Since new ownership our last three visit the quality of food has gone down. Cost have gone up. The inviting management is gone. Amazing how in a short time someone could make a great establishment poor. Three strikes your out. Time to fine a new locations. Joe

Its a traditional Greek Diner in Strong Island..if I have to say more then this is not the place for you.. Owners are warm and gracious. Servers are always on the A game and whatever your comfort food zone is you will find it.

Great old time diner. Large portions of Great food at a reasonable price.

They treat you like family. We've been going for years and they kind of know us there. Great food, really great coffee and just a super nice staff.

The food portion was incredibly large for us. Fair price. But the waiter didn’t give me the water throughout the time even after two reminders.

This diner was sold and is under new ownership. If you are a regular there like we were, you will definitly notice the spiral down in the food. It is very sad to see. The former owners really cared about their diner, their food and their customers experiences. These owners only care about how much money they can make and how they can push out cheap food pre-bought food at high prices. Other reviews posted within the last few months can only be from people being paid to give good reviews and push up their overall online rating. They are not honest reviews, so be aware of this. Examples of clear changes that regular customers will see... 1) coleslaw used to be homemade...Now it is the restaurant depot type stuff. 2) burger buns are consistently stale 3) spinach pie is no longer homemade and taste like lots of fillers have been added. Very very bad in comparison to how it used to be. 5) Take out no longer consistently provides napkins or utensils or even asks customers if they want it. 6) bacon is like rubber. I can go on, but I will stop here. I hope if the current owners read this, they will think about this and change it back to the way the restaurant was run for years. If you don't... no matter how many people you pay to give you good reviews, in a year or 2, you will close due to everyone in the neighborhood seeing what has been done to the food.

It's not the same since Tony left. Most of the waiters/waitresses are still very nice and do a good job, but the quality of the food has tanked. They're changing a lot of recipes, food isn't always cooked right... It's not worth it to be honest. End of an era.

First time dining here and it was great!! Large portions worth the price! Lots of leftovers to take. The soups & deserts not pictured here were satisfying as well!! Friendly staff

We love this diner. Delicious food, warm cozy and clean atmosphere, great service reasonably priced, and for the frequent patrons, a free glass of wine with every complete dinner. An awesome new owner named Steve, is always there to greet and seat customers and if your so inclined, make you a mean cocktail too. We dine here at least once a week and never are we disappointed.

I love this diner. It’s my go-to for good food, huge portions, great prices and an amazing staff. We love the stuffed mushrooms, and they make great cocktails. For dessert the bread pudding is simply divine!

Great little local diner! Staff was very nice and food came quick. Good portion and great for price!

This review is basically about the amazing server we had. We were in an extremely big group (after a funeral) and our server who I’m so sorry I don’t recall her name was outstanding. The whole staff was so quick and so friendly. The food is good too, solid diner food. The parking lot gets full quickly so prepare ahead or go in groups. But this staff is superb and can’t be said enough.

Looks like an older diner, that's been there for yrs. The restaurant was clean and had an old fashion vibe. The waitress was friendly and the food was amazing. Oh and they put a macaroni salad on the table for you to enjoy while waiting for your food. It was so delicious. Not sure what was on the pasta but it was so good. The burgers were huge and the sweet potato fries were also like a double portion in other dinners. Then the dessert was rice pudding, the waitress said that everyone raves about it. Well they were right, it was so creamy.. delish!!! Prices were very reasonable. The only challenging part is the parking lot. It's not very big. But it is so worth a visit. Everything was A++++++

Fantastic food! Great prices! Awesome Service! This diner is my favorite place when I'm extra hungry. Their portions are very generous.

Horrible diner! Ordered a cesar sald and a house salad. both with chicken and got two house salads. the side dressing was 4 cups of mayo. how hard is it to make 2 salads to go. never ordering from there again.

Its the usual diner. Been around for a long time. Good food and service. Family atmosphere.

The atmosphere is so pleasant and the staff is extremely well prepared. The bus boy is in tune to the customers. Love the owners. We go there all different times and the service has always been to byp notch.

So happy we found this diner! Portions are huge! Breakfast was amazing. Food is delicious. There was plenty of food left for another breakfast at home. Very clean from dining room to bathrooms. Wait staff and other employees were all courteous and helped us navigate the huge menu. Great coffee. Highly recommend Infinity Diner. Free parking.

Absolutely love this diner the owner Tony and his sons greet you and make you feel like family. One day my mom was to tired from chemotherapy to go inside and Tony came out to the car to say hello to her and dad.. ill never forget that.. The Food is A1 with amazing workers and extremely clean environment. Always a wonderful experience.

Disappointed I am even leaving this review but maybe the new owners will read this and take charge. I've been coming here for a while and always loved it, but since the new ownership the food has drastically gone downhill --- I understand this is a diner but the quality is below average for an above average price. No utensils given with take out anymore, no crackers for soup. The chicken I ordered was practically inedible and the greek salad dressing is a horror for a diner that serves gyros and salads, please change this if you expect customers to come back.

I did not realize that it is a new owner but the service is as great. Always a pleasant visit. We always enjoy the food. The price is also great.

The Salmon was delicious, the veggies was seasoned just right, our waitress was very personalable and had excellent customer service skills. The music, was right on time. I also enjoyed the fact that is was family oriented.

Great family experience. The host was amazing and attentive to my little ones and gave my family a great experience. The atmosphere is friendly and mellow, classic diner feel with the music and sitting. Food was spot on, and the prices are great. Would recommend it to anyone. Will be my go-to spot for a quick family sit and eat.

No GF options. The service and serving size were good. The music got really annoying. It was a 1978-1982 hair band concert the entire time...

I ordered turkey sausage, scrambled eggs and whole wheat toast with butter. The eggs were a little runny and the bread was not toasted. The bread was very dry with butter just slapped on it. I would not recommend this establishment at all. If I could they would not have received a star at all

City Slam is lots of food for $. Lovely French toast. My boys love the milkshake.

The Infinity Diner is hands down the best diner around. The food and drinks are always fresh and delicious. It feels like a family restaurant. The owners and staff are the nicest people.

Found this place because it was close to the funeral for a friend's mother. Turned out to be fabulous? Great service, great food and a classic diner experience that was enjoyed by all 12 of us.

good food GREAT SERVICE THANK YOU SPRIO

Was excited to go here since it’s close to my house and it was 4.5 stars but I was very disappointed. Service was not great. We ordered shrimp scampi and i guess they forgot the scampi. The penne tasted like it was literally just boiled. The shrimp were not great. Grant it, it was shrimp scampi from a diner but the nerve to charge $25 for boiled penne and 5 shrimp is ridiculous. Our server had no intention in sorting the problem out. My burger was okay. Fries are a simple side yet that was disappointing as well. Will be sticking to other Diners around.

It's a diner. Can a diner really be 4 stars? There was nothing wrong at all. Serviceable burger, onion rings. It's better than fast food but it's pretty close conceptually.

Great Diner that's owned by a really nice family and they have a large variety of delicious food to choose from.

Great staff so friendly - Food is great. I would rather go here than some fancy restaurants. Everything cooked to order. Special requests taken. We have been here at least 100 times and have never been disappointed!

Everything I return to long Island I get food from here. I love there burgers 🍔 😋. This time I went for breakfast and no complaints . The portions were great more than enough to fill you up.

Ooo delicious

Great everything.service above and beyond.fast for busy sunday.personable.better than any new Jersey diner.highly recommended.

We came after a funeral so we were pretty sad. The great food, accommodations and service was uplifting. Everything was excellent. A table favorite was the blueberry pancakes which were so delicious. The blueberries were well cooked into the pancakes, not just thrown on top. My brother who moved out of state years ago saw a Newsday and got nostalgic. He asked it there were any for sale and the owner just gifted it to him. That was a nice touch.

Fantastic service, the food came out insanely quick for 9 in the morning and the picture speaks for itself. I left the place very content

Bypass that New York City commercial food and come here and be treated extremely kindly by the amazing team here. They are kind, fast and the food is a delight. If you are extremely hungry and want good food try this spot and get the lumberjack special.

Great food, great service and great owner. They are so nice and always take care of the kids!!!

As a Canadian who pays 15$+ a pack of bacon back home , That was one of the best and biggest breakfast i ever had for the price . The waitress gave a A++ service , This is what a real country looks like. God bless America 🇺🇸