It's me Calogero with another review , So Me and my girlfriend went to Went to Sbarro in DeerPark on Rt 231 and had dinner and appetizers here, First we had Stuffed Mushrooms (so good) and also Fried Calamari (excellent) and for dinner I had the Shrimp Scampi (Omg so good) and she had the Lobster Ravioli.( So so good ) and the manager Antonio was so nice he gave us both a complementry glass of wine and the service we got from the server Amanda was incredible she was so sweet. So I am definitely giving this food and service 2 thumbs up and 5 stars. ####################### Ok so I went to Mamma's Brick Oven Pizza because I was craving pizza and when I walked in they have this beautiful display of all these different slices and I couldn't make up my mind so one of the managers Nicole came over and says can I help you cuz you look undecided and I said yeah what could you recommend and she said try the Vodka slice and the spinach slice and I got to tell you that was a great recommendation because they were both to die for and she was so sweet she offered another recommendation which was the Sicilian slice and oh my God that was fantastic and I got to tell you I could have eaten one of every slice in the display case because everything looks so delicious and everybody so nice in this restaurant Pizzeria is incredible I give it 2thumbs up and 5 stars once again (oh...and the slices are huge) and today's date is June 11th 2022

Burnt pizza. Like black air pockets and black crust on bottom. Delivery was over an hour. Pizza was barely warm. There’s way too many pizza places around here to chose from. Not a good thing for a bad pizza experience, too easy to go somewhere else

These guys are great... it was my friend bday... we got a late start and walked in to mama's. The staff were unbelievably kind. They were just closing and still let us sit and have some quality time. The food is great. Nicole, Lenny, Jordan, and Raul were so friendly and fun. What a great local friendly homey place. The food is outstanding too. Can't give enough stars

never been here before ! really good pizza soild silician slices ! will be back ! 🍻 👏 ✌️

Had both the regular and the Sicilian. Did not like either. The regular was meh. The Sicilian's crust was too greasy, and the tomatoes tasted canned. They do not sell Coke-only Pepsi, Sierra Mist and other brands. They do not take Apple Pay, only cash or card. I do not recommend.

Not just a pizza takeout, it looks pretty cozy with bread on tables of patrons, table cloths on their tables, portraits on walls and actual plates for your pizza. Definitely worth stopping by

Outstanding food.... the staff is like family. Thanks Nicole, lenny, Jordan and Raul for a great night

Great food! Great service! Casual atmosphere. Monday night is Pasta Night - choice of pasta with salad and garlic knots for $9.99. The tortellini soup is excellent! The spinach Alfredo pizza is incredible! The chicken parmigiana hero is my favorite! If you're in the Deer Park / Babylon area give them a try! UPDATES: There is a new owner. They now offer free delivery. Pasta Night is now $10.99 but you get coffee and dessert (cannoli chips). There are several new additions to the menu including a delicious tilapia oreganata. It comes with shrimp and either roasted potatoes or vegetable. I highly recommend the roasted potatoes! New craft beer selection including Sam Adams Winter and Lagunitas IPA.

A great place for a quick bite or a full corse Dinner. The parking is always great. Everything my family and I have tried so far has been on the money!!! The Employees are respectful, attentive and always make us/me feel welcomed. You have become our Go-to In the Neighborhood. Happy Holidays to the whole crew!!!!!!

This is one of our favorite Italian restaurants in the town. Their chicken Parm, eggplant parm are so yummy, my kids loved it.

Pizza is not bad but not great either. No crisp or crunch to the crust and the sauce is a bit too sweet. For flavor, go with the sausage slice.

Great Pizza, great food and great service. Amanda took good care of our large party of 25

The pizza is just ok. Not nearly as good as the prior place. The crust has no crunch to it and overall could have more flavor. My big issue is I've gone here for take-out a few times now since they changed names and every time we have gotten some slices to go, they are cold!! Someone in charge needs to show the woman working the evenings behind the counter how to properly heat up pizza. Knowing this has happened to us in the past, yesterday I specifically told her to make it hot! By the time I got home (a mile away) it was barely lukewarm and we had to reheat in our oven again!

I've been coming here for years, everyone is so friendly and welcoming. There food is amazing!! It's our go to Pizzaria and restaurant !!

Food was amazing, the dining room looks very nice to have dinner. Slices are not that big but they’re filled with the toppings so I think it’s worth it.

This is one of my favorite pizza/Restaurants! I've been coming here for years, I've eaten many things on the menu Never Disappointed! Everything is fresh and delicious 😋 We get delivery sometimes and I use them for catering parties. Everyone Raves about the food!

I ordered 2 sicilian slice and 1 grandma. They gave me old and over cooked sicilian slice that were cold and grandma slice that looks exactly the same as Sicilians. The pizza was cold and looks like they were sitting in their display all day. I went back to the store and told her these are old, cold and dry the response I get is “that what their Sicilians looks like”. I switched it for 3 plain slices which were also cold. Don’t waste your time here. Go to Pizzaiola where pizza is way better and they don’t sell your left overs.

My go to pizza place with the family!! Nicole is the best she’s always so pleasant! Food is delicious and always quick!

Nice family Italian restaurant. Definitely more then a pizza parlor. Very affordable, warm cozy atmosphere. 11/22. I have a feeling something has changed here. Last two experiences not so great. Calzone served just warm, cheese wasn't melted. Linguine with Alfredo sauce, sauce broke and curdled.

I fell in love with this pizzeria the appearance the aviance they make you feel like family and the food is delish oh my God they actually have captured the taste and the culture this is the closest I can get to Italy the food is phenomenal

Love the Pizza here, the Grandma pie is excellent. I drive all the way from Bellmore just for their Grandma pie. The only pizza that needs a bit of important is the Buffalo chicken. I highly recommend.

Just wanted to say I live in Nassau County and work in North Babylon and I was worried about getting great Pizza and Food until I stumbled across Mamas… The pizza is awesome and made with pride and Great Gourmet Slices and the Food is excellent. 💪 The GM Antonio and the staff are always on point and super accommodating! Definitely check this place out!!!

My family and I go to Mama’s pizza atleast once a week and it’s always excellent. Pizza is always fresh and the staff are wonderful. The Brickoven slice is really delicious.

We came here for our anniversary dinner and our experience was 10/10. From the welcoming, friendly staff to the mouth-watering food and top notch deserts! Mama’s is a great little gem and I will definitely be a new “regular”.

I had The most delicious meal and amazing experience tonight! I had The most delicious baked clams as an appetizer and for my entree I had linguine marinara with shrimp and clams. The service was great, friendly and very engaging! I highly recommend this gem! I cant Wait to go back! 🔤⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Always a pleasant experience here! The counter girls are always so helpful and always suggest new things to try. Always come on mondays when the 2 managers are there and they always make my day. I never write reviews but this place is definitely a place to rave about!

I went to Moma's today and I had a really great spinach pizza that tasted so good. The crust was perfectly chrispy and the topping was amazing! If You like chips dipped in a spinach dip you are going to like Moma's Spinach slice. The spinach slice was creamy rich and was very likely the best pizza topping I have in quite a long time. As far as I'm concerned, this Pizza Shop is a well kept secret. I will definitely be back for another visit and I definitely recommend that anyone reading this give Moma's a try. It's on the Southeast corner of the intersection of Deer Park Ave (Route 231) and Bay Shore Road.

$19.54 for a large pie? The box was a size bigger Then the pizza. No flavor and not much cheese. Not a very good pizza. Middle of the toad at best. Years ago was a different story. I just read Marcos review and he is spot on! So true.

I love this place!! I have a gluten allergy and they go above and beyond to accommodate my needs every time. Nicole is always so helpful and I end up trying new things because of her! Perfect date night spot for my boyfriend and I