Featured Reviews


Frequently mentioned in reviews: flavors (11) delicious (11) chocolate (9) time (9) pies (8) shop (7) good (6) Babylon (6) flavor (6) peanut (6)
Reviews are sorted by relevance, prioritizing the most helpful and insightful feedback at the top for easier reference.
  • 5/5 Cee G. 2 years ago on Google
    Seriously one of the best homemade desserts. I always was off with timing when In the area, but luckily got there early, before our dinner reservation and ordered 4 different flavors: fig crumb, chocolate PB, PB campfire & death by chocolate. I can’t even pick a favorite because each tasted better than the next. The owner was super nice and look forward to going back 😍
    3 people found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Danielle P. 9 months ago on Google • 137 reviews
    Delicious ! Every pie was so good. Flavors were on point and it was the perfect amount of cream in each one. Highly recommend !
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Zach C. 1 year ago on Google • 129 reviews
    I've only been here twice so far, but I'm so glad I finally went. I've followed them on Instagram for a while, but finally found the store when I was walking around Babylon. I didn't take any pictures the first time because I immediately ate the pie I bought. Second time I got 6 total with my dad. My pictures include: death by chocolate, red velvet, original, cookies and cream and lemon poppy. All of the ones I have tasted have been incredible and I can't wait to go back to try other flavors that rotate in and out.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 K O. 11 months ago on Google • 222 reviews
    Espresso pie is amazing, not too sweet and lots of espresso flavor. Chocolate peanut butter pie was delicious. Tasted like a pie version of peanut butter cups. Friendly staff and couldn't believe we caught them open. Only open Thursday Friday and Saturday 12pm - 6pm. Well worth the wait.

  • 5/5 john K. 3 months ago on Google • 34 reviews New
    We love shugaaaaaaa pies. Babylons secret weapon that’s tasty for your palette. Crazy varieties at suga pies in Babylon. Check out Gizelle And Terry the artist behind the taste. I guarantee you will not be disappointed it will blow your mind soon as you take that first bite.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Benny Y. 2 years ago on Google
    OMG!! Are used desserts are in a category which I call Ridiculous!! These deserts are so good, You could probably get addicted to them. I am a huge peanut butter and chocolate fan so that’s what I get every time they go there. But one time I was going there to bring dessert for a party I was going to, so I bought different kinds and flavors. Of course you want course you wanna make everybody happy when you’re a guest and you are bringing some thing. So I got the peanut butter with the chocolate, I got one that was cookies and cream, I got one that was death by chocolate, during Christmas time they had one that had crushed up candy cane in it they gave it a mint flavor as well. And the list goes on and on with the amount of flavors that they have. Right over there in the heart of Babylon Village on Deer Park Ave. in between the alleyway of fitness incentive and swell taco. Trust me, you won’t be disappointed. Just make sure you got some either cold milk or cold almond or oat milk to go with it. And the coffee too of course! 🤙🏼👍🏼😁
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Numbahz 2 years ago on Google
    Just got to enjoy one of the OG vegan Shuga Pie I bought from Cindysnacks in Huntington! So awesome to see these products there and Def would get again or make my way to Babylon soon cause these r YUMM
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 dana b. 2 years ago on Google
    This place is out of this world. I think I am turning into a shuga pie with how many I eat! Good thing they’re only open 3 days a week or else it’d be dangerous… have tried a different flavor each visit and have never been disappointed. Delicious, delectable treats that fit right between your hands!!! Shuga pie shop is the perfect dessert!
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 5/5 Justin B. 5 years ago on Google
    Amazing little shop. Everything they make is delicious. Michelin and Terry are amazing and always take time to speak with us (and our dog Rex) and make us feel welcomed and right at home. A hidden secret that you need to visit. It's one of our favorite places, and definitely Rex's favorite.
    1 person found this review helpful 👍

  • 4/5 Julie 2 months ago on Google • 74 reviews New
    Stopped by, they do not have a shop it is just a walk up window. The cakes were very good, texture and flavor were good and they have a wide selection. They are basically a flat cupcake. Something different and fun to give as gifts. I will say that I wish that they had bite size options but maybe in the future? They should do well.

  • 5/5 Katie L. 6 months ago on Google • 29 reviews
    Very nice owner & delicious dessert! These Shuga pies also happen to be vegan which is nice. Sweet little treats- I had the cinnamon roll, death by chocolate and lemon poppy. All were 10/10 with great favor and perfect ratio of filling and cake!

  • 5/5 pete z. 1 month ago on Google • 22 reviews New
    Finally got to stop here today. And let me say…What a treat!!! Taking something classic like a “whoopie pie” and just re-inventing it so damn well!! Moist Cake, creamy delicious filling, not over filled and hard to eat either.! Service was great and fast. It’s just a walk up window with the list of flavors. And as we were leaving with our order more and more people were lining up. Can’t wait to try the other flavors!!! Pictured : funfetti, choc peanut butter and cookies n cream!

  • 5/5 Avery 2 months ago on Google • 11 reviews New
    Delicious whoopie pies in various different flavours! The quality is always the same. You wouldn’t know this was vegan!

  • 5/5 Kristina S. 3 months ago on Google • 6 reviews New
    If you want something different for dessert, you have to try a Shuga Pie! These little cakes are heavenly. So many flavors to choose from! Love this place!

  • 5/5 Andrea B. 1 year ago on Google
    Delicious treats! So many different flavor options. We had the Creamsicle and the marble peanut butter. Both were yummy! We will definitely be back for more.

  • 5/5 G L. 2 months ago on Google • 5 reviews New
    The absolute best take on a whoopie pie I’ve ever had! Incredible rotating flavors that include seasonal options like pumpkin or smores. Every flavor I’ve had has been delicious. Fresh fruit and crumb topped are some of my favorites. Chocolate Whiskey espresso was pretty amazing. The owners are so kind and inventive. Love stopping anytime we’re in the area. We buy extra and freeze them same day. They stay fluffy when defrosted. Pro tip: You can order bigger ones to replace cakes and I highly recommend.

  • 5/5 Geraldine M. 2 years ago on Google
    Amazing experience for my mouth. Everyone in the family loved it. I'm glad it's a bit of a drive for me or else I would be 700 lbs. I tried to go a few weeks back around one but the line was so long so I left. Today, I got there at 4:15 and there was no wait.

  • 5/5 Mordechai G. 1 year ago on Google
    This little charming hole in the wall deserves 10 stars. We tried three different pies, and they were all so delicious! It was our first time visiting, and the person working there was very patient, explaining everything and giving some personal recommendations. Do yourself a favor and try this place out.

  • 5/5 Donnamarie H. 1 year ago on Google
    First time here and I bought the vanilla chocolate chip and the cinnamon roll!!! Both delicious!!

  • 5/5 Nick T. 1 year ago on Google
    Totally worth waiting on line before they sell out! 100% vegan unbelievably delicious. Unique flavors options always fresh. Owners are wonderful!

  • 5/5 Jessie S. 1 year ago on Google
    I've been going here since I moved to Long Island about 2.5 years ago and they were at the other shop, but never wrote a review. Their shuga pies are so good that everybody in the family is obsessed, vegan or not. It all started when my sister got me a phenomenal chocolate crumb cake from their former storefront for my birthday a few years back and I was amazed. The pistachio shuga pie is my favorite, but the flavors are creative and always delicious. Their service is exceptional, friendly and warm, and I wish them nothing but continued success. We're already planning to buy a boatload of shuga pies for when we move away so we can have some stashed in the freezer, that's how good they are.

  • 5/5 Omar P. 3 years ago on Google
    This Place is amazing. Has the cherry crumb, it was delicious. Would Highly recommend. Owners are extremely pleasant on the phone and in person.

  • 5/5 Randy G. 1 year ago on Google
    This place is worth the hype! Delicious treats and I love trying new flavors every time. YUM

  • 5/5 Mary Donnelly A. 2 years ago on Google
    I’m not one who craves sweets, and you’re more likely to find me in the cheese shop than in a bakery, but I just happened to be in Babylon Village yesterday and I noticed that the Shuga Pie shop was open with no line. It was almost as if the universe was speaking to me… I selected four pies to take home and ate one of them in the car! They are absolutely delicious, filling, and beyond reasonably priced! No surprise that there are consistent five star reviews for the shop. Kudos to the owners for bringing their talents to Babylon! I will definitely be back for more.


Call +1 631-669-1069 Open on Google Maps

Amenities


  • Payments
    • ✓️ Debit cards
    • ✓️ Credit cards
    • ✓️ NFC mobile payments
  • Accessibility
    • ✓️ Wheelchair-accessible car park
  • Service options
    • ✓️ Delivery
    • ✓️ Takeaway
    • ✓️ In-store pick-up
    • ✓️ In-store shopping
    • ✓️ Same-day delivery

Trends



Last updated:

Similar Dessert shops nearby

Kilwins Babylon VIllage image
1
Kilwins Babylon VIllage
Ice cream shop
Traditional store selling chocolates, confections & fudge, as well as original recipe ice cream.
$$ $$
4.20 (151 reviews)
Sweet Sensations image
2
Sweet Sensations
Ice cream shop
👍👍 Sweet sensations has SOO many options. We went because they have VEGAN ice cream. You can see in the pictures they have dozens of flavors. They also have icees frozen yogurt candy smoothies and soft serve everything!
$ $$$
4.20 (97 reviews)
Last updated:
()