I’m not sure if I’ve experienced worst tasting “homemade” food. Now, to be the fair, their bread was fantastic, but our pizza was just topped with poor, bad tasting, not fresh ingredients. The pasta was rubbery, the meats couldn’t have been any drier even with the canned (flavorless) sauce poured all over it. If this is the type of dining experience you enjoy then you may also get a show outside from the owners homeless buddies who have been known in the past to hang around outside and expose themselves as the owner clearly takes no accountability for the actions that they allow to happen on their own premises. Highly recommend you can literally anywhere else, honestly, you can get almost the exact same pizza next door with no wait and 1/5 of the cost

Order here if you want to waste money on sht pizza. They can’t cut pizza correctly. They don’t even know what triangles are. Any pasta dish are only for display. Bland as hell. For some reason pizza box was wet so if you do order, just walk into their restaurant. Maybe they’ll give better treatment compared to their delivery.

The best Italian restaurant in Long Island. The owner, Andy is so welcoming and joyful. He made sure our large party had a 10/10 experience. There are not many places as authentic as 3 brothers cafe. The BEST service and staff I’ve come across. The pizza, pasta, and entrees, both regular menu and vegan menu were incredible. The atmosphere felt like we were in Italy. This place is a GEM 💎 and a MUST visit if you are in town. Thanks again Andy, you’re the best! we’ll be back soon! 🇮🇹🍕🍝

Came here with some friends with a combination of dietary restrictions and having a fantastic dinner was super easy! They were able to enjoy gluten free and vegan food that was delicious from appetizers and salads to our main entrees. I ordered the vegan meatball parmigiana sub which was not only Incredibly delicious but so huge I had to take half home. Definitely going to be coming back!

Outsider opinion: My favorite NY pizza. This is mostly based on the crust flavor and texture 10/10 Also we have a celiac. She has eaten here several times with no problem 👍 They have vegan options but I haven’t touched em.

Nice place for vegan pizza in Long Island. Vegan desserts available too. Good taste.

Love their vegan food. like the taste of their vegan pasta sauce and really appreciate their customer servise.

A classic Italian joint serving a full menu of both regular and vegan options. The staff were kind, the food came out hot and quick, and the whole place was very clean! Definitely worth the drive if you don't live nearby. Photos below of the vegan buffalo wings, vegan mozzarella sticks, vegan crab cakes, and their regular and vegan pizza offerings!

I was a big fan of the apparently now closed (?) Copiague location but recently moved to the Farmingdale area. Was very pleased when I found this location had the exact same menu, as the oyster mushroom “calamari” is one of my favorites. We also got a grandma square pie, the smaller size is a good size for 2 people that just inhaled a plate of fried mushrooms to have leftovers lol! Everything tasted great as expected, and the waitress we had was very sweet. Hoping to come back soon for more great vegan Italian food !! This location is just a little cramped compared to what I was used to with the other location, I think there are tables impeding exit/entrance/takeout counter, which may make it harder for someone with limited mobility.

Got some take out, the vegan pizza was awesome! Loved the 'pepperoni' was very tasty. The ceasar salad and chocolate cake were classic and delicious. So happy they have vegan options 😃

Rip off. Ordered a pizza and Vegan penne ala vodka due to gluten and dairy allergies we had to call since there were no gluten free options on the menu online. After driving 35 minutes out to the restaurant I was told I owed $52 for 1 pizza and 1 Vegan penne order. I was told if I ordered online it would have been $15 less. But there were no gluten free options online to choose…the counter person was no help and refused to match the online price even when I told her they didn’t have gluten free options online - so calling was the only way to order. She could care less. I wanted to brag about this place but seems like they don’t care about the customers anyway.

I have been here so many times and it’s always great until today! Picked up my tofu scramble and there was barely any in there and I ordered tempeh bacon. Now there is always a good amount of the tempeh bacon in it and today there was like 1 piece mixed in. I called up and was pretty much told too bad and that it was mixed in the scramble. The veggies in it were huge slices like someone just threw it together. Won’t be going here again. Terrible customer service. The waitress is AMAZING. Always on her game and the pizza guy is terrific. I don’t know if that was the manager but he was terrible! What a disappointment!!!

I prefer the vegan menu. I had 'meatball parm' and 'buffalo chicken' and both were delicious!

I loved that there was a vegan & a non vegan menu, as a vegetarian I tried the vegan menu & everything was amazing, I loved this place I will def go back, the calzone was HUGE def not for one person. The Buffalo "wings" were surprisingly pretty real even had a "bone" which was a mini dowel, lovely experience. The server was super nice & attentive as well.

I ordered an delivery for cheese pizza. I always love jalapeños on my pizza ..but on Uber eats when i was ordering it was not showing jalapenos option ..when while ordering i wrote to put jalapenos on pizza if possible. And they did it. It was yummyy😋😋. Thanks to the person who did that.

This is my first time eating here. I ordered two slices of Vegan pizza with toppings. Each slice was six dollars which I think is quite expensive. The pizza tasted okay but it did not seem to be too fresh. The pizza was heated up but it was still cold - which is fine if it was not $6.00 per slice. The garlic knots were 3 for $2.00, which is very expensive as well. This is good to have as an option but not a first choice.

This was by far this best vegan pizza they have me for me to date!!! I gave specific instructions not to burn the crust and they executed that perfectly. The crust was nice and soft and chewy! They put plenty of toppings on the pie as well as enough sauce and cheese!

Been coming here on occasion for years. Never disappointed by the food and huge array of vegan meals and desserts. Perfect spot for a casual outing.

Boy, have I missed New York pizza I now reside in the south, you know below the Mason Dixie line. Pizza isn’t the same down here as it is back home. Of course when I’m home I always try to get a slice. However, for the last 4 years I’ve been disappointed with the pizza, it’s not like what it used to be. On a whim I ordered from Three Brothers Pizza Café and I was NOT disappointed. Everything from the Seafood pasta ,Bianca and Margherita pizza was Aaaaah-mazing!!!!! Now when I come back home this is the only Italiano spot that I will be eating at. You could taste the freshness in every single bite and hunny it was DELISH!!!!! They absolutely blew my mind.

I 've been coming here for past 4 years mainly for the vegan pizza and it can be very hit and miss. I've had almost every specialty pizza on their menu and the way they cook it can be great one day and mediocre the next. I don't know if they have different cooks on different days but it is what it is. The Pizza when made on a good day is excellent though. Highly recommend the Works and the buffalo seitan. The place is clean and there's a parking lot but it's quite small.

Half pizza place/half cute restaurant, they always have the nicest waitresses, cute for parties and dates. Biggest vegan menu I've ever seen, literally every meat option has a vegan option that's just as good. One of the most friendly restaurants on the island

The lettuce in my salads were browning and gross. The croutons were mostly burnt, so I would definitely not order a salad from here. An employee (female) was outside not even 3 feet from the door smoking a cigarette. I had to walk past her with my BABY on my hip which is completely unacceptable, unprofessional and disgusting. I’ve been a smoker before and worked at a pizza place, I would never in my life smoke a cigarette anywhere near my work place. Let alone when a customer is walking into your establishment with a baby. And my boss’ never would stand for that either. The woman behind the counter was lovely and kind but I’m not sure that’s enough for me to ever come back here.

I worked at this place and refused to keep going with their horrible habits of using the cheapes of product chicken cheapes money can buy oil from restaurants Depot nothing is healthy at this place theirs pizza chease is the lowest quality food is prepare weeks in advance not fresh daily, the vegan menu can’t be vegan i they used the same oil where seafood and chicken is fried .their cooking back ground are super unhealthy I am sorry for peole that go here thinking they are eating a healthy meal

Irrespective of some rather judgmental and berating alleged customers of this finest establishment, Andy the owner is not only a hardworking and sole proprietor immigrant the restaurants under his guidance are some of the finest vegan offerings on Long Island. Please do not be dissuaded by the vitro and condescending rhetoric that unfortunately people such as the proprietors of three brothers pizza cafe indoor on a daily basis. Their food service ends ambiance are worth enjoying and I happen to live in Forest Hills which even to the closest location in lynbrook is a good 40-minute drive but justified and well worth it. Thank you Andy and look forward to seeing you always.

This is a top notch spot for great Italian food in Farmingdale. They are always very accommodating and the food is always delicious whether it’s their entrees or pizza. The staff is very friendly. Also have many vegan options. Highly recommend!!

I met the owner of this fine establishment Andy Astafa and he's an outstanding individual and a great father. He's a beacon in the local community and his restaurant is out of this world. Keep up the hard work Andy!!! The most based individual on earth.

I’m allergic to dairy so 3 Brother’s pizza 🍕 is the best place for me I always get large pie of penne allá vodka and 1/2 plain. Is near to my house so is very convenient to go here love the staff and the cook is the man at making pizza’s!!!

Great food, great service ! This restaurant is perfect as I am a vegan and my husband is not. Both menus are fantastic

My favorite pizzeria, they use a ton of delicious cheese, lots of toppings if you order them, both the selection and quantity they give. Their dishes are good too, multiple sauces (Tito's vodka owns). Enjoy the many vegan options, or take your vegan friends to a place where they have more than one option to choose from.

It was a great experience as always The Hospitality is great !! the food is Delicious

They still serve daiya cheese which always makes me question a restaurants knowledge of good vegan cooking. They now have something called mooliss for their mozzarella and it was okay. Melted nice. The Buffalo vegan slice didn't have very much flavor, but it wasn't bad.. just not really good. It was 6/10 stars. The mooliss Sicilian was fluffy, and decent. Wasn't bad but had a slight dishwater flavor. I don't know how to describe it. Way better than their daiya slices I had tried a while ago. In my opinion the pizza was pretty overpriced, not many options and not good enough for a $7 slice. The garlic knots were good, but the marinara tasted like a canned sauce. I'd try other things from them, maybe just not the pizza again. Not worth it. The service was okay also, the men that worked there today were polite. I'd suggest reading reviews from lowest to highest before trying, very informative. I just read they cook meat in the same oil as the vegan things?? I hope not. Was going to try brunch but might skip after the reviews.

We had a group of 6 people that ate dinner at this location. The service was great and the food was outstanding. From pizza to seafood pasta, everyone enjoyed the food.

I like this place.! Female sever was awesome. Food was great! I had seafood marinara excellent ! Calzones great, orechietta,broccoliraab and sausage dish was very good but being a non-veggetarian I had to accept the replacement sausage for what it was. I will go there often in the future. They do most everything well

Out of all places I thought NY had to have vegan pizza. This place did not disappoint. They have a “normal” menu and a vegan menu. It was one of the best dairy free pizzas that I’ve ever had. We will be back.

There was an uber eats promotion for buy 1 get 1 free Chicken parm dish so I tried it out not expecting much. It was actually really good, especially for delivery. Chicken parm was delivered hot and crispy and not soggy like I would expect from delivery. Will definitely order again.

This place is a treasure! I have developed lactose intolerance and there's nothing I miss more than NY pizza...this place delivers! Everything we had was amazing, the specialty slices are to die for.

Some of the best vegan food on Long Island I had their Buffalo and BBQ “chicken” pizzas, as well as a Buffalo “chicken” hero All out of this world! Highly recommend.

We ordered an almost $100 order for their Moo-Less products in January. Only received a small part of the order and I have been trying to call, email and contact to either receive a partial refund or the rest of the pizzas (frozen) we ordered. I’m extremely disappointed. I wanted to support a local small business but I will never be ordering from here again, nor will I recommend it to the vegan community. I will be letting everyone in the vegan community know that this is a scam. UPDATE: finally got in touch and they were super nice and accomodating. They resent the pizzas and we’re apologetic.

Pizza’s great. Coffee’s great. Wasn’t a huge fan of the vegan bacon that came with the tofu scramble but overall I enjoyed my food. Parking is also pretty tight.

It was an okay place to eat, nothing spectacular. I went with a couple of people and the woman at the front didn't seem at all interested in helping us, and it felt like it was an issue for us to order. We ordered 2 regular and one vegan slice and they came out lukewarm at best. It tasted okay, but it's nothing I'll come back for. If you're looking for a simple slice, I'd stop in here but otherwise I'd stay away, there are many great places for pizza on the island and this isn't one of them. Be aware the dining area is pretty small!

Love going here because I can get vegan food and my husband can get his cheese pizza. So many vegan options that are all so good!

I USED to love this place! Their food has changed over the years! The garlic knots are neither garlicky nor are they knots! They also are dry! No oil! I don't know what happened to them. The vegan Eggplant Parm is different every time I oder it. For the most part the eggplant tasted good but the vegan cheese on top was disgusting! I've never seen vegan cheese that puffed up the way that this did - it almost looked like mashed potatoes on top of eggplant. (Like a shepherd's pie) The red sauce is still delicious, thank goodness! It's just disappointing that there is zero consistency. Been coming here for YEARS.... now not as excited as I used to be. Now when I go.. I say to myself... please let this meal be good instead of knowing I'm about to have a delicious meal.

My favorite hideaway 3 year relationship love the vegan options

Being vegan sometimes can really limit your options this place is great