First off this Pizzeria is inside an OK Petroleum Gas Station! The owner is a very nice guy and a real gentleman! Not withstanding that his pizza is off the charts!!! I tried 3 types of pizza: 1) Regular 2) Margherita 3) White I say without hesitation that all 3 types were phenomenal. I actually drove 20 minutes to come try their pizza because of their Google reviews and I'm happy I did! Definitely a place to pick up a few pies when having a get together. Hands down it beats the 6 or 7 Pizzeria's in my immediate area!

At first you’re like, this is better than any gas statiom pizza has a right to be. Then you’re like, that’s unfair, because that low expectations. Then you’re like, This is great pizza for ANYWHERE! I really like the grandma and the Sicilian.

Best Pizza around hands down. The energy you get as your looking at what to get is amazing. The staff working here is one of a kind and the family recipe makes the pizza taste savor in your mouth. You walk into a gas station to get lotto tickets or a bottle of water and end up leaving with 2 boxes of pizza because its just so good. Shoutout this hidden gem because word to mother its fire no cap.

Has to be the best pizza in town with a very friendly staff serving pizza right in front of you. Prices are very reasonable and staff is very nice. I stopped to get some lottery tickets and couldn’t resist the smell so it made me try a slice and I ended up bringing 3 pies to my kids and wife at home who also loved it. I’m very picky with food and this is most far the best pizza store I’ve went to. When you take a bite you get that nice crunchy taste and you know it’s some high quality bread not cheap stuff. I definitely recommend this pizza store. Can’t beat the prices and the friendly staff and will always be coming to this pizza store almost everyday. Also forgot to mention how clean and nice the place looks. It’s cleaner than any other pizza store I’ve been to. I highly recommend you to try it out and than prove me right on how good it taste and how great the quality of the pizza is.

Let me tell you I thought it was gonna any average pizza store but there isn’t anything average about the pizza. Just the plain pizza pie was above and beyond. Highly recommend Bonillas pizza

This pizza is so good! Good price too. I was surprised when I saw that it was in a Gas station. Don’t let that stop you from going in and getting a slice!!! Just a random stop totally worth every bite. I love that it’s perfect sauce and crust literally just enough crunch and chew.

Best cheese slice I had in awhile. Crust was thin, crunchy and a little bit charred on the bottom. Just how I like it. I also had Grandma slice and it was also good. The place is located in a gas station and I did not see any tables so it is take out only I think. Definitely will be back.

My brother told me about this place and I’ve been ordering from them ever since! The garlic knots are so good and always taste fresh. I ordered a grilled chicken Cesar slice and a chicken bacon ranch and enjoyed both! I never had a overly greasy slice from here. Definitely give it a try!

Great pizza. Very comfortable, nicely put together. The ambiance is warm & welcoming.

Al is great. The pizza is amazing. I catered a birthday party through them and everyone said the chicken cutlet parmigiana was the best they’ve ever had. I agree. You can’t go wrong here. Everything is fresh and delicious. Don’t let the gas station stop you from making this place your go to. They are completely separate.

Amazing pizza! I was amazed at how great the customer service was! The pizza had the perfect amount of everything! Kitchen was clean, Definitely recommend!

Pizza 💋 Chicken BBQ w. Sesame Crust - Side 💋 Sauteed garlic Spinach 👍🏾 Doordash available and I suggest you don't use your credit card over the📱.

The pizza was good as always. It's just that everyone gets a warm greeting except for me. However little is best besides brooklyn pizza

Their pizza sauce and crispy crust is amazing. The perfect tangyness along with a soft yet crunch to the crust is winning combination. I’ve ordered at least 4 time and each time hands down this remind of what a perfect NY style pizza should be. I just ordered a pie and with the first bite my eyes rolled up ecstasy. The pizza store in a gas station might throw some people off but don’t judge a book by it’s cover. Don’t wait, just order!

Tried it because it was recommended by a friend even though I was like really it’s in a gas station ? I have to say it was very good and very reasonable with their prices. I would definitely go back .

This pizza place has renewed my faith in humanity. GREAT staff, DELICIOUS pizza, REASONABLE prices, CLEAN kitchen. AND I don’t have to cook it. A win, all the way around. Don’t judge this book by its cover!!!!

I have been going to that pizzeria ever since it opened 5 STARS

Friendly people yummy pizza and delicious pasta I highly recommend one with shrimp and chicken broccoli spinach mushroom and pink sauce over linguine pasta 😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋😋

Just OK pizza. It's part of a gas station / convenience store.....so take that into consideration and adjust your expectations accordingly.

Bonilla pizzeria Great food, excellent customer service, they always greet you with a smile establishment very clean 👍🏽

Absolutely delicious pizza. Their grandma ala Vodka is one of the best I've ever had, and prices are reasonable as hell too.

They are really good in terms of cleanliness, food quality, service and prices. I highly recommend everyone giving this pizzeria a try. Staff is very friendly and assisted me as soon as i came in. Very good energy and customer service shown.

It's located in the renovated gas station store. I like the pizza and their various specials are good! I get gas and I get food. A nice little spot.

I work 15 minutes away from Bonillas Pizza and I pass atleast 3 pizzerias on my way but my Team only wants Bonillas Pizza from now on! They've proven time after time that being located in a gas station doesn't mean a damn thing, but that they're facing adversity with 5 star family recipes and service with their Pizza Pies to Gourmet Salads and everything in between. I hope I see more of Bonillas Pizza's in every OK Petroleum gas station on Long Island, PERIOD

Ordered a neapolitan pizza. I was craving it for days after I had consumed it. Amazing pizza!!