It's amazing how popular this OFIC as they called themselves are. We got there after 8 pm and there was a line to get in the store to order. It's understandable because inside the store is very small. The store is not setup for indoor dining and not sure if they deliver or take online orders. Why would they, It's perishable merchandise subjected to melting very fast regardless of dryice technology. This store can be seen from a vehicle in normal traffic and has parking and wheelchair-accessible entrance. They sell ice-cream; need I say more -- many assortments of flavors and t-shirts and water and cakes.

The ice cream is phenomenal!! I’ve been coming here for years and just can’t get enough! And it’s all made fresh in store! The service is always fast & friendly! & all of the workers there are super super nice!! My favorite flavor is their chocolate Oreo with whip and a cherry. Definitely stop by if you’re in the area :)

This was my first time after passing this place for 10 years. The price is high like every where else right now. Did not like the sour sop it was blah. Loved the grapenut. It was a little too sweet for me. So this has a be a once in awhile treat instead of a weekly one.

Discovering this charming ice cream parlor felt like stumbling upon a countryside gem. They offer an impressive variety of flavors, and the staff is wonderfully friendly. What a delightful find! 🍦🏡😄

My friend and I stopped here on the way home from a baby shower, and wow! What a delicious stop ! The ice cream was light, refreshing and what seemed to be churned to profession. The woman who waited on us was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable about the flavors !

Incredible ice cream and friendly staff, awesome soft serve and has been around for over fifty years. Definitely would come again!

I can't believe I've been driving past this place for the last 6 years without stopping for ice cream. If you like ice cream (the real one), then this should be on your todo list for the summer. They also serve shaved ice if you're into that.

Friendly staff, clean place, and delicious ice cream that will leave you wanting more. Honestly, it's my favorite place to buy ice cream.

Delicious! I had the card ice cream, hot fudge sundae style, and it reminded me of Stewart's Ice Cream (which is the best in the Northeast). Now I don't have to wait until I go upstate to have amazingly delish ice cream!

Best ice cream place! Very friendly customer service, feels very welcoming as soon as you walk in. The place is nice and clean. There are so many flavors to choose from. The ice cream is always fresh and delicious. Way better than all of the rest!! A++++

I am almost 50 & I’ll always remember my grandfather bringing us here in the back of his pick up truck or my dad would bring home sundaes on his way home from work. Years later, my friends and I would ride our bikes to get a cool treat. Pregnancy cravings with both of my children and a sweet treat with them on a hot summer night when they were older. I now live in North Carolina and wish so badly I could take a quick drive over to Old Fashioned Ice cream. Was sitting here thinking about this place and saw it survived the pandemic & all the businesses closing. So happy to see you guys are still there! I hope I can come home and visit soon. It’s been over 5 years. My longest break ever from the best ice cream!

All home made all the time. This place is incredible. Staff always issues service with a smile. They got flavors that I have never tasted before. They even have Strawberry ice cream cakes y'all. Worth the wait, travel, and price. You won't be disappointed.

I'm so glad I've discovered this place. The ice cream is a delicious. Customer service is also great.

I have been going to this place for YEARRRSSS. I always order a hard ice cream chocolate shake with no syrup. I love their ice cream, normally all the people who work there are great. Two weeks ago I ordered a chocolate shake and it literally was filled 60% with ice cream and then another 20% with whip cream. I went with my fiancé and showed him when we went to the car and it was so upsetting. It was the first time so I didn’t care. Happened again another night. Then I gave them the benefit of the doubt. Went to get it again today 2/17 around 8:45pm. The girl I had was new. I told her what I wanted and very nicely I said… “last time whoever did my shake did not fill it good and it was halfway filled. Can you please make sure it’s decently filled?” She is making my shake and I’m LITERALLY watching. She asks another girl who I guess was in charge. The other girl started shaking her head nonstop and looking back at me. The girl mixes the chocolate ice cream and IN FRONT OF ME she laughs and adds a s**tload of milk and closes the cup. DIDNT EVEN MIX IT. I was trying so hard not to say anything and flip out. I went to my car and opened the lid and she literally filled it up SO much with milk at the top that I tilted it and milk was POURING out. I had to go home and mix it myself. I didn’t expect it to be full…. I expected it to be decently filled for paying $6.75 for a shake. I do not think a customer should be treated like that by a fricken child. It was beyond rude and unprofessional. I go almost twice a week or more here with my fiance. I’ll save myself the calories and stop going there that’s fine by me. Not worth the $6.75 if I get treated like that for having an issue. Wish I took photos.

This place is one of the friendliest, cleanest and greatest ice cream shops around. Love love love it. (So do the kids)

A great local ice cream shop. It has a good selection of flavors and rotating limited time flavors which are always delicious . The service is always friendly and quick and prices are reasonable. Definitely recommend it.

Wow! My chocolate shake was amazing! Thick and nice chocolate flavor. Pistachio saucers were great too!

Excellent staff! And the ice cream of course is delicious. They have every kind of ice cream you could possibly imagine. Five stars

Always worth the trip from queens. The dole whip and Malibu rum soft serve twist was super yummy. And Joe loved his Cookie Monster and central perk scoops

Great little local ice cream shop! We stopped in on an unseasonably hot October day to get cones. Rainbow sherbet and chocolate chocolate chip both hit the spot. Good value for the cones and the ice cream was good. One thing I wish they had would be tables or benches.

Best ice cream on Long Island. They have so many flavors that I can’t really choose one.

I always love getting my ice cream from here. It's delicious and fresh.

Delicious ice-cream and friendly staff. A must have if you're around this area.

My fave spot recently. Love the Central Perk ice cream. Also enjoyed some Cookie Monster ice cream.

Always amazing, very best home-made ice cream! A great local business and everyone is so friendly!

I usually feel very "stanky" against this establishment because they can be cheap and overpriced (this is the closest to me to hit that icecream spot.....), but today they screwed up on my banana split and made it right no problems. I am 100% for customer service and righting your wrongs. The ladies that handled it were great I was on "stanky" when I called because of the money I spent. I will be back because I know if I have an issue my patronage will be respected. This occured around 9:30pm today, thank you ladies for being so pleasant in the face of an upset customer!

This is such amazing ice cream! Better than any other ice cream place! The service is amazing, the ice cream hit different, and the people working there are amazing! Worth the travel AND the wait ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Great ice cream, the service was wonderful! Homemade Ice Cream with different special flavors!

After driving past this place for years,finally stopped and bought some ice cream. OMG! There is no other ice cream store like this one! Fantastic flavors! Incredible ice cream! My favorite was the banana!

There is so many flavor to choose from n there ice cream is amazing. The customer service is great to. It was worth the drive

I love this place! My favorite ice cream spot. We love their ice cream pies!

Great ice cream at not horrid prices.