Fine dinning, good service, not rushed, Nice presentation, Food was Hot and delicious as ordered. We will be dropping in again but not the next day why because the portions are able to share almost like family style type restaurants keep the fire burning chefs job done well also front of house ran flawless the ownership should be proud of them all.

Great tasty food! The food portions are huge!!! Everyone takes a bag to go! So its ideal that you order 1 main course for 2 people will be more than enough! Side salad is a full plate so its a big serving of food here. For the price they charge definitely worth it. The staff is welcoming and pleasant. The waiter was super nice and knew his menu and knew how to make a guest fulfilled and was able to help me choose what i want and play around with menu) cozy place. Good for a date and definitely a family go to spot!

(Updated) This place just deserves a 5 star) Thanks mamas for the Comfort foods and Thanks for doing what you do and making me dam happy when i eat your food! The menu is the best thing i have ever seen in my life. Easily my favorite Italian place on Long Island and as long as i live and breathe on this Island i will always get it! lol. Last time ill update because its a 5 Star hands Down.

Whoever gives Mama’s less than five stars is fooling themselves. The food was outstanding and the menu was plentiful. The meat was perfect, the pizza was tasty, and a special shout-out to our server, Johnny B, for his pleasant demeanor and abundant patience.

Unbelievable chicken specials, every Thursday. You will not be disappointed with a menu that never ends. So many choices all so delish! Weather "special nights" or another day Mama's has a dish to please all. Tremendous portions, always hot, very efficient service. The hostess (Melinda) goes above and beyond to keep everyone happy... ask for Kim another example of superb service! NOTE pic's are from meals we already started eating, both great selections!

So before arriving at mamas, we stopped by another Italian restaurant and we’re turned off by all of the staff looking miserable to be there and decided to go to mamas instead. The manager and waitress at the host stand were delightful and sat us right away. Jordan our server was the best person we could have ever gotten for our first experience. He was so honest and upfront. He had such charisma that made us just smile, he gave us great suggestions and we left happy and full. Turned our night around!

Very good lobster ravioli. Drinks are a little expensive but when are they aren't on long island? The guy who helped us was really helpful and nice. We stayed for an hour due to closing.

Went for a delicious lunch, the portions where dinner size, the broccoli 🥦 cooked with garlic to perfection, firm but tender so tasty! The seafood Fradiablo amazing👏 so fresh, tasty with the garlic and slightly spicy sauce. The gluten free pasta with marinara sauce, cooked to perfection🥰 The staff and service so welcoming, friendly, fast and efficient! What a gem and joy to eat there specially on a stormy gloomy day!

My friends and I went to Mama's tonight for my friends 30th birthday. First and foremost, our server, Christine was awesome. One of the best servers I've had there. I ordered the Chicken Guissepe over pappardelle pasta. I got it without shrimp, but it was still a huge portion of chicken The pink pesto cream sauce was delicious. My friends ordered the Chicken Bellagio and the Ribeye Surf and Turf. The chicken bellagio was panko breaded chicken over a pesto spaghetti topped with prosciutto and arugula. The surf and turf came with a perfectly cooked Ribeye steak, stuffed breaded shrimp and mashed potatos. I didn't have any, but it looked divine and my friend said it was unreal. We finished with a chocolate lava cake for my friends birthday. It was warm, chocolaty and gooey. The ice cream and whipped cream went perfectly with the cake. Overall, it was a great experience and I will return as I usually do.

I have to say, I was expecting more. The food was great. The portions are tremendous. The service, meh. Even though the lady was nice, she didn't refill our drinks. Didn't ask if we wanted dessert before giving us the check. I know it was busy but we felt rushed. The place is super crowded and you will have to wait on a Saturday. Honestly, you can go anywhere for this level of Italian food.

Excellent from beginning to end. Waitress was extremely pleasant - food was incredible. The size of the portion I had never experienced before except if it was a family style place. And the food/sauce was incredibly tasty and cooked to perfection. I also was extremely happy that I didn’t have to make a choice between having a salad or pasta since the entree comes with both - yea- love it! They took care of boxing our leftovers right at our table. Everyone there was extremely pleasant - We live a bit away from the restaurant but you can bet we’ll be going there whenever we can since this now became our #1 Italian Restaurant.

Food was good, ..... But why in the world would you serve or send a salad looking like this for someone to eat? ¿REALLY? I called and asked to speak with the manager/owner, was told she was busy, left my number and name to have them call me back and have not heard back from them! DISGUSTING!!

Fantastic Italian food. Super large portions and nice wait staff. Pic shows eggplant Parmigiano with a side of spaghetti and house salad. Still eating the leftovers 😋

I love this restaurant. Everything was delicious, from their old fashioned to the lobster stuffed mushrooms which we devoured before taking pictures lol. The short ribs with mashed potatoes was delightful and the Tartufo that we had for dessert was scrumptious. The service was top-notch and will be returning several times to explore the extensive menu.

I love Mama's for their specialty pies! The shrimp pesto pizza is my personal favorite, but we also like getting their chicken arugula and chicken marsala deep dish pizzas. They're definitely on the pricier side, but worth it as a treat every now and then. (4 stars because we dined-in once before and weren't impressed by the pasta and risotto we got. We've decided to stick to their take-out pie options instead.)

Best pasta to eat at with their pasta night specials. They give you a salad, huge plate of pasta that you can have for lunch the next day, fresh garlic knots, and cheesecake with coffee or tea. Their pizza is great too, I recommend their sweet chicken chili slice. Me and my wife come here every year. Can't go wrong with Mama's.

What a great place to sit down and have dinner. Definitely make a reservation even on a monday night it was crowded. They have pasta and chicken specials during different days of the week. The garlic Knotts are amazing. If you celebrate a birthday here and want to bring your own dessert there is a fee for bringing your own dessert. When I emailed a question about this they got back to me very quickly. The staff is friendly and the environment is comfortable and clean. I also recommend their delicious meatballs.

I love the food and everything! So good!!! Except, when it is summer and the air is broke (like today) so hot! People where complaining. And we asked why it was so hot and they said because people where coming in and out. Yeah, when there are fans on and the inside feels like the outside except the sun beating on you. Like I said, food amazing! But I gave this 4 stars due to the air broken. Not cool. I’m not saying it is a bad restaurant but they really need to fix there air.

Had food catered for Mother’s Day. It was absolutely spectacular. We had about 10 half trays of food and each one was perfect. They skimped on nothing. It was Mother’s Day and they were incredibly busy and everything was perfect. Thank you very much. We are looking forward to next year.

Have been here before and always enjoyed the food and dessert. This time not so much. The waiter Gregg was nice and a great server. He went over the specials and even though I was going to get chicken parmigiana I decided the strip steak special sounded good. My husband got veal parmigiana. His food came out barely warm and he was disappointed in the taste. My steak was not a strip steak it was a cheap club steak with a ton of fat on it. Called over the waiter and asked him what happened to the strip steak. He said it was. I called over the manager and asked for chicken parmigiana. The chicken parmigiana came out and I was extremely disappointed. This was not what I was used to getting. It did not taste like it usually did and I have had it many times here. The chicken was frozen chicken cheap frozen chicken they threw in a fryer and than baked, threw cheap sauce on it mozzarella and called it homemade chicken parmigiana for 27.00. Dessert. Coffee came out barely hot and old. Was definitely sitting there for awhile. And the waiter knew it a good waiter should have fixed this. The lava cake and cheese cake were old. Very disappointed. Found out there are new owners. New owners who have ruined this restaurant. Quality and consistency are key to have a successful business. Passing off cheap quality food for for top quality is just wrong!!

Mamas is a great place. Always great service. Food is amazing. Great specials at great prices. One of my favorite restaurants.

Clearly a popular local place. Food was fabulous and plentiful. Outrageous portions for the price. You can't leave the table without your take home containers.

Had a really bad experience today. Ordered a grandma pie from mamas on a Saturday around 6PM. In the past, I’ve had various dishes from mamas plenty of times and they’ve been pretty consistently good, but this was something different entirely. I’m not sure if I got pranked or if there was an honest to god mistake in the kitchen (I’d like to give the benefit of the doubt) but this is the saltiest pizza I’ve ever tried. I could barely get through two slices before throwing out the entire pie. And I don’t mean salty like it could be a preference thing. I mean salty like I had to stop and grab other salty things around my kitchen to taste and make sure there wasn’t something medically wrong with me. I wanted to call and ask if it’s possible a mistake had been made in the kitchen. After all, I’m sure the Saturday dinner rush is a busy time, but ultimately I feel like I shouldn’t have to call. Food delivery apps exist for a reason. To avoid interaction. I shouldn’t have to try to call and work towards a resolution because this should never have been a problem in the first place. Anyway, I hope this is a severely isolated incident and nobody else has to experience it.

Food was delicious and large portions. Fast service and excellent staff. I highly recommend this restaurant.

First time at Mamas visiting from North Carolina. Honestly the place blew my mind. I have genuinely never seen pizza like this and everything looked delicious. We ended up dining in for dinner and portions are just as massive as the slices. Everything delicious. I had the lobster ravioli and my friend got a Veal Chop (I think special so not everyday item?) which looked insane.

Mama's was AMAZING! The food was incredible! Really nice atmosphere, and great staff! I'll definitely be going back!