rude old hag any of your money.

Visiting my Brother, I always like to do a little shopping on the Island, well, I found my place to be a constant! Robert was immediately very accommodating as well as his adorable Mom! I bought a bag full of jewelry for the crafts that I make, what a selection to chose from! They were super nice and kind to me ♥️

Rude owner and overpriced. She screamed at my friend of color and stared at him the entire time we were shopping. Both of us were extremely uncomfortable. I would not give this woman any business.

Bought two really beautiful cashmere sweaters and a mint condition leather Coach bag. Great designer finds and reasonable prices. I definitely will be back!

Awesome shopping experience! My sister in law bought beautiful earrings for her sons upcoming wedding, my daughter bought a gorgeous ring for herself and a cute pair of earrings for my granddaughter and I bought several pairs of earrings. All in all a memorable experience. Robert was extremely friendly and knowledgeable! I will definitely be returning to the shop the next time I visit my sister in law.

I just loved shopping in this store! So many beautiful hats, sweaters, coats, vintage wear,is knick knacks, jewelry OMG stuffed with some much merchandise! Robert was clearly the star of the show! Fun loving comedic guy that makes you want to go back just to say hello to him! He makes shopping 🛍 Fun.I am not from the area but worth the drive!

SUBLIME shopping experience! So much amazing merchandise at more than reasonable prices. Rob was so funny and helpful and sweet—what a character! Spent 3+ hours perusing the huge and varied collection. Truly a hidden gem on Long Island. Will be back very soon!

One of my favorite stores in the whole world. Rob is incredible, Cooky is incredible. The pieces are mix of incredible vintage and perfectly priced designer. You cannot go wrong, and you will spend a long time perusing. I am alwayssss excited to come to Cooky’s and I always leave at least twice as happy as when I entered.