Bay Shore Inn image

Bay Shore Inn

Hotel

Unassuming hotel featuring colorful, basic rooms with free Wi-Fi, plus minifridges on request. People often mention room, night,


Address

300 Bay Shore Rd, Bay Shore, NY 11706

Contact

(631) 666-7275

Rating on Google Maps

3.10 (443 reviews)

Open on Google Maps

Featured Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: room (18) night (6)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 2/5 Cynthia Amaya ('The A. 9 months ago on Google β€’ 143 reviews
    Pricey for the type of room $150/Sat night. Asked for a non-smoking room and yet you coupd smell smoke. Poorly painted walls. Hallway paneling is popping up and are taped up. After being in the room for an hr. The light in bathroom wasn't turning on at all and had to walk downstairs and to front desk as there's no front desk log on the phones to just call to advise od this. To just have them change me to a different room! Price said $120 on the window yet I got charged $150... Didn't even bother asking the worker when I had to go downstairs to turn the key in for the 1 room to get access to the other room. Just all very frustrating. Gets 2 starts for the trying on customer service to make it right and the AC actually working in this heat wave.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 Michael M. 2 years ago on Google
    Worst.. I was at this place when I worked with YRC trucking. Drug dealing in the parking lot. I walk into the lobby and the lady behind the bullet proof class was interesting. Walking to the room/the hallways were cluttered with old mattresses. The room was gross……
    2 people found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 2/5 Rick S. 2 years ago on Google
    Old building and rooms. Warped floor, open outlets in the wall poor wiring. Wifi was extremely unreliable. Didn't feel real safe as when I first arrived to my room the door was open. The bed was so lopsided it would have been easy to roll out of it. This was a last minute need and I do not recommend for a long stay or families.
    2 people found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 THE T. 1 year ago on Google
    If I could give zero stars then I would. This place grotesque it had cobwebs in the bedroom and there was nasty dirt on the ceiling. The bed was also disgusting and extremely uncomfortable. The springs in the bed were broken and when I was lying down it felt like the springs were digging into my whole back and it was extremely painful! I asked ff
    2 people found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 2/5 Sharon H. 3 years ago on Google
    I really didn't have a choice but to stay here one night as many of the motels were booked. Initially I thought it wasn't so bad as the lobby was very clean and the woman who registered me was very polite. I had asked for a non smoking room on the first floor due to health reasons. Unfortunately all I could smell entering and exiting the hallway to and from the room was a strong smell of marijuana. The was no wifi and the cable was limited. I was informed after notifying the front desk that the cable wires are the old wires and not the fiber optic currently used by cable. This causes distortion on the upper channel. The room was clean and sanitized.
    2 people found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 5/5 Michelle T. 1 year ago on Google
    I've been coming to the Bayshore Inn for quite some time. The staff is so friendly. Mark and Maria are two of the people that keep me coming back. They always ask how am I doing and always say have a great day. It's a pleasure to stay at the Bayshore Inn.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 2/5 Deborah E. 2 years ago on Google
    I never stayed in that motel but from what I just read .no thank you I will find a better place .no way not me I like clean things good luck with the flush lol
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 Paul L. 1 year ago on Google
    Would be my last choice out of a hundred others just above a -10 travel lodge on Main St. No coffee maker, only two outlets in room and one used by microwave and refrigerator. Rooms and building have not been touched up, renovated or painted in decades. My flight was moved later in the day and asked for late checkout and wanted to charge one night's price for a few hours (flight was @ 6:30 pm so now at airport for over 5 hours). Sorry, but hospitality not in their accommodations.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 Jose R. 1 year ago on Google
    I've stayed here plenty of times for a couple of hours. Over night not to many. Went there at 3am for an overnight stay and was told $150. I've been going there since 2011. I can't understand how they can justify the price. Not much has changed. It still looks like a beat up place. Only difference is key cards to enter the room. Went to the Hilton in Ronkonkoma for $125. Beautiful big room that doesn't smell.
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 Rosio G. 1 year ago on Google
    Staff is really rude the lady tried to dismiss me after paying $350 for 2 nights because she didnt have proper training to look for my reservation. (she kept insisting in saying I did not pay for my room and I did not book it even after paying 2 week ago and having proof of it and showing it to her) Room are disgusting and uncomfrotable
    1 person found this review helpful πŸ‘

  • 1/5 T K. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 11 reviews
    This place needs to be shut down. It attracts the worst walks of life and is an eye sore to the neighborhood. Their rates are by the hour - that says enough.

  • 1/5 Victoria G. 3 months ago on Google β€’ 10 reviews New
    Horrible service they say five minutes for check out don’t even give u five minutes they come knocking on door every 30 seconds and lady stands there like a weirdo . Don’t recommend.

  • 3/5 Paulajean J. 7 months ago on Google β€’ 8 reviews
    Nothing fancy.Good for overnight if traveling and just need to sleep. Wouldn't recommend for longer than a night

  • 1/5 Tierra W. 1 year ago on Google
    The toilet was clogged on arrival, furniture is water stained and damage. One light doesn't work while another is cracked. As well the extra lock is broken off the door.

  • 5/5 Jason M. 2 years ago on Google
    Enjoyed myself.... Lol

  • 5/5 Suzanne M. 1 year ago on Google
    I liked it had plenty of money stayed there many nights

  • 4/5 E R. 1 year ago on Google
    Clean rooms,good prices,great service,nice and quiet.

  • 3/5 Malcolm K. 1 year ago on Google
    Decent Spot. I had a Jawn who used to have her man drop her off up the block at the apartments and we would come here to do the nasty. A hood inn. U get what I mean. Not bad though.

  • 1/5 Paul Road Carter w. 2 years ago on Google
    Rooms are very nasty and needs a whole lot of repairs

  • 4/5 Jerell C. 2 years ago on Google
    Good place could use a little renovating but other than that it's pretty decent

  • 1/5 Diane M. 2 years ago on Google
    Furniture and fixtures are all broken, even in the bathroom. Undersink there were discussing used things, I won't elaborate. Burn marks on everything, even the ice bucket. Horrible, horrible place. Cockroaches climbing up the walls. I sat up all night watching for bugs, worst night ever!!!

  • 2/5 D b. 2 years ago on Google
    No microwave and when we asked to get 1 or be moved,staff was very rude...door had no lock,looked like it was kicked the door in,price was way to much for such poor service

  • 4/5 N 1 year ago on Google β€’ 2 reviews
    Never judge a book it’s cover! The outside looks horrible and we almost left. We got a room for short stay and the room was surprisingly nice. It was clean and so was the bathroom. Heat worked well. Front desk person was fine and very nice. Parking was fine and discreet. Rates reasonable. If you are a looking to go somewhere to play for a few hours I would consider this place. I post this as I was looking at reviews myself before we went _ hope this helps.
    3 people found this review helpful πŸ‘


Call (631) 666-7275 Open on Google Maps

Trends



Last updated:

Similar places



Similar Hotels nearby

La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport image
1
La Quinta Inn & Suites by Wyndham Islip - MacArthur Airport
Hotel
Casual hotel with a fitness room & freebies like shuttle service, breakfast & WiFi.
$92/night
3.60 (1.1K reviews)
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport image
2
Hilton Garden Inn Islip/MacArthur Airport
Hotel
Relaxed hotel featuring a bright restaurant, plus a fitness room & an indoor pool.
4.00 (1K reviews)
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center image
3
Clarion Hotel & Conference Center
Hotel
Traditionally styled quarters, as well as dining, a gym & a seasonal outdoor pool.
2.80 (1K reviews)
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia image
4
Hampton Inn Long Island/Islandia
Hotel
Contemporary hotel with free hot breakfast & Wi-Fi, plus an exercise room & an indoor pool.
4.10 (893 reviews)
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport image
5
Rodeway Inn MacArthur Airport
Hotel
Straightforward airport hotel offering an exercise room, as well as complimentary breakfast & Wi-Fi.
$90/night
3.30 (494 reviews)
Last updated:
()