Newly opened, everything is brand new and obviously very clean. A little dark inside but we sat by the window, it was a nice atmosphere. Staff is very friendly and the food is excellent and reasonably priced. Great for the locals that crave the "Old Judge" pizza!!! Plenty of seating, a nice variety on the menu. The paper tablecover is, I'm sure convenient, but we found it awkward. I will definitely be back and recommend you to go! I've already spread the word verbally as well. . Update: they added lighting and cut the paper table top more suitable. Introduced the place to some friends that have pizza and mussels once a week from another local place, they are committed to changing they enjoyed it so much. I actually moved to Florida but visit this area several times a year, I will always make sure this is one of my stops! All the food is excellent. Nice, clean, comfortable place to visit with friends, have a cold beer and good food! Several big screens around to watch the games too!! Update 10/2023 I've been hearing a lot of complaints regarding the service, mainly getting orders wrong. I've experienced it myself as well. However, I have no complaints with my recent visit.. New visit, wasn't too impressed this trip. Food wasn't great, I'll stick to pizza here.

I tried to give this place a chance multiple times but this order was the last one for me. I ordered a SALAMI and cheese stromboli not only was I charged extra for cheese which is supposed to already come inside a stromboli but they also gave me the wrong meat inside, I called to let them know and was told I was wrong that the meat is 100% salami and not ham but clearly, this is ham and tastes like ham. Ive never had a salami stromboli look or taste like this before ever. Also ordered a sicilian slice of pizza which I had to load with garlic because there was absolutely no flavor at all, and what exactly is this $1 misc food charge and I never received my soda that I paid for. Ridiculous, over $20 for this meal waste of money.

I remembered the Old Judge when I was a kid, great family place! Now 60 years later, was excited to see the Old Judge back again! The new place is really nice, and spotlessly clean. The wait staff is young, friendly, and attentive. The food was delicious, from the stuffed mushrooms, to the pizza. Had the "Old Judge" last week, it was super thin and tasty. Tried the regular large pie this week, was very good, but preferred the Old Judge. The only reason I didn't give 5 stars was the Beer prices. $6 for a Coors Light bottle is quite high for this area. I frequent many local places, and the most I pay is $5. Not a big deal, but I'll be drinking soda on my next visit.

From the inside the place is clean, but seems strangely (dis)organized. From the outside, the dark window treatments make the place look like an adult entertainment café which had me sitting in the parking lot for 5 minutes trying to figure out if I was at the right place. There were no other customers just after lunch hour, on a heavily trafficked Street. Staff was very nice and polite! The pizza slices I ordered to go were OK. I would have a hard time going the 10 minutes out of my way for a return trip. Pizza Crust and sauce was good, cheese just a bit too thick and chewy. I can't speak on the rest of the food, it looks good, but I wanted to try the place based on an Instagram reel highlighting the business. Perhaps the place is more lively as a Cafe after or during dinner. You'll have to see for yourself.

Let me start by the portions was more then enough. I think I tried every pizza they had. Literally watched every game on Sunday and left 15 pounds heavier lol. The staff too notch. The atmosphere was friendly and family oriented. I’ll definitely be back and will recommend to my friends. See you guys this Sunday!!

Finally got to try the Old Judge Style pie and it was phenomenal! The sauce is definitely the star on this pie, as well as the thin crust. Whatever brand evoo they use really shines through. Very, very delicious! Can't wait to explore the rest of the menu!

Great place to celebrate my 49th birthday. First time there, but definitely not our last. Great crowd, service and DJ. Very clean and just an overall good time. Looks like a great place to stop in for a drink, but if your hungry you will be pleased with the menu.

Excellent pizza and Italian food. The old judge pie is my favorite! my family orders from here weekly & they always deliver perfectly. Highly recommend for a great place for drinks also

Sabrina was an amazing waitress. She accommodated our huge party of 15+ people for my son’s birthday. The food was over the top amazing Entertainment top notch. So much fun. Can’t wait to come back!

Really neat spot! My coworker and I split a Large Old Judge with Bacon each week, and it's a fantastic pizza. Good friendly staff, neat atmosphere, and you can draw on the tables!

ANAZING vibes and energy here, everyone's so welcoming and it's very spacious and the music is 25/10. Classic songs and wednesday movie nights WITH a pasta buffet selection! Sabrina was so kind and generous the whole time we stayed and the food itself tastes delicious. Penne vodka taste just like my favorite spot in the city but this one is closer to home :) Thank you guys sm!!!

Food is great. Pizza is cooked crispy and has a thin crust. Our server Sabrina was attentive and nice. Definitely try the old bay wings.

Stopped in for lunch let me tell you best pizza I’ve had in a while . The old judge is amazing . The place is clean and the atmosphere is great . I had amazing service by a young lady named Angela she was great . Loved this place and will definitely be returning!

My children love the pizza. The service is always great. Sabrina is accomodating and professional. The delivery drivers are polite and patient. The delivery times are extremely reasonable. Wish I could give more stars.

A friend of mine recommended this place. I went with my sun for brunch and watch some football. My son says dad don’t tell Nonna but this Chicken Alfredo is good. I tasted the famous judge pizza omg. Top 5 on my taste pallet. Definitely be back for a full Sunday of football I loved the atmosphere. I had strangers buying me drinks because I was. Cowboys fan lol.

Drove past this place few times on my lunch break, decided to order for pick up today. I ordered the Grilled Chicken and Vodka sauce pie, it was phenomenal! I was helped by this very pretty lady named Angelena who was super nice,hope to see her again. The place itself was slow when I walked in (12:15) but they open at 11 so it was expected, very nice bar and lounge area.

Was looking for some decent pizza because i cant seem to find any around the area, Glad that i ran into this place because the pizza was delicious. Perfect crust and sauce. Good size and delicious. Gonna start making it my regular take out pizza spot!

Place is just fantastic if I could I would blow every last bit of my gambling money on this fine establishment the pizza is just outstanding and the perfect size for each slice. They also have a bar and all of the staff is very kind and respectful especially this kid who looks like he reads about greek mythology and walks like he is in some sort of sigma edit named Pasquale or sometimes Pat. Great place would recommend to anybody!