Fun time at mother's day Boozy brunch everything was great. Cassie our server was amazing

What a terrible experience at this huge restaurant/ bar. We came on Taco Tuesday which happens to be karaoke night as well. The food was not terrible, basic bar fare but the staff was inattentive at best and incompetent and rude at their worst. The temperature on the side of the bar where the music was so ridiculously freezing cold that some regulars were wearing winter coats. (That should have given us a clue when we first walked in) Someone mentioned to my wife that they sold Lily Sweatshirts and the waitress told her it was 20.00 and brought her one which she put on. It literally must have been like 45 degrees and windy so we rushed thru dinner and asked for the check. They charged her 30.00 and when we complained the girl lied and said she never said it was 20.00. No matter, we paid the bill and left never to return to this poor excuse for a restaurant!

Tonight was our first visit to Lily’s of Babylon. Our service was fantastic. We started with Alanna(?) and she was great. When her shift ended we were handed over to Mark , who was very good but not as good as Alanna. Our complaint is we could NOT taste any alcohol in our drinks at all. I was charged $13 per drink because I asked for the drink in a pint glass and therefore I was charged for a double shot. Sorry, no alcohol. I know what a double tastes like. My wife had two short drinks, then a pint and also couldn’t taste any alcohol. That is our only complaint. The music of the J Haus band was fantastic.

Best waitress ever!! Went for brunch. Had the bottomless Brunch. Amazing. The Bloody Mary's are to die for. Definitely going back

Amazing places just with amazingly delicious food.I want to say a special thank you to Kasadi, this is a bartender ,for her care and good mood.I will definitely come back to this place.

I love Lily's. If it's a rare Tuesday I don't have my son I come here for karaoke but it is a restaurant so I can also try bringing my son sometimes. The food is good. I don't drink alcohol so I can only rate the food and service but Lily's is very good for both of those.

Great service! The bartenders & waitresses are on top of everything. I came to Lily's to watch a band & this place didn't disappoint me. Bring a date or bring your friends. The dance floor is big & the crowd is fun. I had a great time. I highly recommend Lily's!

Ordered from Lily’s tonight and was quite disappointed. We’re from the area so we decided it was a nice night and we would walk down. We walked and picked up our order and got all the way back only to find that we were not given our entire order. We called back only to be told that we “left” the rest of our meal there, when it in FACT was not given to us. So, we walked back to retrieve the rest of our order. Once we get back to our house to finally sit down and enjoy our meal, the pretzel that we had ordered was so hard that we couldn’t even enjoy it and ended up having to toss it out any way. This was a first and a last.

Held a Baptism celebration here recently. It was excellent. The staff was terrific, food was great and it was an all around wonderful experience. I will be back. Thank you, Lily's!

Did you know "Half way to Saint Patrick's Day" is September 17th. Go to Lily Flanagan's on Sept 17 and get $5 taps and 17%off your bill! All while enjoying a nice meal, great wings, delish Bavarian Pretzels Octoberfest menu and with live music! Enjoy!

The place was awesome. The service, Food & atmosphere was fantastic. There is not 1 thing bad I can say about this place. The guest enjoyed and loved the room that we had for our party. If your looking for a great place Lily's is the place to go to. Also the price was fair.

Went for the first time on NYE. Great location. Place has charm, nicely decorated for the holidays. Late night buffet dinner was very good. Staff was friendly enough for a busy night. I didn’t see anyone cleaning. There were a lot of spilled drinks as expected and the floor was sticky and gross at one point. DJ was ok, he was playing good stuff but there wasn’t much of a countdown, just randomly started counting down and luckily I heard him so I was ready. I would go back for the actual restaurant experience too.

I have been here many times for drinks but finally decided to try it for dinner and it was a pleasant surprise! The menu has tons of choices, both Irish and American cuisine. Lots of appetizers, which is great for sharing with a big group. The drinks are always good too! We enjoyed a flatbread, steak tidbits, duck breast and dessert. It's a nice sized space with pleasant service!

Had a few meals from this place now. Food is always good. Busy at times and bustling, but service is great. I ordered a Caprese Chicken sandwich and ended up finding a Crispy Chicken sandwich when I got home. The manager got on the phone and made it right with an apology. I'll be back, the food and service is too good not to.

Food was amazing and the service was great... Nice atmosphere...Full plates and Irish classics are 1/2 price on a couple days during the week .. Great night... The short ribs are my fave.... Definitely going back

We came here for brunch and then again for dinner. The potato soup is my favorite. It's so good. The brunch was absolutely delicious. I got a broccoli and cheese omelette and it was huge! It was cooked very nicely; not overcooked or runny. Delicious. I come here at least once every time I visit the island. Great food and great service. The only reason I gave it 4/5 stars is because it gets very very loud. We had to shout across the table to hear one another. Other than that, it's a great place!

This was our first visit to Lily's and although the food was excellent our service was not. She seemed friendly enough with other tables but when she came to our table she barely looked at us, reached across my face to pick up dishes while taking to table next to us. I think she even sighed when we asked for dessert to go. Unfortunately we had to reflect this in our tip. We frequent the restaurants in this area a lot and we love tipping generously to show our appreciation of good friendly service. Not sure if we'll be back here. Maybe only if we get a different server.

Had my pandemic wedding reception here. We go back every once in a while for dinner. The only problem with going here is that all of the food is amazing, so it takes my wife forever to choose what she wants to eat.

Went to the Sunday Comedy Brunch. 100% will I recommend this event to all. The food was delicious, the comedians were great, and if you stick with the brunch cocktails (unlimited) it's $135 per couple which includes tax and tip. The event is 3 hours so it left us time to go downstairs and enjoy a few pints.

They are under construction, which was a slight issue. HOWEVER the food and service staff was very good. Im sure it will be beautiful when it's completed. Would definitely recommend it!!!

For the past few years Lily’s was my favorite place to go to for Sunday football! The crowd was great, and the football card was even more amazing. Now that they aren’t doing the football card they’re Sunday football deals just aren’t holding up to their card. I will not be going back every Sunday like I have done in the past.

Must have been bad night for Lily. Been there many times and July very good. Well, Sunday night, 6:00 very slow . Waitresses were huddled-and talking.they were interrupted by someone in charge, turned and apologized. The order was uneventful and have had it many times. The fish and chips was not edible …fish was probably sitting all day, fries were frozen and dried out ( wrinkled ) all laying on bits of water cress and shredded red cabbage. Inedible. Took it hand and through it out! The “chef” brought our dinner out carrying it almost over his head. Such a disappointing time after a wonder concert in Bay Shore. Service and food were terribly disappointing for a very expensive dinner. ( 1 drink each , no appetizers, no dessert!

How many times have I come to lilys to be greeted warmly and made to feel welcome. The staff is great. It doesnt just stop there. The food is fresh a d tasty. The new menu is out and i want to try everything .Football on Sundays is lots of fun with raffles also to win.

Held my sisters bridal shower here on 5/6/2023 in their room upstairs. The food was awesome, the service was incredible, the staff even helped out those who needed assistance with gifts. Nicole was great at helping us plan everything. It was the perfect party! I highly recommend having your next party/event here! I know my family will be keeping lily's in mind for the future!

I was very happy to return to what it was many moon ago, BARKERS. I was out for the block party n a friend said the food here is good..she was RIGHT. 3 of us had no complaints loved the mocktail selection which I did have, it was so good I had 2. I had to walk to the other side which brought back great memories at that bar from back in the day n nice to see no changes there. We so enjoyed ourselves we went back for dinner several days later..so glad my friend suggested to eat there..NOT DISAPPOINTED WITH ANYTHING..

It is always a pleasure to come to this place. The staff is very friendly, food is delicious and drinks are amazing! I brought my friends from the city to enjoy the boozy brunch and they all were surprised to visit this place. They have come another 3 times all the way from Manhattan to Lily's for dinner, boozy brunch, and lunch.

Lily's lives a double life. Happy hour until 9pm on Fridays when it caters to the older crowd, who are there to listen to less known local cover bands. Then by ten PM Friday, and later on Saturday, the 60 yo's escape and a much younger crowd replaces them ready to party. I've never stayed late enough to hear if the dated disco tunes evolve into house music, because, frankly, I can't tolerate the required spaghetti strapped midriff tops on a freezing night! This place is iconic with multiple traditional bars, a moderate sized dance floor, adequate sound system and a team of bouncers. However, drink prices are double that of nearby Farrell's. Pick your crowd and go.

We've been here before and the food is always good. This time we went here on a Saturday night. Didn't know they have a DJ and stop serving food early. Also a $10 cover charge wasn't in the plan. We stayed anyway and had a good time with friends regardless. Would recommend for a fun night out, just get here early if you want a meal.

Recently went to Lily's for Sunday football with a bunch of friends and Callie was the best server!

Great restaurant to relax and unwind, food was very good my Wife loved the goat cheese and fig flat bread. Staff was professional and courteous. It was a pleasure to eat there.

booked a party for a surprise birthday. The ladies that helped w the event were spot on, accommodating, and helpful. The food was great, as was the service. Everything went smoothly, and I am happy I chose Lilly’s.

Great Band playing tonight (Victom of Rock), playing great tunes and sounded great. $5 Heineken drafts...can't beat it...definitely going back.

Haven't gone to Lily's in some time. Living in the area it's one of the few places that upped their food and cocktail menu to please just about everyone in your family. The staff was both attentive and knowledgeable of what is in their menu. This time we had Cassie as our server. She was delightful IG @longisland_wine_dine

First time there food was good but the service was horrible. Seems like if you where not a regular customer you where not waited on in a timly order. My party came in with a reservation we where seated and we waited and waited for some one to take our drink order. Finally after 15 min. The waitress came over and took our drink order. About 15 min later the drinks arrived. All this time we did not get a menu. Finially some one came with menus. We ordered and it was another 20 to 25 min. For the food. Customers who came in after us left before we even got our food. Needless to say we will not go there again nice place but the service SUCKS.

I stopped in with my wife for a burger, they are delicious! Hand made, nice size, juicy, flavorful. Friday night the live bands are great. Awesome staff,great place to go for a bite/drink!